Abstract:Purpose This study aims to propose a moderated mediation model to investigate the moderating effects of environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance on the relationship between inefficient investment and firm performance and the mediating effect of firms that participate in institutional research on the relationship between investment efficiency and performance. This study also analyses the heterogeneity of the corporate nature, intensity of industrial research and development (R&D), industrial competition and regional marketization. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a panel data fixed-effects model to conduct a regression analysis of 1,918 Chinese listed firms from 2016 to 2020. A Fisher's permutation test is used to examine the differences between state-owned and nonstate-owned firms. Findings Inefficient investment negatively impacts corporate performance and higher ESG performance exacerbates this effect by attracting more institutional research which reveals more problems. State-owned enterprises perform significantly better than nonstate-owned enterprises in terms of ESG transformation. Industrial R&D intensity, competition and regional marketization also mitigate the negative effects of inefficient investment on corporate performance. Practical implications This study suggests that companies should consider inefficient investments that arise from agency issues in corporate ESG transformation. In addition, state-owned enterprises in ESG transformation should take the lead to achieve sustainable development more efficiently. China should balance regional marketization, encourage enterprises to increase R&D intensity, reduce industry concentration, encourage healthy competition and prevent market monopolies. Originality/value This study combines the agency and stakeholder theories to reveal how inefficient investments that arise from agency issues inhibit value creation in ESG initiatives.

How does corporate social performance affect investment inefficiency? An empirical study of China market

Environmental Performance and Corporate Risk-Taking: Evidence from China

Investment efficiency, ESG performance and corporate performance: evidence from Chinese listed enterprises

ESG Performance and Capital Investment

The Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on Labor Investment Efficiency: Evidence from China

Corporate underinvestment and its effects on environmental, social, and governance performance

The Effect of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Performance on Corporate Financial Performance in China: Based on the Perspective of Innovation and Financial Constraints

ESG ratings and corporate success: analyzing the environmental governance impact on Chinese companies’ performance

The IPO corporate social responsibility information disclosure: Does the stock market care?

Different kettles of fish: corporate social performance, media legitimacy, and corporate financial performance of Chinese firms

Corporate Social Responsibility, Analyst Focus and Firm Performance

Remote hand: Cross-regional SASAC holdings and corporate investment efficiency: Evidence from China

Corporate Social Responsibility Disclosure Quality and Firms' Investment Efficiency: Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

THE MECHANISM OF HOW ESG AFFECTS CORPORATIONS PERFORMANCE: ASYMMETRY INFORMATION AND PROPERTY RIGHTS

Corporate Social Responsibility and Investor Relations Management: Evidence from China

Corporate green innovation behaviour and investment efficiency: evidence from China

ESG performance, auditing quality, and investment efficiency: Empirical evidence from China

Does It Pay to Be Responsible? The Performance of ESG Investing in China

Do Political Ties Cause Over-Investment in Corporate Social Responsibility? Empirical Evidence from Chinese Private Firms

ESG Performance and Corporate Resilience: An Empirical Analysis Based on the Capital Allocation Efficiency Perspective