Bank Competition and Information Production

Filippo De Marco,Silvio Petriconi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022109024000152

IF: 4.337

2024-02-24

Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis

Abstract://static.cambridge.org/content/id/urn%3Acambridge.org%3Aid%3Aarticle%3AS0022109024000152/resource/name/firstPage-pdf-S0022109024000152a.jpg

economics,business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Bank Competition, Information Specialization and Innovation

Lin Tian,Liang Han,Biao Mi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-019-00815-6

2019-01-01

Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting

Abstract:Complementary to rich existing evidence on bank competition and corporate innovation, this paper aims to investigate the impacts of bank competition on innovation efficiencies, in terms of both R&D input and output at firm level. By acknowledging the role played by information asymmetries in financing innovation, we also examine the moderating effects of information specialization at both industry and firm level on corporate innovation. Analyzing innovation and bank structure data from U.S. between 1992 and 2010, we show novel evidence that increased bank competition improves innovation efficiencies in terms of both R&D input (investment) and output (patents and profits generated by R&D). In addition, we find bank competition has a greater favorable effect on innovation for those firms with more specialized information, such as those operating in an industry with more dispersed productivity growth and those with more concentrated patent types. Overall, our findings support market power hypothesis and banking strategic theory where bank competition improves credit supply to corporate innovation.
Does Bank Competition Inhibit the Formation of Zombie Firms?

Xiaoqian Zhang,Bin Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iref.2022.03.011

IF: 3.399

2022-01-01

International Review of Economics & Finance

Abstract:The intensified competition in China's banking industry is an important embodiment of gradual financial reform. Based on the Annual Survey of Industrial Enterprise Database, we find that the probability of forming zombie firms decreases by 0.48% with 1% increase of city-level bank competition. The result still holds when we introduce an IV based on the number the bank branches in 1937 when China's bank industry was at the boom before the World War II. The underlying mechanism is that the financial expense ratio of zombie firms increases by 0.17% with 1% increase of bank competition, which supports the “competition-stability” view. We also introduce the exogenous shock event of China's WTO accession and proxy variable from the survey on foreign banks in 1935 when China's bank industry was at the boom before the war, and the results are still robust.
Banking Market Competition and Corporate Innovation

lin tian,liang han,shengnian wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2564618

2015-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:By using the U.S. data, this study shows that state-level banking market competition, measured by Panzar-Rosse (1984) H-statistic, increases the number of patents and citations generated by firms and improves corporate innovation efficiency, supporting market power hypothesis. Greater banking competition is also found to enable innovative firms to adopt more ambitious innovation policies and have more flexibility to experiment with new technologies. The investigation of the heterogeneity of banking competition effects at the state-level shows that regional innovation in the states with lower R&D intensity benefits more from improved competition in local banking markets where additional innovation makes a greater marginal economic contribution. At the firm-level, such favourable effects vary across firm characteristics and innovative firms, with greater dependence on external finance and being financially constrained, enjoy a greater benefit from increased banking competition. The research also examines the role of information specialisation and finds that the banking competition effects are stronger for firms operating in informationally opaque industries and having more specialised information. It implies that banks benefit from the economies of scale in more specialised information acquisition when allocating credit supply. Finally, the research reveals novel evidence on the substitution effects of competition in a wider region and neighbour-state to local banking market in financing corporate innovations. The finding shows ‘how local is local banking market’ depends on the operating scope and information transparency of borrowing firms and local banks have an information advantage over distant banks in financing local businesses and informationally opaque corporate innovation activities.
Competition and Financial Stability in the European Listed Banks

Maria Celia López-Penabad,Ana Iglesias-Casal,José Fernando Silva Neto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440211032645

