Abstract:Estimating the probability of the binomial distribution is a basic problem, which appears in almost all introductory statistics courses and is performed frequently in various studies. In some cases, the parameter of interest is a difference between two probabilities, and the current work studies the construction of confidence intervals for this parameter when the sample size is small. Our goal is to find the shortest confidence intervals under the constraint of coverage probability being at least as large as a predetermined level. For the two-sample case, there is no known algorithm that achieves this goal, but different heuristics procedures have been suggested, and the present work aims at finding optimal confidence intervals. In the one-sample case, there is a known algorithm that finds optimal confidence intervals presented by Blyth and Still (J Am Stat Assoc 78(381):108–116, 1983). It is based on solving small and local optimization problems and then using an inversion step to find the global optimum solution. We show that this approach fails in the two-sample case and therefore, in order to find optimal confidence intervals, one needs to solve a global optimization problem, rather than small and local ones, which is computationally much harder. We present and discuss the suitable global optimization problem. Using the Gurobi package we find near-optimal solutions when the sample sizes are smaller than 15, and we compare these solutions to some existing methods, both approximate and exact. We find that the improvement in terms of lengths with respect to the best competitor varies between 1.5 and 5% for different parameters of the problem. Therefore, we recommend the use of the new confidence intervals when both sample sizes are smaller than 15. Tables of the confidence intervals are given in the Excel file in this link (https://technionmail-my.sharepoint.com/:f:/g/personal/ap_campus_technion_ac_il/El-213Kms51BhQxR8MmQJCYBDfIsvtrK9mQIey1sZnZWIQ?e=hxGunl).

Exact interval estimation for the linear combination of binomial proportions

An optimal exact confidence interval for the difference of two independent binomial proportions

Exact Confidence Intervals for Linear Combinations of Multinomial Probabilities

Bootstrap method-based estimation on the confidence interval for additive interaction in cohort studies

A permutation-based approach to inference for weighted sum regression with correlated chemical mixtures

Interval estimation of relative risks for combined unilateral and bilateral correlated data

Exact interval estimation for three parameters subject to false positive misclassification

Formulas, Algorithms and Examples for Binomial Distributed Data Confidence Interval Calculation: Excess Risk, Relative Risk and Odds Ratio

The cost of using exact confidence intervals for a binomial proportion

Generalised Clopper–Pearson confidence intervals for the binomial proportion

Two-sided confidence interval of a binomial proportion: how to choose?

Optimal confidence interval for the difference between proportions

Comparing Confidence Intervals for a Binomial Proportion with the Interval Score

Bayesian, frequentist and fiducial intervals for the difference between two binomial proportions

Simultaneous confidence interval construction for many-to-one of proportion ratios of bilateral correlated data

An optimal exact interval for the risk ratio in the 2×2 table with structural zero

Analysis of two Binomial Proportions in Non-inferiority Confirmatory Trials

Asymptotic infimum coverage probability for interval estimation of proportions

P-values and confidence intervals for weighted log-rank tests under truncated binomial design based on clustered medical data

Estimating the reciprocal of a binomial proportion

Common odds ratio test and interval estimation for stratified bilateral and unilateral data