Observations and Open Questions in Beam-Beam Interaction

Tanaji Sen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1102.2432

2011-02-12

Abstract:A review article on the physics of beam-beam interactions in circular colliders.

Accelerator Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Analytical Estimation of the Beam-Beam Interaction Limited Dynamic Apertures and Lifetimes in e^+e^- Circular Colliders

Jie Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0168-9002%2801%2900239-X

2000-12-22

Abstract:Physically speaking, the delta function like beam-beam nonlinear forces at interaction points (IPs) act as a sum of delta function nonlinear multipoles. By applying the general theory established in ref. 1, in this paper we investigate analytically the beam-beam interaction limited dynamic apertures and the corresponding beam lifetimes for both the round and the flat beams. Relations between the beam-beam limited beam lifetimes and the beam-beam tune shifts are established, which show clearly why experimentally one has always a maximum beam-beam tune shift, \xi_{y, max}, around 0.045 for e-^+e$^- circular colliders, and why one can use round beams to double this value approximately. Comparisons with some machine parameters are given. Finally, we discuss the mechanism of the luminosity reduction due to a definite collision crossing angle.

Accelerator Physics
Simulations and experimental results on beam-beam effects in SuperKEKB

Demin Zhou,Kazuhito Ohmi,Yoshihiro Funakoshi,Yukiyoshi Ohnishi,Yuan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.26.071001

2023-06-05

Abstract:The beam-beam interaction is one of the most critical factors determining the luminosity performance of colliders. As a circular collider utilizing the crab-waist scheme, multiple factors, such as beam-beam, crab waist, impedances, etc., interact to determine the luminosity of SuperKEKB. The interplay of these factors makes it challenging to predict luminosity via simulations. This paper presents recent advances in understanding the luminosity performance of SuperKEKB from beam-beam simulations and experiments. The key aspects affecting the luminosity of SuperKEKB, as well as the areas where further research is needed, are highlighted.

Accelerator Physics
Tune Shifts and Spreads Due to Short and Long Range Beam-Beam Interaction

Wang, L.F.,Zhang, C.,Wang, S.H.,Guo, Z.Y.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/pac.2001.987259

2001-01-01

Abstract:The performance of existing and proposed collider is often limited by the beam-beam interaction. The tune shift and spread from head-on and long-range beam-beam interactions for both round and flat Gaussian beam have been studied with analysis method in this paper. These formulas are useful for multi-bunch colliders where both short-range and long-range beam-beam interactions should be considered.
Beam-Material Interaction

N.V. Mokhov,F. Cerutti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5170/CERN-2016-002.83

2016-08-08

Abstract:Th is paper is motivated by the growing importance of better understanding of the phenomena and consequences of high- intensity energetic particle beam interactions with accelerator, generic target , and detector components. It reviews the principal physical processes of fast-particle interactions with matter, effects in materials under irradiation, materials response, related to component lifetime and performance, simulation techniques, and methods of mitigating the impact of radiation on the components and envir onment in challenging current and future application

Accelerator Physics,Instrumentation and Detectors
Renormalization Group Approach to the Beam-Beam Interaction in Circular Colliders

Stephan I. Tzenov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0106101

2001-06-30

Abstract:Building on the Renormalization Group (RG) method the beam-beam interaction in circular colliders is studied. A regularized symplectic RG beam-beam map, that describes successfully the long-time asymptotic behavior of the original system has been obtained. The integral of motion possessed by the regularized RG map has been used to construct the invariant phase space density (stationary distribution function), and a coupled set of nonlinear integral equations for the distributions of the two colliding beams has been derived.

Accelerator Physics,Pattern Formation and Solitons
Beam Dynamics Issues in the SuperKEKB

Demin Zhou,Haruyo Koiso,Akio Morita,Kazuhito Ohmi,Katsunobu Oide,Hiroshi Sugimoto

2024-01-13

Abstract:This article reviews the beam dynamics issues, such as intra-beam scattering, beam-beam interaction, lattice nonlinearity, and space charge, in SuperKEKB before its commissioning.

