Do Computer Simulations Allow a Better Understanding of Basic Electrical Circuits than Real Lab Experiments?

Bjoern S. Schmekel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1001.4395

2010-01-25

Abstract:Several Authors have demonstrated that substituting computer simulations for real experiments conducted in a lab may help to improve students' understanding of the material. In the present work we try to understand the reasons for this intriguing finding and investigate possible prerequisites necessary to achieve this outcome. The study was conducted in an introductory college-level physics class in Germany. All simulations were performed using PSPICE.

Physics Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore whether computer simulations are more suitable than student experiments for improving the understanding of basic circuits. Specifically, the research aims to evaluate whether using computer simulations instead of traditional student experiments can more effectively improve students' understanding of basic circuits in middle school physics teaching. By comparing the effects of the two teaching methods, the research attempts to answer the following core questions:

1. **Can computer simulations provide a better learning experience than traditional experiments?** The research focuses on whether computer simulations can help students understand the basic principles of circuits more in - depth, and whether this understanding is more profound than that obtained through hands - on experiments.
2. **Can computer simulations reduce students' repetitive work and thus improve their learning efficiency?** The research hypothesizes that by reducing the time students spend on experiment preparation and data recording, computer simulations can allow them to have more time to focus on understanding and exploring the working principles of circuits.
3. **Can computer simulations stimulate students' interest in learning and make them participate more actively in classroom activities?** The research also examines whether computer simulations can improve students' participation and enthusiasm, especially when dealing with complex or abstract circuit concepts.
4. **Compared with traditional experiments, can computer simulations better cultivate students' independent thinking and problem - solving abilities?** The research explores whether computer simulations can encourage students to conduct more independent exploration, design and test their own circuit models, rather than just verifying known theories.

Through these specific hypotheses and research objectives, the paper attempts to comprehensively evaluate the application effects of computer simulations in middle school physics teaching, especially their role in improving students' understanding of basic circuits.