An empirical test for Eurozone contagion using an asset-pricing model with heavy-tailed stochastic volatility

Nicholas G. Polson,James G. Scott

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.5789

2012-03-27

Abstract:This paper proposes an empirical test of financial contagion in European equity markets during the tumultuous period of 2008-2011. Our analysis shows that traditional GARCH and Gaussian stochastic-volatility models are unable to explain two key stylized features of global markets during presumptive contagion periods: shocks to aggregate market volatility can be sudden and explosive, and they are associated with specific directional biases in the cross-section of country-level returns. Our model repairs this deficit by assuming that the random shocks to volatility are heavy-tailed and correlated cross-sectionally, both with each other and with returns. The fundamental conclusion of our analysis is that great care is needed in modeling volatility if one wishes to characterize the relationship between volatility and contagion that is predicted by economic theory. In analyzing daily data, we find evidence for significant contagion effects during the major EU crisis periods of May 2010 and August 2011, where contagion is defined as excess correlation in the residuals from a factor model incorporating global and regional market risk factors. Some of this excess correlation can be explained by quantifying the impact of shocks to aggregate volatility in the cross-section of expected returns - but only, it turns out, if one is extremely careful in accounting for the explosive nature of these shocks. We show that global markets have time-varying cross-sectional sensitivities to these shocks, and that high sensitivities strongly predict periods of financial crisis. Moreover, the pattern of temporal changes in correlation structure between volatility and returns is readily interpretable in terms of the major events of the periods in question.

Statistical Finance,Applications

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is that during the European sovereign debt crisis from 2008 to 2011, the traditional GARCH and Gaussian stochastic volatility models were unable to explain two key features exhibited by the global market during the assumed contagion period: the shocks to overall market volatility can be sudden and explosive, and are related to the cross - sectional directional deviation of returns at the specific country level. The author proposes a new asset - pricing model, which assumes that the stochastic shocks to volatility have a heavy - tailed distribution and are correlated with other volatilities and returns in the cross - section, in order to more accurately describe and explain these phenomena.

Specifically, the paper aims to solve the above problems through the following points:

1. **Model innovation**: A multi - factor model with heavy - tailed stochastic volatility is introduced, which can capture the suddenness and explosiveness of volatility shocks, as well as the specific directional deviation between such shocks and market returns in different countries.

2. **Empirical analysis**: Using daily data, an analysis was carried out for the two major EU crisis periods in May 2010 and August 2011, and a significant contagion effect was found, defined as the excess correlation in the factor - model residuals containing global and regional market risk factors.

3. **Risk factor construction**: Global and regional volatility risk factors are proposed to quantify the impact of volatility shocks on the cross - section of expected returns, and it is shown how to construct these volatility risk factors directly from the time series of market returns.

4. **Predictive ability**: The research shows that the market's sensitivity to these risk factors changes over time, and high sensitivity strongly indicates the approach of a financial crisis period. In addition, volatility shocks have little predictive value during calm periods, but have significant predictive value during market crisis periods.

5. **Statistical method**: A new method for measuring volatility shocks is proposed, which solves the problem of large - scale volatility shocks that cannot be explained by traditional volatility estimators during the recent financial crisis, and the explosive stochastic volatility model is fitted using the particle learning method.

Through these methods, the paper aims to provide a more accurate framework for understanding and quantifying the contagion effect in financial markets, especially during unstable periods such as the European sovereign debt crisis.