Accelerator Physics
Design considerations for colliders using co-moving beams for fusion cross section research

E. Nissen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2024.169158

2024-02-07

Abstract:Collisions between beams moving in the same direction but with different velocities allow for low center of mass energy collisions with higher energy beams. These types of systems lend themselves to fusion interactions since they require low center of mass kinetic energies, but can benefit from higher energies in the constituent beams. Here we cover the design considerations for a machine that could study these types of interactions. We especially highlight reactants that can be stored and collided in a single ring, using a collision timing system known as gear-changing, which could allow for a proof of concept experiment in an existing machine.

physics, particles & fields, nuclear,nuclear science & technology,instruments & instrumentation
Beam-beam Blowup in the presence of x-y coupling sources at FCC-ee

Dima El Khechen,Katsunobu Oide,Frank Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1904.10306

2019-04-23

Abstract:FCC-ee, the lepton version of the Future Circular Collider (FCC), is a 100 Km future machine under study to be built at CERN. It acquires two experiments with a highest beam energy of 182.5 GeV. FCC-ee aims to operate at four different energies, with different luminosities to fulfil physics requirements. Beam-beam effects at such a high energy/luminosity machine are very challenging and require a deep understanding, especially in the presence of x-y coupling sources. Beam-beam effects include the beamstrahlung process, which limits the beam lifetime at high energies, as well as dynamic effects at the Interaction point (IP) which include changes in the beta functions and emittances. In this report, we will define the beam-beam effects and their behaviours in the FCC-ee highest energy lattice after introducing x-y coupling in the ring.

Accelerator Physics
Beam-beam Effects of 'Gear-changing' in Ring-Ring Colliders

Yue Hao,Vladimir N. Litvinenko,Vadim Ptitsyn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevSTAB.17.041001

2013-09-07

Abstract:In ring-ring colliders, the collision frequency determines the bunch structures, e.g. the time between the bunches in both rings should be identical. Because of relatively low relativistic speed of the hadron beam in sub-TeV hadron-hadron- and electron-ions-colliders, scanning the hadron beam's energy would require either a change in the circumference of one of the rings, or a switching of the bunch (harmonic) number in a ring. The later would cause so-called 'gear-changing', i.e. the change of the colliding bunches turn by turn. In this article, we study the difficulties in beam dynamics in this 'gear-changing' scheme.

Accelerator Physics
Backgrounds at future linear colliders

O. Markin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1402.2515

2014-02-11

Abstract:A brief review of the background for experiments at future electron-positron linear colliders is done. Two sources of background are discussed: the beam delivery system and the interaction point. The abundance of background muons, neutrons, photons and electron-positron pairs is quoted for different sub-detectors and both background sources. The background caused by the beamstrahlung is described in more detail. Space distributions are sketched and the impact on calorimeters is discussed for the background neutrons.

Instrumentation and Detectors,High Energy Physics - Experiment
New methods of particle collimation in colliders

Giulio Stancari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1110.0144

2011-10-02

Accelerator Physics

Abstract:The collimation system is an essential part of the design of any high-power accelerator. Its functions include protection of components from accidental and intentional energy deposition, reduction of backgrounds, and beam diagnostics. Conventional multi-stage systems based on scatterers and absorbers offer robust shielding and efficient collection of losses. Two complementary concepts have been proposed to address some of the limitations of conventional systems: channeling and volume reflection in bent crystals and collimation with hollow electron beams. The main focus of this paper is the hollow electron beam collimator, a novel concept based on the interaction of the circulating beam with a 5-keV, magnetically confined, pulsed hollow electron beam in a 2-m-long section of the ring. The electrons enclose the circulating beam, kicking halo particles transversely and leaving the beam core unperturbed. By acting as tunable diffusion enhancer and not as a hard aperture limitation, the hollow electron beam collimator extends conventional collimation systems beyond the intensity limits imposed by tolerable losses. The concept was tested experimentally at the Fermilab Tevatron proton-antiproton collider. Results on the collimation of 980-GeV antiprotons are presented, together with prospects for the future.
Model to study interplay between Beamstrahlung and coupling impedance in future lepton colliders

D. Leshenok,S. Nikitin,M. Zobov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2004.02553

2020-04-06

Abstract:A semi-analytical model has been developed to study a combined effect of Beamstrahlung due to beam-beam interaction and beam coupling impedance in the future lepton colliders CEPC and FCCee. This model allows evaluating an impact of the coupling impedance on the bunch length and energy spread in collision. The model is benchmarked against numerical simulations. Analytical estimates for the supercolliders are presented.

