Abstract:Background and Context. Metacognitive skills are important for all students learning to program and interest in applying pedagogical approaches in early programming courses that focus on metacognitive aspects is growing. However, most studies of such approaches are not rigorously based in theory, and when they are, almost always utilize foundational education and psychology theories from as far back as the 1970s. More recent theory is less tested, and not all relevant metacognitive theories have been explored in the computing education research literature. Objectives. We present the first use in a programming education context of a newer metacognitive theory that explicitly examines the differences between self-regulation, co-regulation, and socially shared regulation. Our research questions are: 1) How do students express their learning strategies, both when working alone and when working in groups, and how do these align with existing models of self-regulation and co-regulation? and 2) To what extent do written expressions of self-regulation, co-regulation, and socially shared regulation relate to student performance? Methods. Grounded in the above mentioned theory, we collected qualitative self-reflection and quantitative course performance data from nearly 1,000 students in an introductory programming course. We use these data to explore students’ self-regulation habits when studying alone and their co-regulation habits when studying in groups. Findings. Our findings indicate that higher self-regulation correlates with higher performance, but higher co-regulation had the opposite effect. We explore these differences through a qualitative analysis of the self-reflection statements and identify co-regulation strategies to build upon existing models of self-regulation. Implications. We identify emergent themes in our data that align with those in recent literature in self-regulated learning in computing education and present the first set of co-regulation themes in computing education. This work is at the frontier of self- and co-regulation in introductory programming and identifies several factors that can be used to advance future work and, most importantly, improve student outcomes.

Educating Programmers: A Reflection on Barriers to Deliberate Practice

Practical thinking in programming education

What Do We Think We Think We Are Doing?: Metacognition and Self-Regulation in Programming.

Learning and Teaching Programming: A Review and Discussion

Metacognition and Self-Regulation in Programming Education: Theories and Exemplars of Use

Understanding Growth Mindset Practices in an Introductory Physical Computing Classroom: High School Students' Engagement with Debugging by Design Activities

Public Engagement in Action: Developing an Introductory Programming Module for Apprentices

Getting by with Help from My Friends: Group Study in Introductory Programming Understood As Socially Shared Regulation

A Pedagogical Framework for Teaching Computer Programming: A Social Constructivist and Cognitive Load Theory Approach

Square Pegs and Round Holes: Pedagogy for Autistic Students in Computing Education

Improving software practice through education: Challenges and future trends

A Closer Look at Metacognitive Scaffolding: Solving Test Cases Before Programming

Thinking beyond chatbots' threat to education: Visualizations to elucidate the writing and coding process

Parlez-vous Java? Bonjour La Monde != Hello World: Barriers to Programming Language Acquisition for Non-Native English Speakers

Contrasting stances at the crossroads of debugging learning opportunities

Debugging Pathways: Open-Ended Discrepancy Noticing, Causal Reasoning, and Intervening

Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives

More Programming Than Programming: Teaching Formal Methods in a Software Engineering Programme

Novice Programmers and the Problem Description Effect

The Widening Gap: The Benefits and Harms of Generative AI for Novice Programmers

Challenging but Full of Opportunities: Teachers' Perspectives on Programming in Primary Schools