Magnetic field symmetries of nonlinear transport with elastic and inelastic scattering

Salil Bedkihal,Malay Bandyopadhyay,Dvira Segal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.88.155407

2013-07-15

Abstract:We study nonlinear electronic transport symmetries in Aharonov-Bohm interferometers subjected to inelastic scattering effects and show that odd (even) conductance terms are even (odd) in the magnetic field when the junction is (left-right) spatially symmetric. This observation does not hold when an asymmetry is introduced, as we show numerically, but odd conductance terms only manifest a weak breakdown of the magnetic field symmetry. Under elastic dephasing effects, the Onsager-Casimir symmetry is maintained beyond linear response and under spatial asymmetries.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the symmetry problem of nonlinear electron transport in the Aharonov - Bohm (AB) interferometer, especially in the presence of elastic and inelastic scattering effects. Specifically, the author attempts to study the following problems:

1. **Magnetic field symmetry**: When inelastic scattering effects are present, do odd (even) conductance terms still maintain even (odd) magnetic field symmetry?
2. **Phase rigidity**: In spatially symmetric junctions, is there phase rigidity, that is, the symmetry of current with respect to the magnetic field?
3. **Rectification effect**: The behavior of the direct - current rectification current \(R(\phi)\) under different conditions (such as when the magnetic flux is a multiple of \(2\pi k\) or in geometrically symmetric junctions).

### Main research content

- **Elastic dephasing effect**: The author proves that under the elastic dephasing effect, the Onsager - Casimir symmetry is maintained, even in the nonlinear response region and in the case of spatial asymmetry.
- **Inelastic effect**: After introducing the inelastic effect, the author explores the symmetry changes of current and conductance terms in geometrically symmetric and asymmetric junctions.
- **Double - quantum - dot interferometer model**: Through numerical simulation, the nonlinear transport characteristics in the double - quantum - dot interferometer are studied, and the theoretical predictions are verified.

### Key conclusions

1. **Spatially symmetric junctions**:
- The odd - conductance term \(D(\phi)\) is even - symmetric with respect to the magnetic field, that is, \(D(\phi)=D(-\phi)\).
- The rectification current constructed by the even - conductance term \(R(\phi)\) is odd - symmetric with respect to the magnetic field, that is, \(R(\phi)= - R(-\phi)\).

2. **Spatially asymmetric junctions**:
- After introducing spatial asymmetry, the above symmetry relationships are broken, but the odd - conductance term still exhibits a weaker magnetic - field - symmetry breaking.

3. **Experimental verification**:
- These observations are consistent with the experimental data. In particular, in the case of geometric asymmetry, the symmetry of the odd - conductance term is more robust.

### Mathematical expressions

- **Current expansion**:
\[
I(\phi)=G_1(\phi)\Delta\mu+G_2(\phi)(\Delta\mu)^2+G_3(\phi)(\Delta\mu)^3+\cdots
\]
where \(G_n > 1\) are nonlinear conductance coefficients.

- **Symmetry breaking caused by the magnetic field**:
\[
\Delta I(\phi)\equiv\frac{I(\phi)-I(-\phi)}{2}
\]

- **Direct - current rectification current**:
\[
R(\phi)\equiv\frac{1}{2}[I(\phi)+\bar{I}(\phi)] = G_2(\phi)(\Delta\mu)^2+G_4(\phi)(\Delta\mu)^4+\cdots
\]
where \(\bar{I}\) is the current obtained after exchanging the chemical potentials of the two terminals.

Through these studies, the author provides an in - depth understanding of magnetic - field symmetry and phase rigidity in nonlinear transport systems and lays the foundation for further experimental and theoretical research.