Accelerator Physics
Beam-beam effects in BEPCII

Y. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1410.4057

2014-10-15

Accelerator Physics

Abstract:We first introduce the design parameters of the Beijing Electron-Positron Collider II (BEPCII) and the simulation study of beam-beam effects during the design process of the machine. The main advances since 2007 are briefly introduced and reviewed. The longitudinal feedback system was installed to suppress the coupled bunch instability in January 2010. The horizontal tune decreased from 6.53 to 6.508 during the course of data taken in December, 2010. The saturation of the beam-beam parameter was found in 2011, and the vacuum chambers and magnets near the north crossing point were moved 15 cm in order to mitigate the long range beam-beam interaction. At the beginning of 2013, the beam-beam parameter achieved 0.04 with the new lower $\alpha_{p}$ lattice and the peak luminosity achieved 7 x 10$^{32}$ cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$.
Beam Delivery and Beamstrahlung Considerations for Ultra-High Energy Linear Colliders

Tim Barklow,Spencer Gessner,Mark Hogan,Cho-Kuen Ng,Michael Peskin,Tor Raubenheimer,Glen White,Erik Adli,Gevy Jiawei Cao,Carl A. Lindstrom,Kyrre Sjobak,Sam Barber,Cameron Geddes,Arianna Formenti,Remi Lehe,Carl Schroeder,Davide Terzani,Jeroen van Tilborg,Jean-Luc Vay,Edoardo Zoni,Chris Doss,Michael Litos,Ihar Lobach,John Power,Maximilian Swiatlowski,Luca Fedeli,Henri Vincenti,Thomas Grismayer,Marija Vranic,Wenlong Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-0221/18/09/P09022

2023-05-31

Abstract:As part of the Snowmass'21 community planning excercise, the Advanced Accelerator Concepts (AAC) community proposed future linear colliders with center-of-mass energies up to 15 TeV and luminosities up to 50$\times10^{34}$ cm$^{-2}$s$^{-1}$ in a compact footprint. In addition to being compact, these machines must also be energy efficient. We identify two challenges that must be addressed in the design of these machines. First, the Beam Delivery System (BDS) must not add significant length to the accelerator complex. Second, beam parameters must be chosen to mitigate beamstrahlung effects and maximize the luminosity-per-power of the machine. In this paper, we review advances in plasma lens technology that will help to reduce the length of the BDS system and we detail new Particle-in-Cell simulation studies that will provide insight into beamstrahlung mitigation techniques. We apply our analysis to both $e^+e^-$ and $\gamma\gamma$ colliders.

Accelerator Physics,High Energy Physics - Experiment
Enhanced beam-beam modeling to include longitudinal variation during weak-strong simulation

Derong Xu,Vasiliy S. Morozov,David Sagan,Yue Hao,Yun Luo

2024-06-20

Abstract:Beam-beam interactions pose substantial challenges in the design and operation of circular colliders, significantly affecting their performance. In particular, the weak-strong simulation approach is pivotal for investigating single-particle dynamics during the collider design phase. This paper evaluates the limitations of existing models in weak-strong simulations, noting that while they accurately account for energy changes due to slingshot effects, they fail to incorporate longitudinal coordinate changes ($z$-variation). To address this gap, we introduce two novel transformations that enhance Hirata's original framework by including both $z$-variation and slingshot effect-induced energy changes. Through rigorous mathematical analysis and extensive weak-strong simulation studies, we validate the efficacy of these enhancements in achieving a more precise simulation of beam-beam interactions. Our results reveal that although $z$-variation constitutes a higher-order effect and does not substantially affect the emittance growth rate within the specific design parameters of the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC), the refined model offers improved accuracy, particularly in scenarios involving the interaction between beam-beam effects and other random diffusion processes, as well as in simulations incorporating realistic lattice models.

Accelerator Physics
Beam-beam studies for the High-Energy LHC

K. Ohmi,O. Dominguez,F. Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1108.1871

2011-08-09

Abstract:LHC upgrades are being considered both towards higher luminosity (HL-LHC) and towards higher energy (HE-LHC). In this paper we report initial studies of the beam-beam effects in the HE-LHC [1]. The HE-LHC aims at beam energies of 16.5 TeV, where the transverse emittance decreases due to synchrotron radiation with a 2-hour damping time. As a result of this emittance, shrinkage the beam-beam parameter increases with time, during a physics store. The beam-beam limit in the HE-LHC is explored using computer simulations.