IF: 2.032

2021-07-01

SAGE Open

Abstract:The analysis of the relationship between bank competition and financial stability remains a controversial issue and widely discussed in the academic and political community. Using a sample of 117 listed banks in 16 European countries for the years 2011 to 2018, the article explores the impact of market power, measured by the Lerner index, on the bank stability, measured by distance-to-default and Z score. Our results show that for the overall sample, higher market power in banking decreases the risky behavior of banks, confirming the “competition-fragility” view. We do not find any support for a U-shaped relationship between competition and bank risk-taking. However, our findings differ from previous studies pointing out that the relationship between bank competition and risk-taking is differentiated depending on whether the bank is based in a country with a more stable banking system or a less stable one. In countries with a less financially stable banking system, increased competition leads to increased bank risk-taking. In countries with a more stable banking system, market power seems not to influence banks’ financial stability. Public policies must guarantee banking competition but limiting excessive bank risk-taking, especially in countries with less financially sound banking systems. The consolidation of European banking can be a key element for achieving these policies.

social sciences, interdisciplinary
Competition, coinsurance and moral hazard in banking

Augusto Hasman,Margarita Samartín

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2024.107207

IF: 3.539

2024-05-12

Journal of Banking & Finance

Abstract:This study examines the interaction between bank deposit market competition, incentives to take risks on the asset side, and willingness to participate in the interbank market for liquidity coinsurance. The interbank market in the model has two countervailing effects on risk-taking. First, it allows for more profitable long-term investment, which adds to a bank's charter value and decreases risk-taking motives. Second, greater investment in the long-term asset also makes risk-taking potentially more profitable, thus eroding charter value. Finally, risk-taking motives also influence banks' decisions to participate in the interbank market. We demonstrate how a combination of capital requirements and posting a surety bond can restore charter value, promote cooperation and boost economic activity. Additionally, this measure does not limit competition in generating charter value and implies lower costs than capital requirements alone.

economics,business, finance
Is competition good or bad for the price, quantity, and quality of bank lending?

Japan Huynh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0287002

IF: 3.7

2023-08-10

PLoS ONE

Abstract:This paper extends the existing literature by examining an important channel through which bank competition could drive the real economy by comprehensively influencing bank lending in three components–price, volume, and quality. For the measurement of bank competition, we build a series of different structural (concentration indicators) and non-structural (Lerner, Boone, and Panzar-Rose H-statistic indexes) measures, given that the reliance on solely one individual measure could lead to a misleading conclusion. Through a sample of commercial banks during 2007–2021 in a single Vietnamese banking market, we find a decline in bank loan growth and a rise in credit risk under the pressure of high competition. With respect to the association between bank competition and the price of credit, our empirical evidence is mixed based on different measures to analyze the banking market structure. Our findings support the view that greater competition results in a less proliferated banking sector with riskier assets. We also confirm that these findings are robust to additional tests, including employing alternative measures of bank lending dimensions and market structure, removing the periods of the financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic, and changing the empirical estimation technique. In addition, our deeper analysis reveals that the adverse impact of bank competition on lending, shown by reduced credit supply and increased credit risk, is less pronounced for banks with a higher degree of income diversification. This result suggests that bank diversification may protect the quantity and quality of bank lending from the detrimental competition effect.

multidisciplinary sciences
Competing or coopeting? Italian banking rivalry in Egypt, 1924–1940

Enrico Berbenni,Chiara Cantù,Stefano Colombo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jmh-05-2022-0014

2022-08-31

Journal of Management History

Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate the key drivers of coopetition by adopting a managerial and economic framework. A case of coopetition failure is investigated by means of a historical example focused on the Egyptian adventure of the Italian banks in the first decades of the XX century. Design/methodology/approach The authors adopt a qualitative case study and a flexible pattern matching approach to develop theoretical ideas. Because the flexible pattern matching approach was adopted, the authors build the analysis on a tentative analytical framework specified a priori to provide guidance and focus. This approach allows a theory-driven research paradigm. The historical case study is mainly grounded on original sources drawn from some major banking and institutional archives. Findings While several scholars emphasised the relevance of external drivers, the literature has paid less attention to how relational and internal drivers combine. The historical case suggests that key mechanisms supporting the success of coopetition concern planning of common goals, conflicts management, alignment and formalisation of governance. In this vein, internal and relational dimensions seem to be more relevant than environment-context dimension. In addition, the historical example shows that an intra- and inter-firm alignment is required to pursue the implementation of a coopetitive strategy. This suggests the relevance of a holistic approach to investigate coopetition. Further evidence confirms the role of governance mechanisms for the success of coopetition. Originality/value The main contribution of this study is the re-consideration of the drivers of coopetition. In particular, the role of coopetition drivers has been investigated using a historical event: the Italian multinational banking in Egypt in the interwar years.
Bank Competition and Access to Finance: Evidence from African Countries

