Perceptions of Risk, Benefit and Trust - A Comparative Assessment Between Healthcare Workers and the General Public Towards 3 Medical Technologies

Shira Ramot,Orna Tal
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/rmhp.s462411
2024-06-14
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Shira Ramot, 1 Orna Tal 1– 3 1 Department of Management, Health Systems Management Program, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel; 2 Shamir Medical Center (Assaf Harofeh), Zerifin, Israel; 3 ICET - Israeli Center for Emerging Technologies, Zerifin, Israel Correspondence: Shira Ramot, Email Background and Objective: While there is a substantial amount of research on risk perception, there has been less focus on the way medical technologies are perceived by experts as opposed to lay individuals. We investigated the factors that may influence the risk perception of healthcare workers (HCWs) and the general public regarding 3 distinct medical technologies: magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and the Covid-19 vaccine. Methods: A cross-sectional study conducted in 2021 among 2 populations: HCWs employed at a general public hospital and a sample of outpatients and individuals who are not medical professionals. The participants completed an electronic questionnaire. Results: In total, 739 respondents were included: 197 HCWs (26.7%) and 542 members of the public (73.3%). Most of the respondents (89.4%) reported being vaccinated against Covid-19, 43.8% had previously undergone an MRI but 90% had not undergone LASIK. Overall, all 3 technologies assessed in the study were rated by the respondents as having a high benefit and low risk. HCWs and the public showed statistically significant differences in perceived risk towards MRI and LASIK, as well as in some of the risk perception characteristics of each technology. In contrast, no differences in risk perception towards the Covid-19 vaccine were found between HCWs and the public. Both study populations showed a significant negative correlation between trust in the MoH and the perceived risk towards MRI and the Covid-19 vaccine. Both study populations regarded information provided by medical sources as the most reliable for decision-making. Conclusion: The perceptions and concerns towards medical technologies influence individuals' behavior and acceptance of technologies. They are also essential for risk communication. The study contributes to the understanding of attitudes towards various medical technologies, including risk perception, risk characteristics, trust and sources of information pertaining to each of the technologies, by examining the differences between HCWs and the general public. Keywords: healthcare workers, medical technologies, risk perception. trust, information source Innovative medical technologies have a significant impact on medical staff, patients, and the entire healthcare system. Generally, there is a prevailing enthusiasm for innovation and an anticipation for added advantages. At the same time, concerns and perceptions of patients and healthcare workers (HCWs) may impede the adoption and utilization of the technology. Different factors, such as perceived risk and benefit, and characteristics of the technology and the user, can influence the perceptions of medical technologies. The Covid-19 pandemic illustrated the importance of considering not only the effectiveness and safety of a new technology, namely the Covid-19 vaccine, but also individuals' own fears and perceptions. Understanding and addressing these concerns were crucial in overcoming hesitancy and promoting widespread immunization. Uniquely, this research examines personal perceptions of HCWs and the public towards medical technologies. Understanding risk perceptions associated with medical technologies is important given its influence on individuals' behavior and their willingness to accept and use the technology. 1 It is also essential for effective risk communication. 2 Many studies conducted over the years have investigated the various factors influencing the evaluation and perception of health risks by individuals. The psychometric paradigm has elucidated variations in perceptions of different risks and investigated factors associated with risk characteristics, such as severity, familiarity, freedom to choose the technology, and uncertainty. 1,3 Other studies have suggested that personal factors related to the "perceiver", such as demographic characteristics, knowledge, trust, worldview and belief, may also play a role. 1,4 The rapid advancement of technology has led to the implementation and utilization of new technologies in the health system. However, comprehensive knowledge about potential health risks associated with their use sometimes remains limited, potentially influencing risk perceptions towards these technologies. Psychometric studies have indicated that activities or technologies are viewed as having greater risk when they are novel, relatively u -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?