Lasma Alberte,Ali H. Chamseddine,Viatcheslav Mukhanov
Abstract:We consider Higgs massive gravity [1,2] and investigate whether a nonlinear ghost in this theory can be avoided. We show that although the theory considered in [10,11] is ghost free in the decoupling limit, the ghost nevertheless reappears in the fourth order away from the decoupling limit. We also demonstrate that there is no direct relation between the value of the Vainshtein scale and the existence of nonlinear ghost. We discuss how massive gravity should be modified to avoid the appearance of the ghost.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to avoid the problem of nonlinear ghosts in the massive gravity theory. Specifically:
1. **Background Introduction**:
- Firstly, the paper introduced the application of the Higgs mechanism in massive gravity, showing how this theory smoothly transitions to general relativity below the Vainshtein radius, thus solving the van Dam, Veltman and Zakharov discontinuity problem.
- It mentioned that the Vainshtein scale depends on the nonlinear extension of the Fierz - Pauli term, and discussed the relationship between actions of different Vainshtein scales and the avoidance of nonlinear ghosts.
2. **Core Problem**:
- Although in some theories, such as those proposed in [10, 11], nonlinear ghosts can be avoided in the decoupling limit, these theories, especially in the fourth - order perturbation theory, will still have nonlinear ghosts when leaving the decoupling limit.
- The main purpose of the paper is to explore whether nonlinear ghosts can be completely avoided in these theories far from the decoupling limit.
3. **Research Method**:
- Through detailed perturbation analysis, especially the analysis of the fourth - order perturbation theory, the author showed the inevitability of nonlinear ghosts.
- By introducing specific scalar field configurations and perturbation expansions, the author calculated in detail the appearance conditions and mass of nonlinear ghosts.
4. **Conclusion**:
- The paper concluded that even when considering higher - order terms, nonlinear ghosts still inevitably appear in the fourth - order perturbation theory.
- This result indicates that the appearance of nonlinear ghosts has no direct relationship with the specific value of the Vainshtein scale.
- The author further discussed how to modify the Higgs massive gravity theory by giving up the "fake Lorentz invariance" in the scalar field configuration space to avoid the appearance of nonlinear ghosts.
5. **Significance**:
- These findings are of great significance for understanding the nonlinear ghost problem in the massive gravity theory, especially in terms of the physical applicability and experimental verification of the theory.
- Through these studies, the author provided new ideas and directions for future massive gravity theories.
In conclusion, through detailed theoretical analysis and calculation, this paper explored the inevitability of nonlinear ghosts in the massive gravity theory and proposed possible solutions. This research has important academic value for deepening the understanding of the massive gravity theory.