Does Sleep Selectively Strengthen Certain Memories Over Others Based on Emotion and Perceived Future Relevance?
Per Davidson,Peter Jönsson,Ingegerd Carlsson,Edward Pace-Schott
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/NSS.S286701
2021-07-24
Nature and Science of Sleep
Abstract:Per Davidson, 1– 3 Peter Jönsson, 4 Ingegerd Carlsson, 1 Edward Pace-Schott 2, 3, 5 1 Department of Psychology, Lund University, Lund, Sweden; 2 Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 3 Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; 4 School of Education and Environment, Centre for Psychology, Kristianstad University, Kristianstad, Sweden; 5 Athinoula A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Charlestown, MA, USA Correspondence: Per Davidson Email Sleep has been found to have a beneficial effect on memory consolidation. It has furthermore frequently been suggested that sleep does not strengthen all memories equally. The first aim of this review paper was to examine whether sleep selectively strengthens emotional declarative memories more than neutral ones. We examined this first by reviewing the literature focusing on sleep/wake contrasts, and then the literature on whether any specific factors during sleep preferentially benefit emotional memories, with a special focus on the often-suggested claim that rapid eye movement sleep primarily consolidates emotional memories. A second aim was to examine if sleep preferentially benefits memories based on other cues of future relevance such as reward, test-expectancy or different instructions during encoding. Once again, we first focused on studies comparing sleep and wake groups, and then on studies examining the contributions of specific factors during sleep (for each future relevance paradigm, respectively). The review revealed that although some support exists that sleep is more beneficial for certain kinds of memories based on emotion or other cues of future relevance, the majority of studies does not support such an effect. Regarding specific factors during sleep, our review revealed that no sleep variable has reliably been found to be specifically associated with the consolidation of certain kinds of memories over others based on emotion or other cues of future relevance. Keywords: sleep, memory, emotion, REM sleep, consolidation, forgetting A large body of studies has found sleep, as compared to wake, to be beneficial for memory consolidation (for an extensive review, see Rasch & Born 1 ). It has further frequently been suggested that sleep does not benefit all memories equally, but that sleep preferentially strengthens memories believed to be of high future relevance. Factors that determine the future relevance of a memory could be intrinsic to the material, such as emotion or personal interest, or manipulated extrinsic factors, such as information about a reward for successful remembering, knowledge that there will be a subsequent memory test, or forgetting instructions during encoding. Looking at peer-reviewed papers published 2018 and forward only, claims that sleep preferentially benefits memories based on their emotional value or their perceived future relevance are often repeated in both review papers and in the introduction sections of empirical studies as undisputed facts, or at least as if it was the typical finding in the field. 2–23 In this review paper, we aim to examine how robust these kinds of effects really are, by thoroughly reviewing the literature. The review consists of two parts based on what kind of future relevance has been examined. The first part examines the role of sleep in the consolidation of stimuli that are intrinsically emotional (and hence, by definition, relevant). The second part examines studies of sleep effects on intrinsically neutral material that has in some way been manipulated to establish a degree of future relevance (such as reward value, test-expectancy, or different forms of forgetting instructions). We include studies in which items with different degrees of future relevance have been encoded, and in which there has been a delay interval containing sleep between encoding and the memory test. In each part, we will first discuss the literature that has contrasted sleep and wake groups, and then the literature examining whether there are any factors during sleep that are specifically involved in strengthening certain kinds of memories over others based on their perceived future relevance. Regarding specific factors during sleep, a special focus will be on the frequently made assertion that rapid eye movement (REM) sleep preferentially benefits emotional memories. Looking at literature published from 2018 and forward only, this is often cited as a fact or as the typic -Abstract Truncated-
neurosciences,clinical neurology