The Complexity of Corporate Culture as a Potential Source of Firm Profit Differentials

Frederik Banning,Jessica Reale,Michael Roos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2305.14029

2023-05-23

Theoretical Economics

Abstract:This paper proposes an addition to the firm-based perspective on intra-industry profitability differentials by modelling a business organisation as a complex adaptive system. The presented agent-based model introduces an endogenous similarity-based social network and employees' reactions to dynamic management strategies informed by key company benchmarks. The value-based decision-making of employees shapes the behaviour of others through their perception of social norms from which a corporate culture emerges. These elements induce intertwined feedback mechanisms which lead to unforeseen profitability outcomes. The simulations reveal that variants of extreme adaptation of management style yield higher profitability in the long run than the more moderate alternatives. Furthermore, we observe convergence towards a dominant management strategy with low intensity in monitoring efforts as well as high monetary incentivisation of cooperative behaviour. The results suggest that measures increasing the connectedness of the workforce across all four value groups might be advisable to escape potential lock-in situation and thus raise profitability. A further positive impact on profitability can be achieved through knowledge about the distribution of personal values among a firm's employees. Choosing appropriate and enabling management strategies, and sticking to them in the long run, can support the realisation of the inherent self-organisational capacities of the workforce, ultimately leading to higher profitability through cultural stability.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: Why do firms within the same industry exhibit persistent differences in profit margins? Specifically, the paper models firms as a Complex Adaptive System (CAS) and explores how corporate culture, as one of the internal factors, co-evolves with management strategies and impacts firm performance and profitability. The paper aims to answer the following research questions:

1. What potential impacts might corporate culture have on profit differences between otherwise similar firms?
2. How does the frequency of changes in management strategies affect firm outcomes and profitability?
3. Under what conditions can management's attempts to guide the organization enhance profitability?

By integrating concepts and methods from economics, social psychology, and complexity science, the paper employs an agent-based bottom-up approach and proposes three main extensions: the formation of dynamic social networks and their impact on social norms and corporate culture, adaptive behavioral rules of employees based on job satisfaction, and endogenous management strategies. These extensions contribute to a deeper understanding of internal firm mechanisms, particularly the role of corporate culture in firm performance and profitability.