Misraku Molla Ayalew,Zhang Xianzhi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10842-018-0283-6

2018-06-11

Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade

Abstract:Whether competition helps or hinders firms’ access to finance is a much-debated question in economic literature and policy issues. This study considers the consequences of bank competition on credit constraints using rich enterprise-level data set from the World Bank’s Enterprise Surveys. The study addresses 9632 firms from 27 African Countries. In addition to classical concentration measure, competition is measured by three non-structural measures (Boone indicator, H-statistics and Lerner index). The results show that bank competition worsens credit/financing constraints which supports the information hypothesis. However, further investigations show that bank competition has a significant positive effect on firms’ need for external financing, decision to apply for new line of credit and banks loan approval decision. Despite higher loan application approval rate by banks, large proportion of firms are discouraged to apply for bank loan. Small, medium and young firms are more likely to report higher financing constraints, more likely to need external financing but less likely to apply for bank loans and have low access to bank loan.
Information and bank credit allocation

Giovanni Dell'Ariccia,Robert Marquez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0304-405x(03)00210-1

IF: 8.9

2004-04-01

Journal of Financial Economics

Abstract:Private information obtained by lenders leads to borrower capture to the extent that such information cannot be communicated credibly to outsiders. We analyze how this capture affects the loan portfolio allocation of informed lenders. First, we show that banks charge higher interest rates and finance relatively less creditworthy borrowers in market segments with greater information asymmetries. Second, when faced with greater competition from outside lenders, banks reallocate credit toward more captured borrowers (flight to captivity). Third, if borrower quality and captivity are sufficiently correlated, an increase in the competitiveness of uninformed lenders can worsen the informed lender's overall loan portfolio. The model explains observed consequences of financial liberalizations.

economics,business, finance
Bank competition, risk-taking and financial stability: insights from an emerging economy

Bhavya Srivastava,Shveta Singh,Sonali Jain

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/cr-10-2021-0143

2022-06-17

Competitiveness Review

Abstract:Purpose Amidst the backdrop of a wide array of structural developments that have revolutionized the competitive landscape of Indian commercial banking, this paper aims to empirically examine the role of two external monitoring mechanisms – competition and concentration on financial stability and further highlights the significance of bank-level heterogeneity in the nexus. Design/methodology/approach The study uses the Lerner index, defined through a translog specification, as a measure of market power. A system generalized method of moments technique accounts for the dynamic associations among the competition-concentration-stability nexus. The study further examines the moderating effect of ownership, size and capitalization on the nexus. The study also uses the Boone indicator and comments on the competition-bank stability relationship after controlling for bank governance. Findings The findings indicate that banks are less stable in a more competitive and higher concentrated environment. Exploring bank-level heterogeneity, first, the authors report that as competition increases, state-owned banks have greater incentives to undertake risky activities than private and foreign banks, which point to implicit sovereign guarantees that characterize the former. Second, the authors document an adverse influence of competition on the soundness of larger banks consistent with the "too-big-to-fail" assertion. Third, results corroborate the disciplinary role of regulatory capital and lend support to stricter capital norms under Basel III in a more competitive environment. Originality/value This paper is perhaps the first to capture competition and concentration in a single model; to reconcile conflicting evidence on competition-risk nexus; to shed light on the joint effect of competition and Basel accords for Indian banks.
Digital financial and banking competition network: Evidence from China

Kaiwei Jia,Ying He,Mohammad Mohsin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1104120

