Abstract:Categorical data analysis of 2 × 2 contingency tables is extremely common, not least because they provide risk difference, risk ratio, odds ratio, and log odds statistics in medical research. A χ2 test analysis is most often used, although some researchers use likelihood ratio test (LRT) analysis. Does it matter which test is used? A review of the literature, examination of the theoretical foundations, and analyses of simulations and empirical data are used by this paper to argue that only the LRT should be used when we are interested in testing whether the binomial proportions are equal. This so-called test of independence is by far the most popular, meaning the χ2 test is widely misused. By contrast, the χ2 test should be reserved for where the data appear to match too closely a particular hypothesis (e.g., the null hypothesis), where the variance is of interest, and is less than expected. Low variance can be of interest in various scenarios, particularly in investigations of data integrity. Finally, it is argued that the evidential approach provides a consistent and coherent method that avoids the difficulties posed by significance testing. The approach facilitates the calculation of appropriate log likelihood ratios to suit our research aims, whether this is to test the proportions or to test the variance. The conclusions from this paper apply to larger contingency tables, including multi-way tables.

Likelihood ratio type two-sample tests for current status data

Non-parametric Tests for the Tail Equivalence Via Empirical Likelihood

A likelihood ratio test for completed sampling in population size estimation studies

Nonparametric Treatment Comparison for Current Status Data

On the E ffi ciency of Generalized Likelihood Ratio Tests

A Nonparametric Goodness-Of-Fit-Based Test for Conditional Heteroskedasticity

Nonparametric goodness of fit tests for Pareto type-I distribution with complete and censored data

A new class of robust two-sample Wald-type tests

Nonparametric tests for transition probabilities in nonhomogeneous Markov processes

A Class of Two-Sample Nonparametric Tests for Panel Count Data

A nonparametric two-sample conditional distribution test

Testing conditional independence via empirical likelihood

Nonparametric covariate hypothesis tests for the cure rate in mixture cure models

An efficient asymptotic approach for testing monotone proportions assuming an underlying logit based order dose-response model

Log-Rank-Type Tests for Equality of Distributions in High-Dimensional Spaces.

Empirical Likelihood Inference and Goodness-of-fit Test for Logistic Regression Model under Two-Phase Case-Control Sampling

Approximative Tests for the Equality of Two Cumulative Incidence Functions of a Competing Risk

Hazard ratio estimation for two-sample case under interval-censored failure time data.

Nonparametric Estimation of Current Status Data with Dependent Censoring

Empirical Likelihood for the Difference of Two Survival Functions under Right Censorship

Likelihood Ratio Test and the Evidential Approach for 2 × 2 Tables