Abstract:Differential item functioning (DIF) is an important issue in large scale standardized testing. DIF refers to the unexpected difference in item performances among groups of equally proficient examinees, usually classified by ethnicity or gender. Its presence could seriously affect the validity of inferences drawn from a test. Various statistical methods have been proposed to detect and estimate DIF. This dissertation addresses DIF analysis in the context of computerized adaptive testing (CAT), whose item selection algorithm adapts to the ability level of each individual examinee. In a CAT, a DIF item may be more consequential and more detrimental be cause fewer items are administered in a CAT than in a traditional paper-and-pencil test and because the remaining sequence of items presented to examinees depends in part on their responses to the DIF item. Consequently, an efficient, stable and flexible method to detect and estimate CAT DIF becomes necessary and increasingly important. We propose simultaneous implementations of online calibration and DIF testing. The idea is to perform online calibration of an item of interest separately in the focal and reference groups. Under any specific parametric IRT model, we can use the (online) estimated latent traits as covariates and fit a nonlinear regression model to each of the two groups. Because of the use of the estimated, not the true t, the regression fit has to adjust for the covariate “measurement errors”. It turns out that this situation fits nicely into the framework of nonlinear error-in-variable modelling, which has been extensively studied in statistical literature. We develop two bias-correction methods using asymptotic expansion and conditional score theory. After correcting the bias caused by measurement error, one can perform a significance test to detect DIF with the parameter estimates for different groups. This dissertation also discusses some general techniques to handle measurement error modelling with different IRT models, including the three-parameter normal ogive model and polytomous response models. Several methods of estimating DIF are studied as well. Large sample properties are established to justify the proposed methods. Extensive simulation studies show that the resulting methods perform well in terms of Type-I error rate control, accuracy in estimating DIF and power against both unidirectional and crossing DIF.

Unfair items detection in educational measurement

Unveiling fairness in scoring: a thorough method for precise cutoff score calculation in education assessment

Detecting uniform differential item functioning for continuous response computerized adaptive testing

Test Fairness: Examining Differential Functioning of the Reading Comprehension Section of the GSEEE in China

Using Interpretable Machine Learning for Differential Item Functioning Detection in Psychometric Tests

Fairness Evaluation with Item Response Theory

Make Fairness More Fair: Fair Item Utility Estimation and Exposure Re-Distribution

Evaluation Measures of Individual Item Fairness for Recommender Systems: A Critical Study

Fairness and Unfairness in Binary and Multiclass Classification: Quantifying, Calculating, and Bounding

Metrizing Fairness

Detection of Item Preknowledge Using Likelihood Ratio Test and Score Test

Measurement and Fairness

A Psychometric Framework for Evaluating Fairness in Algorithmic Decision Making: Differential Algorithmic Functioning

Higher-Order Asymptotics and Its Application to Testing the Equality of the Examinee Ability Over Two Sets of Items

Practical Significance of Item Misfit in Educational Assessments

Exploring the Impact of Deleting (or Retaining) a Biased Item: A Procedure Based on Classification Accuracy

Standardized Interpretable Fairness Measures for Continuous Risk Scores

A flexible framework for evaluating user and item fairness in recommender systems

Measuring Non-Expert Comprehension of Machine Learning Fairness Metrics

Classroom assessment fairness inventory: a new instrument to support perceived fairness in classroom assessment

Statistical Detection and Estimation of Differential Item Functioning in Computerized Adaptive Testing