Electronic Cooling in Graphene

R. Bistritzer,A.H. MacDonald

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.206410

2009-02-24

Abstract:Energy transfer to acoustic phonons is the dominant low-temperature cooling channel of electrons in a <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://crystal.For" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> cold neutral graphene we find that the weak cooling power of its acoustical modes relative to the heat capacity of the system leads to a power law decay of the electronic temperature when far from equilibrium. For heavily doped graphene a high electronic temperature is shown to initially decrease linearly with time at a rate proportional to n^(3/2) with n being the electronic density. We discuss the relative importance of optical and acoustic phonons to cooling.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the understanding of the electron - cooling mechanism in graphene, especially the cooling behavior under low - temperature and high - electron - density conditions. Specifically, the author focuses on the following two main issues:

1. **Energy - exchange mechanism between electrons and phonons**: Under low - temperature conditions, electrons are cooled through interactions with acoustic phonons and optical phonons. For nearly neutral graphene, the energy transfer of acoustic phonons is weak, causing the electron temperature to decrease in a power - law decay manner.

2. **Dynamic differences in electron cooling under different doping conditions**: In highly - doped graphene, the electron temperature decreases linearly with time when far from the equilibrium state, and exponentially decays when approaching the equilibrium state. In addition, the author also explores the relative importance of acoustic phonons and optical phonons in different temperature ranges.

### Specific problem description

- **Electron cooling in neutral graphene**:
- For nearly neutral graphene (i.e., the chemical potential \(\mu\) is much smaller than the electron temperature \(T_e\)), the author finds that when the lattice temperature \(T_L\) is much lower than the electron temperature \(T_e\) and \(T_e\lesssim180\,\text{K}\), the electron temperature satisfies the power - law decay:
\[
T_e(t)=T_0\sqrt{\frac{t}{\tau_0}+ 1}
\]
where the characteristic time is:
\[
\tau_0=\frac{424}{D^2T_0^2}\,\mu\text{s}
\]
\(T_0\) is the initial electron temperature, and \(D\) is the deformation potential, with the unit of eV.

- **Electron cooling in highly - doped graphene**:
- In the case of high doping (i.e., the chemical potential \(\mu\) is much larger than the electron temperature \(T_e\)), the electron temperature decreases linearly with time when far from the equilibrium state, and the rate is proportional to the \(3/2\) power of the electron density \(n\):
\[
\frac{\partial T_e}{\partial t}=-\gamma_d(T_e - T_L)
\]
where
\[
\gamma_d=\frac{3D^2\epsilon_F^3}{4\pi^2\rho v_g^4}=0.133D^2n^{3/2}\,\text{meV/ns}
\]
Here, the unit of \(n\) is \(10^{12}\,\text{cm}^{-2}\).

### Main conclusions

- **Neutral graphene**: Due to the low energy of acoustic phonons and the small joint - state density, its cooling efficiency is low, and the electron temperature slowly decays in a power - law form.
- **High - doped graphene**: The cooling rate is relatively fast, especially when far from the equilibrium state, the electron temperature rapidly decreases in a linear manner.

These research results are helpful for understanding the thermal - management problems in graphene - based electronic devices and provide a theoretical basis for the future design of graphene - based electronic devices.