The effect of terrorist events on media portrayals of Islam and Muslims: evidence from New York Times headlines, 1985–2013

Erik Bleich,Hasher Nisar,Rana Abdelhamid

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01419870.2015.1103886

2015-11-05

Ethnic and Racial Studies

Abstract:This article examines whether media portrayals of Islam and Muslims are overwhelmingly negative, whether they have evolved over time, and what factors most consistently affect their tone. We analyse every fourth New York Times headline about Islam or Muslims between 1985 and 2013. We find that headlines have not been predominantly negative. In addition, New York Times headlines about Islam and Muslims have become more positive over the long term, even after the 9/11 attacks. Most counter-intuitively, we find that terrorist attacks have had a systematic positive effect on headline tone. During the first four weeks after each Islamist terrorist attack on an American target, the tone of New York Times headlines became significantly more positive compared to the four weeks prior to the attack. However, over the subsequent few months, coverage reverted back toward the tone that prevailed during the weeks before the event.

sociology,ethnic studies