2023-01-30

Abstract:The rapid development of digital finance resulted in fierce competition in the banking industry. The study used Bank-corporate credit data to measure interbank competition based on social network model, and we transformed the regional digital finance index into bank-level digital finance index using each bank's registry and license information. Furthermore, we employed QAP (quadratic assignment procedure) to empirically test the effects of digital finance on the competitive structure among banks. Based on which, we verified its heterogeneity and investigated the mechanisms through which the digital finance affected the banking competition structure. The study finds that, digital finance reshapes the banking competition structure, and intensifies the inter-bank involution while increasing the evolution. The large nation-owned banks have been in central position in the banking network system, with stronger competitiveness and higher strength of digital finance development. For large banks, digital financial development has no significant impact on inter-bank co-opetition and is only more significantly correlated with banking weighted competitive networks. For small and medium-sized banks, digital finance has a significant impact on both co-opetition and competitive pressure. Meanwhile, digital finance also led to the increasing homogeneous competition. In addition, compared with large nation-owned banks, the competitiveness of small and medium-sized joint-equity commercial banks and urban commercial banks are more vulnerable to digital finance and resulting in homogenization problems. Mechanism analysis showed that (1) digital finance promotes the overall competitiveness of the banking industry by improving the inclusiveness of financial services, which expands the service scope (scale effect); (2) digital finance promotes the competition by improving the pricing ability, risk identification ability and finally the capital allocation ability of banks (Pricing effect). The above findings provide new ideas for the governance of banking competition and the realization of a new pattern of economic development.
Stress test precision and bank competition

Diego Moreno,Tuomas Takalo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2024.111702

IF: 1.469

2024-04-12

Economics Letters

Abstract:We study a banking sector in which banks choose their asset portfolios and, upon the public disclosure of stress test results, raise funding by promising investors a repayment. Competitive banks must gamble, choosing assets that are riskier the more precise is the stress test. Allocative efficiency, however, improves with precision. When risk taking is not too sensitive to the precision of information, maximal transparency maximizes both stability and surplus. In contrast, banks with market power select safer assets, and opacity maximizes stability, as well the surplus if the social cost of bank failure is significant.

economics
Competing to Commit: Markets with Rational Inattention

Carlo M. Cusumano,Francesco Fabbri,Ferdinand Pieroth

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20221605

IF: 10.7

2024-01-01

American Economic Review

Abstract:Two homogeneous-good firms compete for a consumer’s unitary demand. The consumer is rationally inattentive and pays entropy costs to process information about firms’ offers. Compared to a collusion benchmark, competition produces two effects. As in standard models, competition puts downward pressure on prices. But, additionally, an attention effect arises: the consumer engages in trade more often. This alleviates the commitment problem that firms have when facing inattentive consumers and increases trade efficiency. For high enough attention costs, the attention effect dominates the effect on prices: firms’ profits are higher under competition than under collusion. (JEL D11, D21, D43, D83, L12)

economics
Unveiling endogeneity between competition and efficiency in Chinese banks: a two-stage network DEA and regression analysis

Yong Tan,Peter Wanke,Jorge Antunes,Ali Emrouznejad

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-021-04104-1

IF: 4.82

2021-05-29

Annals of Operations Research

Abstract:Abstract Although there is a growing number of research articles investigating the performance in the banking industry, research on Chinese banking efficiency is rather focused on discussing rankings to the detriment of unveiling its productive structure in light of banking competition. This issue is of utmost importance considering the relevant transformations in the Chinese economy over the last decades. This is a development of a two-stage network production process (production and intermediation approaches in banking, respectively) to evaluate the efficiency level of Chinese commercial banks. In the second stage regression analysis, an integrated Multi-Layer Perceptron/Hidden Markov model is used for the first time to unveil endogeneity among banking competition, contextual variables, and efficiency levels of the production and intermediation approaches in banking. The competitive condition in the Chinese banking industry is measured by Panar–Rosse H-statistic and Lerner index under the Ordinary Least Square regression. Findings reveal that productive efficiency appears to be positively impacted by competition and market power. Second, credit risk analysis in older local banks, which focus the province level, would possibly be the fact that jeopardizes the productive efficiency levels of the entire banking industry in China. Thirdly, it is found that a perfect banking competition structure at the province level and a reduced market power of local banks are drivers of a sound banking system. Finally, our findings suggest that concentration of credit in a few banks leads to an increase in bank productivity.

