Theory of the Magnetic-Field-Induced Insulator in Neutral Graphene

J. Jung,A.H. MacDonald

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.80.235417

2009-09-08

Abstract:Recent experiments have demonstrated that neutral graphene sheets have an insulating ground state in the presence of an external magnetic field. We report on a $\pi$-band tight-binding-model Hartree-Fock calculation which examines the competition between distinct candidate insulating ground states. We conclude that for graphene sheets on substrates the ground state is most likely a field-induced spin-density-wave, and that a charge density wave state is possible for suspended samples. Neither of these density-wave states support gapless edge excitations.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: the properties of the insulating ground state of a neutral graphene sheet in the presence of an external magnetic field. Specifically, through Hartree - Fock calculations of the π - band tight - binding model, the researchers explored the competition among different candidate insulating ground states to determine the most likely field - induced insulating state.

### Research Background and Problem Description

1. **Experimental Phenomena**
- Recent experiments have shown that under the action of an applied magnetic field, a neutral graphene sheet exhibits an insulating ground state.

2. **Theoretical Challenges**
- In order to understand this phenomenon, it is necessary to explain why graphene changes from a conductive state to an insulating state under the influence of a magnetic field. In particular, it is necessary to determine whether this transition is related to some symmetry breaking.

3. **Specific Problems**
- The paper aims to reveal, through theoretical calculations, what the most likely field - induced insulating states are under different conditions (such as graphene on a substrate and suspended graphene).
- Specifically, the researchers focused on two possible insulating ground states: spin - density - wave (SDW) and charge density - wave (CDW).

### Main Research Contents

1. **Model Selection**
- The π - band tight - binding model was used for Hartree - Fock calculations, taking into account the influence of electron - electron interactions.

2. **Parameter Settings**
- There are two key parameters in the model: relative dielectric constant \(\varepsilon_r\) and local interaction \(U\).

3. **Result Analysis**
- By calculating the energy differences in different states, it was determined which state has the lowest energy under different parameters.
- The results show that the most likely field - induced state in graphene on a substrate is spin - density - wave (SDW), while in suspended graphene samples, charge density - wave (CDW) may be the possible state.
- These two density - wave states do not support gapless edge excitations in the ν = 0 energy gap.

### Summary of Mathematical Formulas

- The magnetic field length is defined as:
\[
\ell_B=\sqrt{\frac{\phi_0}{B}}
\]
where \(\phi_0 = \frac{ch}{e}\) is the magnetic flux quantum.

- The energy of the n - th Landau level is:
\[
E_n=\pm\frac{2\hbar v_F}{\ell_B}\sqrt{|n|}
\]
where \(v_F=\frac{\sqrt{3}at}{2\hbar}\) is the Fermi velocity of graphene.

- The expression for the direct interaction energy:
\[
\delta E_{DI}=\frac{(\delta n)^2}{2}\left[U+\sum_{j\in A}V(d_{ij})-\sum_{j\in B}V(d_{ij})\right]
\]
where \(d_{ij}\) is the distance between lattice points \(i\) and \(j\), and \(U = V(d_{ii})\).

Through these studies, the paper reveals the properties of the insulating ground state of neutral graphene under an applied magnetic field and provides a theoretical basis for understanding the underlying physical mechanisms.