Abstract:A famous conjecture bearing the name of Vandiver states that $p \nmid h_p^+$ in the $p$ - cyclotomic extension of $\Q$. Heuristics arguments of Washington, which have been briefly exposed in Lang (1978), p. 261 and Washington (1996), p. 158 suggest that the Vandiver conjecture should be false if certain conditions of statistical independence are fulfilled. In this note, we assume that Greenberg's conjecture is true for the \nth{p} cyclotomic extensions and prove an elementary consequence of the assumption that Vandiver's conjecture fails for a certain value of $p$: the result indicates that there are deep correlations between this fact and the defect $\lambda^- > i(p)$, where $i(p)$ is like usual the irregularity index of $p$, i.e. the number of Bernoulli numbers $B_{2k} \equiv 0 \bmod p, 1 < k < (p-1)/2$. As a consequence, this result could turn Washington's heuristic arguments, in a certain sense into an argument in favor of Vandiver's conjecture.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of whether Vandiver's conjecture holds. Specifically, Vandiver's conjecture asserts that $h^+_p = 1$ in the $p$-cyclotomic extension. Washington proposed heuristic arguments based on certain assumptions of statistical independence, suggesting that Vandiver's conjecture may not hold. However, the author of this paper, Mihăilescu, by introducing the assumption of Greenberg's conjecture, proved that if Vandiver's conjecture does not hold for a certain value of $p$, then there are deeply related facts, especially related to the defect $\lambda^{-}(p)$.
### Main contributions
1. **Transformation of heuristic arguments**: This paper shows that Washington's heuristic arguments can actually be transformed into arguments supporting Vandiver's conjecture. This is because if Vandiver's conjecture fails, then according to the results in the paper, $\lambda^{-} > i(p)$ must be satisfied, which indicates that the two events are not statistically independent.
2. **Mathematical proof**: The author proved a fundamental theorem, that is, for an odd prime number $p$ with irregularity index $i(p) = 1$, if $h^+_p > 1$, then $\lambda^{-} \geq 2$. This result reveals the correlation between two previously considered independent events.
### Theorem statement
**Theorem 1**: Let $p$ be an odd prime number with irregularity index $i(p) = 1$. If $h^+_p > 1$, then $\lambda^{-} \geq 2$.
### Methods and conclusions
The author reached the above conclusions by detailed analysis of the class group structure in the $p$-cyclotomic extension and the relationship of Iwasawa invariants. This result not only reveals new evidence that Vandiver's conjecture may be true, but also provides a research method that can further explore the potential consequences of the Kummer - Vandiver conjecture.
### Significance
This research provides a new perspective on Vandiver's conjecture and challenges previous heuristic arguments through strict mathematical proofs. Although more research is still needed to directly determine the truth or falsehood of the Kummer - Vandiver conjecture, the results of this paper indicate that it is valuable to consider that Vandiver's conjecture may be true and provide a direction for further research.
### Formula summary
- $h^+_p$: represents the class number of the positive part in the $p$-cyclotomic extension.
- $\lambda^{-}$: represents the Iwasawa invariant of the negative part.
- $i(p)$: represents the irregularity index of $p$, that is, the number of Bernoulli numbers satisfying $B_{2k} \equiv 0 \mod p$, where $1 < k < (p - 1)/2$.
Through these formulas and theorems, the paper deeply explores the class group structure in the $p$-cyclotomic extension and its relationship with Vandiver's conjecture.