operations research & management science
Bank competition with technological innovation based on evolutionary games

Chong Lai,Rui Li,Xiujuan Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iref.2023.07.055

2023-08-19

Abstract:We investigate the competition between banks according to an evolutionary model, in which the payoff gradient depends on a time-variant technological innovation factor. The explicit solutions of equilibrium strategies are derived via the method of characteristics. Advantageous technological innovation reduces costs and increases profits and credit supply. Better technology also induces the market's herding behavior. Under the Bertrand competition, besides technological innovation, we consider the product substitutability and obtain the equilibrium price, which depends on a substitution parameter and the marginal cost. If there is moderate product differentiation, banks will not always reduce interest rates to seize market share.

economics,business, finance
Does bank competition spur firm innovation?

Peisen Liu,Houjian Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15140326.2020.1806001

2020-01-01

Journal of Applied Economics

Abstract:For transition economies, the virtues of financial development for economic growth are obvious; however, bank competition has dubious effects due to various firm characteristics. This study uses Chinese banking and firm data from 1998 to 2011 to examine how bank competition affects firm innovation and how firm size and ownership influence the effects of bank competition. The results show that bank competition promotes firm-level innovation and that this positive effect is stronger for small firms and non-state-owned enterprises (non-SOEs). In addition, bank competition has a more beneficial influence on innovation for transparent firms and domestic firms. These conclusions thus shed light on the real effects of bank competition and the determinants of firm innovation in developing countries.

economics
Lost in diversification

Marco Bardoscia,Daniele d'Arienzo,Matteo Marsili,Valerio Volpati

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crhy.2019.05.015

2019-05-01

Comptes Rendus Physique

Abstract:As financial instruments grow in complexity, more and more information is neglected by risk optimization practices. This brings down a curtain of opacity on the origination of risk, which has been one of the main culprits in the 2007–2008 global financial crisis. We discuss how the loss of transparency may be quantified in bits, using information theoretic concepts. We find i) that financial transformations imply large information losses, ii) that portfolios are more information sensitive than individual stocks only if fundamental analysis is sufficiently informative on the co-movement of assets, iii) that securitisation, in the relevant range of parameters, yields assets that are less information sensitive than the original stocks, and iv) that, when diversification (or securitisation) is at its best (i.e. when assets are uncorrelated), information losses are maximal. We also address the issue of whether pricing schemes can be introduced to deal with information losses. This is relevant for the transmission of incentives to gather information on the risk origination side. Within a simple mean variance scheme, we find that market incentives are not generally sufficient to make information harvesting sustainable.<h2 class="section-title u-h3 u-margin-l-top u-margin-xs-bottom">Résumé</h2>À mesure que la complexité des instruments financiers augmente, de plus en plus d'informations sont négligées par les méthodes d'optimisation des risques. Cela obscurcit l'origine du risque, ce qui a été l'une des causes principales de la crise financière mondiale de 2007–2008. Nous discutons la manière dont la perte de transparence peut être quantifiée en bits, à l'aide de concepts de théorie de l'information. Nous constatons i) que les transformations financières impliquent d'importantes pertes d'information, ii) que les portefeuilles sont plus sensibles que les stocks à l'information tant que si l'analyse fondamentale est suffisamment informative quant aux mouvements conjoints des actifs, iii) que la titrisation, dans la gamme pertinente de paramètres, produit des actifs moins sensibles à l'information que ceux initiaux, iv) que, lorsque la diversification (ou titrisation) est à son meilleur (c'est-à-dire lorsque les actifs sont non corrélés), les pertes d'information sont maximales. Nous abordons également la question de savoir si des systèmes de valorisation peuvent être mis en place pour faire face aux pertes d'information. Ceci est pertinent pour inciter les initiateurs à collecter des informations sur l'origine du risque. Dans le cadre simple d'une approximation moyenne–variance, nous constatons que les incitations de marché ne sont généralement pas suffisantes pour rendre la collecte d'information durable.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, multidisciplinary
Desirable banking competition and stability

