Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this study is to evaluate the sustainability performance of modular construction from a life cycle perspective. So far, the sustainability performance of modular buildings has been explored from a life cycle viewpoint. There is no comprehensive study showing which material is the best choice for modular construction considering all three sustainable pillars. Therefore, a life cycle sustainability performance framework, including the three-pillar evaluation framework, was developed for different modular buildings. The materials are concrete, steel and timber constructed as a modular construction method. Design/methodology/approach Transitioning the built environment to a circular economy is vital to achieving sustainability goals. Modular construction is perceived as the future of the construction industry, and in combination with objective sustainability, it is still in the evaluation phase. A life cycle sustainability assessment, which includes life cycle assessment, life cycle cost and social life cycle assessment, has been selected to evaluate alternative materials for constructing a case study building using modular strategies. Subsequently, the multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) method was used to compute the outranking scores for each modular component. Findings The calculated embodied impacts and global warming potential (GWP) showed that material production is the most critical phase (65%–88% of embodied energy and 64%–86% of GWP). The result of embodied energy and GWP shows timber as an ideal choice. Timber modular has a 21% and 11% lower GWP than concrete and steel, respectively. The timber structure also has 19% and 13% lower embodied energy than concrete and steel. However, the result of the economic analysis revealed that concrete is the most economical choice. The cost calculations indicate that concrete exhibits a lower total cost by 4% compared to timber and 11% higher than steel structures. However, the social assessment suggests that steel emerges as the optimal material when contrasted with timber and concrete. Consequently, determining the best single material for constructing modular buildings becomes challenging. To address this, the MCDM technique is used to identify the optimal choice. Through MCDM analysis, steel demonstrates the best overall performance. Originality/value This research is valuable for construction professionals as it gives a deliberate framework for modular buildings' life cycle sustainability performance and assists with sustainable construction materials.

Integrated Value Model for Sustainable Assessment of Modular Residential Towers: Case Study: Ten Degrees Croydon and Apex House in London

MIVES multi-criteria framework to sustainability index of design for manufacture and assembly

Integrating three pillars of sustainability for evaluating the modular construction building

An enhanced multi-criteria decision-making approach oriented to sustainability analysis of building facades: A case study of Barcelona

Sustainability assessment in residential high-rise building design: state of the art

A Prototype System Dynamic Model for Assessing the Sustainability of Construction Projects

Assessment of Modular Construction System Made with Low Environmental Impact Construction Materials for Achieving Sustainable Housing Projects

An open building information modelling based co-simulation architecture to model building energy and environmental life cycle assessment: A case study on two buildings in the United Kingdom and Luxembourg

Towards a sustainability assessment model for affordable housing projects: the perspective of professionals in Ghana

Assessment of social sustainability performance for residential building

Energy use in residential buildings for sustainable development: The fifth Solar Decathlon Europe revelations

Multi-criteria assessment framework for sustainable rehabilitation and reconstruction of housing using mathematical model

Coupling and Quantifying Sustainability and Resilience in Intelligent Buildings

Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment Study of Conventional and Prefabricated Construction Methods: MADM Analysis

The Potential Contribution of Modular Volumetric Timber Buildings to Circular Construction: A State-of-the-Art Review Based on Literature and 60 Case Studies

Integration of life-cycle assessment in a multimodal building design approach

A BIM-integrated multi objective optimization model for sustainable building construction management

Identifying and assessing modular construction implementation barriers in developing nations for sustainable building development

An Integrated Building Information Modeling and Life-Cycle Assessment Approach to Facilitate Design Decisions on Sustainable Building Projects in Canada

Development of a Multi-Criteria Decision-Making model to assist building designers in the choice of superficial construction systems in urban areas

MIVES Technique for Sustainability Assessment in Architecture and Civil Engineering Industries