Abstract:Run-times of quantum algorithms are often studied via an asymptotic, worst-case analysis. Whilst useful, such a comparison can often fall short: it is not uncommon for algorithms with a large worst-case run-time to end up performing well on instances of practical interest. To remedy this it is necessary to resort to run-time analyses of a more empirical nature, which for sufficiently small input sizes can be performed on a quantum device or a simulation thereof. For larger input sizes, alternative approaches are required. In this paper we consider an approach that combines classical emulation with detailed complexity bounds that include all constants. We simulate quantum algorithms by running classical versions of the sub-routines, whilst simultaneously collecting information about what the run-time of the quantum routine would have been if it were run instead. To do this accurately and efficiently for very large input sizes, we describe an estimation procedure and prove that it obtains upper bounds on the true expected complexity of the quantum algorithms. We apply our method to some simple quantum speedups of classical heuristic algorithms for solving the well-studied MAX-$k$-SAT optimization problem. This requires rigorous bounds (including all constants) on the expected- and worst-case complexities of two important quantum sub-routines: Grover search with an unknown number of marked items, and quantum maximum-finding. These improve upon existing results and might be of broader interest. Amongst other results, we found that the classical heuristic algorithms we studied did not offer significant quantum speedups despite the existence of a theoretical per-step speedup. This suggests that an empirical analysis such as the one we implement in this paper already yields insights beyond those that can be seen by an asymptotic analysis alone.

A quantum no-reflection theorem and the speeding up of Grover's search algorithm

Grover's search algorithm and the quantum measurement problem

Simple exact quantum search

A summary on two new algorithms for Grover's unsorted database search problem

Grover's Algorithm for Multiobject Search in Quantum Computing

Quantifying Grover speed-ups beyond asymptotic analysis

Generalization of Grover's Algorithm to Multiobject Search in Quantum Computing, Part I: Continuous Time and Discrete Time

Analysis and Simulation of Grover’s Search Algorithm

Quantum Severalty: Speed-up and Suppress Effect in Searching Problem

Efficient Implementation of a Quantum Search Algorithm for Arbitrary N

Quantum search algorithm by adiabatic evolution under a priori probability

In Quantum Computing Speedup Illusory?: The False Coin of "Counting Function Evaluations"

On Grover's Search Algorithm from a Quantum Information Geometry Viewpoint

Quantum Advantage of Noisy Grover's Algorithm

A Family of Grover's Quantum Searching Algorithms

Nonexistence of a Universal Quantum Machine to Examine the Precision of Unknown Quantum States

Grover's Algorithm Offers No Quantum Advantage

Towards Entropic Constraints on Quantum Speedups

Using Quantum Switches to Mitigate Noise in Grover's Search Algorithm

Depth optimization of quantum search algorithms beyond Grover's algorithm