Abstract:Introduction: Gross anatomy is the first subject to be grasped by budding medicos before learning a long series of skills and competencies required to bloom as a physician or surgeon. In recent years, the teaching time for anatomy has been reduced. The number of anatomy teachers is much less in comparison to the increasing number of students. There is also a paradigm shift in medical education; it has become competency-based, learner-centric, and technology-based. So, anatomical education is also shifting to adopt blended learning strategies. Now, the onus of learning lies more with the students, which can be promoted through self-directed learning (SDL). Many first-year medical students are unprepared for SDL and need assistance understanding SDL. Structured SDL can successfully instill the habit of SDL in young medical students, who are supposed to be lifelong learners in their professional careers. The concept of structured SDL under the supervision of teachers is comparatively new in India. Very few studies are there to compare the effectiveness of SDL with those of traditional teaching methods. The present study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of SDL in learning the gross anatomy of an important viscus, viz., the liver, and to compare it with the effectiveness of the traditional method of teaching by demonstration/prosection. Methods: This interventional comparative study was carried out at the department of anatomy of a government medical college in Kolkata, India. Sixty willing first-year undergraduate medical students were included in the study. The students were divided into two batches (Batch A and Batch B) of 30 each. Students of Batch A were taught the viscus (liver) by the traditional method of teaching by demonstration/prosection for one and a half hours. Validated pre-test and post-test questionnaires were administered to evaluate learning outcomes. Students of Batch B had a structured self-directed learning (SDL) session under the supervision of teachers on the same topic, viz., viscus (liver), for one and a half hours. The pre-test and post-test questionnaires were given before and after the SDL sessions to evaluate learning outcomes. The results were statistically analyzed. Results: It was observed that the mean post-test score after traditional teaching improved significantly compared to the mean pre-test score. Also, the mean post-test score after the SDL session improved significantly compared to the mean pre-test score. It was found that the mean post-test score after exposure to traditional teaching methods was slightly better than the mean post-test scores after exposure to SDL, but this difference was not statistically significant. Conclusion: It can be inferred that structured SDL under the supervision of teachers was almost as good as the traditional teaching method by demonstration/prosection in learning the gross anatomy of an important viscus, viz., liver. In the context of the reduced number of anatomy teachers and an increasing number of students, this may open up an option of teaching some portion of gross anatomy, like a few viscera, by SDL. However, a more robust study with a larger sample size can be more conclusive.

Self Directed Learning: A More Impactful Tool for Learning Tracheostomy by Medical Undergraduate?!

Studying the effectiveness of self-directed education in learning and teaching the otolaryngology module in an integrated-based curriculum

Increasing health care providers' knowledge of tracheostomy and laryngectomy

Standardizing nurse training strategies to improve knowledge and self-efficacy with tracheostomy and laryngectomy care

Mastering tracheostomy care: Refresher programme for tracheostomy training for nurses: Comparison of two training methods based on hands-on simulation-based training alone versus additional complementary self-directed e-learning

A Therapeutic Education Program for patients that underwent at temporary tracheotomy and total laryngectomy: leading to improved the "Diagnostic, Therapeutic and Assistance Path"

Learning Gain During a Fast Self-driven Bronchoscopy Simulation Training: A Preliminary Study Comparing Low and High-fidelity Models

Online learning in thoracic surgical training: promising results of multi-institutional pilot study

Self-Directed Learning Versus Traditional Teaching in Learning Gross Anatomy Among First-Year Medical Students: A Comparative Study

A Simulated Tracheostomy Tube Change Educational Intervention to Promote Competency Among Novice Healthcare Professionals: A Repeated Measures Study

Application of Microteaching Combined with Problem-Based Learning (PBL) Teaching Model in Teaching Clinical Nursing Interns in Otorhinolaryngology Department

The impact of three learning methods on dental students' satisfaction and knowledge acquisition

Self-directed learning for medical graduates: A boon or bane in disguise? A cross-sectional study in Chennai

Effectiveness of error-based active learning compared to conventional lecture-based method among undergraduate dental students: A randomized controlled trial

Module to facilitate self-directed learning among medical undergraduates: Development and implementation

Can surgical skills be taught using technological advances online? A comparative study of online and face-to-face surgical skills training

Improving Emergency Airway Knowledge and Self-Efficacy Levels of Outpatient Gastroenterology Staff via Implementation of Online Education and In Situ Simulation

A Study to Assess the Effectiveness of Planned Teaching Programme on Knowledge and Practice Regarding the Suctioning Techniques among ICU Staff Nurses in Apollo Speciality Hospitals, Nellore - Andhra Pradesh, India

The Student Grand Round: A Peer Teaching Initiative

Improving surgical skills with feedback: directly-observed versus video-recorded practice

Developing and introducing structured cooperative self-directed learning activities for undergraduate medical students