Jonathan Benchimol,Caroline Ninou Bozou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfs.2024.101266

IF: 3.554

2024-05-12

Journal of Financial Stability

Abstract:Every financial crisis raises questions about how the banking market structure affects the real economy. Although low bank concentration may reduce markups and foster riskier behavior, concentrated banking systems appear more resilient to financial shocks. We use a nonlinear dynamic stochastic general equilibrium model with financial frictions to compare the transmissions of shocks under different competition and concentration configurations. The results reveal that oligopolistic competition amplifies the effects of the shocks relative to monopolistic competition. The transmission mechanism works through the markups, which are amplified when banking concentration is increased. The desirable banking market structure is determined according to financial stability and social welfare objectives. Moreover, we find that depending on policymakers' preferences, a banking concentration of five to eight banks balances social welfare and bank stability objectives in the United States.

economics,business, finance
Bank Competition and Credit Risk in Euro Area Banking: Fragmentation and Convergence Dynamics

Maria Karadima,Helen Louri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm13030057

2020-03-16

Journal of Risk and Financial Management

Abstract:Consolidation in euro area banking has been the major trend post-crisis. Has it been accompanied by more or less competition? Has it led to more or less credit risk? In all or some countries? In this study, we examine the evolution of competition (through market power and concentration) and credit risk (through non-performing loans) in 2005–2017 across all euro area countries (EA-19), as well as core (EA-Co) and periphery (EA-Pe) countries separately. Using Theil inequality and convergence analysis, our results support the continued existence of fragmentation as well as of divergence within and/or between core and periphery with respect to competition and credit risk, especially post-crisis, in spite of some partial reintegration trends. Policy measures supporting faster convergence of our variables would be helpful in establishing a real banking union.
Bank Competition, Financing Constraints and Enterprise Innovation

Jingya Hou,Xiaoyu Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47260/jafb/1263

2022-08-03

Journal of Applied Finance & Banking

Abstract:Abstract In recent years, the innovation behavior of enterprises has attracted more and more attention. Our study proves that encouraging bank competition can promote enterprise innovation. The study found that there is a negative correlation between the bank concentration index in county areas and the innovation output of local enterprises in China. At the same time, we find that bank competition can more effectively improve the financing constraints of private enterprises and small enterprises, thus promoting enterprise innovation. JEL classification numbers: G21,O31,O32. Keywords: Bank Competition; Financing Constraints; Enterprise Innovation; Credit Discrimination.

Bank Competition and Information Production

Bank Competition, Information Specialization and Innovation

Does Bank Competition Inhibit the Formation of Zombie Firms?

Banking Market Competition and Corporate Innovation

Competition and Financial Stability in the European Listed Banks

Competition, coinsurance and moral hazard in banking

Is competition good or bad for the price, quantity, and quality of bank lending?

Competing or coopeting? Italian banking rivalry in Egypt, 1924–1940

Bank Competition and Access to Finance: Evidence from African Countries

Information and bank credit allocation

Bank competition, risk-taking and financial stability: insights from an emerging economy

Digital financial and banking competition network: Evidence from China

Stress test precision and bank competition

Competing to Commit: Markets with Rational Inattention

Unveiling endogeneity between competition and efficiency in Chinese banks: a two-stage network DEA and regression analysis

Bank competition with technological innovation based on evolutionary games

Does bank competition spur firm innovation?

Lost in diversification

Desirable banking competition and stability

Bank Competition and Credit Risk in Euro Area Banking: Fragmentation and Convergence Dynamics

Bank Competition, Financing Constraints and Enterprise Innovation