Accelerator Physics
Strong-strong beam-beam simulations with lattices of circular e+e- colliders

Zhiyuan Li,Yuan Zhang,Kazuhito Ohmi,Demin Zhou,Yiwei Wang,Gang Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2024.169386

2024-04-20

Abstract:Strong-strong beam-beam simulations for circular colliders are very time-consuming. Thus far, such simulations have predominantly utilized a linear transfer matrix to represent the full nonlinear lattice. Otherwise, when nonlinear lattices were included, beam-beam interactions were usually studied by using weak-strong or quasi-strong-strong numerical models. The next-generation circular colliders, including FCC-ee at CERN, CEPC in China, and the Super Tau-Charm Factories in China and Russia, will leverage the crab waist collision scheme with a large Piwinski angle. This scheme has already been employed in the two currently operational colliders, DAFNE and SuperKEKB. Accurate predictions of the performance of such colliders call for strong-strong beam-beam simulations, taking into account the interplay of the beam-beam interaction with lattice nonlinearities, beam-coupling impedances, and other collective effects. To answer this call, a novel code APES-T that allows integrating the direct strong-strong beam-beam simulations with element-by-element nonlinear tracking has been developed. To overcome the limitations in computing time, APES-T employs parallelization techniques. Specifically, the beam-beam module is parallelized using MPI programming, while the element-by-element tracking modules are parallelized using GPU programming. In this paper, we present the development of the APES-T code, its benchmark against the SAD code, and its application to the CEPC in investigating the interplay between beam-beam interaction, beamstrahlung, and lattices.

physics, particles & fields, nuclear,nuclear science & technology,instruments & instrumentation
Physics Overview

Yu-Ping Kuang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9905547

1999-05-30

Abstract:Recent developments of physics at the TeV energy scale, especially physics related to the electron-positron linear colliders are briefly reviewed. The topics include the present status of the standard model, Higgs physics, supersymmetry, strongly interacting electroweak symmetry breaking mechanism, and top quark physics.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Theory of Beam Echoes

Tanaji Sen

2024-11-22

Abstract:We develop the theory of beam echoes in circular accelerators under several different conditions. We derive detailed expressions for the echo amplitude and pulse width with nonlinear quadrupole and dipole kicks, first without and then with momentum spread. We use the theory with the linearized dipole and quadrupole kicks to solve the diffusion equation for different dependencies of the diffusion coefficient on the action. We then consider the use of multiple quadrupole kicks to increase the maximum echo amplitude. We have extended these calculations partially to the 2D case and we also have partial results for longitudinal echoes.

Accelerator Physics
Longitudinal Beam Dynamics in Circular Accelerators

Frank Tecker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2011.02932

2020-11-05

Abstract:This paper gives an introduction of longitudinal beam dynamics for circular accelerators. After briefly discussing some types of circular accelerators, it focuses on particle motion in synchrotrons. It summarizes the equations of motion, discusses phase-space matching during beam transfer, and introduces the Hamiltonian of longitudinal motion.

Accelerator Physics

Observations and Open Questions in Beam-Beam Interaction

Analytical Estimation of the Beam-Beam Interaction Limited Dynamic Apertures and Lifetimes in e^+e^- Circular Colliders

Simulations and experimental results on beam-beam effects in SuperKEKB

Tune Shifts and Spreads Due to Short and Long Range Beam-Beam Interaction

Beam-Material Interaction

Renormalization Group Approach to the Beam-Beam Interaction in Circular Colliders

Beam Dynamics Issues in the SuperKEKB

Design considerations for colliders using co-moving beams for fusion cross section research

Beam-beam Blowup in the presence of x-y coupling sources at FCC-ee

Beam-beam Effects of 'Gear-changing' in Ring-Ring Colliders

Backgrounds at future linear colliders

New methods of particle collimation in colliders

Model to study interplay between Beamstrahlung and coupling impedance in future lepton colliders

Beam-beam effects in BEPCII

Beam Delivery and Beamstrahlung Considerations for Ultra-High Energy Linear Colliders

Enhanced beam-beam modeling to include longitudinal variation during weak-strong simulation

Beam-beam studies for the High-Energy LHC

Strong-strong beam-beam simulations with lattices of circular e+e- colliders

Physics Overview

Theory of Beam Echoes

Longitudinal Beam Dynamics in Circular Accelerators