Media in a Crisis Situation Involving National Interest:: A Content Analysis of the TV Networks Coverage of The 9/11 Incident during the First Eight Hours
Laura Lindsay,Liu Xigen,Kirsten Mogensen
2002-08-07
Abstract:A content analysis of coverage of 9/11 incident during the first eight hours examined how five television networks framed the news coverage as events unfolded. Media performed their function in a crisis basically as they were expected and coverage and issues do not vary significantly among the networks. This study found that a variety of sources was used, and the influence of government officials was not as great as in the coverage of a crisis with less involvement of U.S. national interest. Media primarily serve as the sources of accurate information instead of guidance and consolation in the crisis. Human interest was not found to be a dominant frame in the coverage, even though the crisis involved human casualties. Dominant frames were associated with the dominant theme of the incident. The stage of a crisis was an important factor determining the coverage frames. Coverage frames changed over different stages as the unfolding event brought attention to new issues. Introduction On September 11, 2001, continuous television coverage by CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS and FOX News of the most aggressive terrorist attack on America to date began within seconds of the initial plane crash into the North Tower at 8:45 EST. Viewers saw the incident as it unfolded, a national disaster resulting in unimaginable death tolls, destruction of buildings and disruption of normal life processes (Greenberg, Hofschire and Lachlan, 2001). To keep up with the latest development of events, people turned on their televisions and kept them on (The Pew Research Center, 2001). According to one study, 91 percent said television news was a useful source of information about terrorism and 69 percent said it was the most useful source (Stempel and Hargrove, 2001). Another study found that Americans were generally satisfied with the coverage television gave them on that day (The Pew Research Center, 2001; WestGroup Research, 2001). Much research has been devoted to determining how news media frame information so that it affects our understanding and interpretation of issues. The series of events on 9/11 posed a unique opportunity to understand how television networks handled coverage in a situation in which they were thrust without warning, and in some cases, placed in harm’s way. If the general reaction of the public was that television did a good job informing America about the crisis, then the question we wanted to answer was, what did the television media do that responded to the needs of the American viewer during a crisis when the national interest was at stake? We are particularly interested in how the different networks framed the content of television news coverage as events unfolded.
Geography,Political Science