Understanding the psychodynamics of the pathway to suicide

Rachel Gibbons

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09540261.2024.2351937

2024-05-26

International Review of Psychiatry

Abstract:This paper describes the current understanding of the psychodynamics of the pathway to suicide and argues that the limitations of current epidemiological and observational approaches often overlook crucial psychodynamic factors. It describes how an underlying vulnerability in the capacity to process emotions can lead to unbearable pain, where death is perceived as the only escape. The intense emotional states following life's losses can then precipitate a profound division within the self. This internal split is characterised by a detached, destructive 'perpetrator' aspect and a vulnerable 'victim' aspect, with the former often overpowering the latter in the lead-up to suicide through suicidal fantasies of life after death. Drawing on data from various sources, including case studies, mental health audits, and coroner's reports, the paper assesses the practical efficacy of understanding suicide through a psychodynamic lens. This approach aims to provide more effective intervention strategies, not just by preventing suicide but also by addressing the needs of those left bereaved, who often suffer from complex grief and an elevated risk of suicide themselves. By shifting focus from solely preventive measures to a deeper understanding of the underlying psychological mechanisms, this research advocates for a more holistic approach to suicide prevention. It calls for a shared philosophical inquiry into the nature of human existence and the existential conflict between the will to live and the impulse to die, suggesting that a more nuanced comprehension of these dynamics could lead to better support systems both for those at risk and those bereaved.

psychiatry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the current lack of understanding of the psychodynamics of suicide. The author believes that existing epidemiological and observational methods often overlook crucial psychodynamic factors when studying suicide. The paper aims to deepen the understanding of the path to suicide by exploring the psychodynamic perspective, thereby providing more effective intervention strategies. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Defects in emotional processing ability**: The paper points out that an individual's potential vulnerability in processing emotions may lead to unbearable pain, ultimately making death seem the only way out.
2. **Internal self - division**: Intense emotional states may trigger a profound split in the self, manifested as a detached - from - reality, destructive "aggressor" aspect and a vulnerable "victim" aspect. This internal split is particularly prominent in the pre - suicide stage.
3. **The role of suicide fantasies**: The paper explores the role of suicide fantasies in the suicide process and divides them into six categories: fusion, revenge, self - punishment, stabbing, gambling with death, and separation attempts. These fantasies not only reflect an individual's mental state but may also become a key force driving suicidal behavior.
4. **The final triggering event**: The paper emphasizes that individuals who enter the pre - suicide state usually need a final triggering event to prompt them to take action. This event may seem insignificant, but it is decisive for the individual.
5. **Confusion and dissociation**: The ultimate betrayal and disappointment lead the individual to separate from the life - affirming part and enter a dissociative state, creating the conditions for committing suicide.

Through these discussions, the paper calls for a re - examination and improvement of existing suicide prevention measures from a deeper psychological mechanism, focusing not only on prevention but also on the needs of individuals who have lost their loved ones to suicide.