Energy Supplier Obligations and White Certificate Schemes : Comparative Analysis of Results in the European Union

S. Rezessy,P. Bertoldi

Abstract:This paper discusses the most recent results of the energy saving obligations implemented by Member States of the European Union, analysing dominant end-use sectors and measures, as well as estimated costs. The paper examines the implications of different designs on the outcomes of national schemes and draws conclusions about the design and operation of supplier and utility obligations and tradable certificate schemes. In the European Union (EU) supplier obligations to save energy and white certificate schemes have delivered larger savings than originally expected with obliged companies exceeding targets and, in some cases, at cost below what policy makers have anticipated. Supplier obligations have fostered the uptake of standardised energy efficiency actions often targeting smaller energy users (residential sector), lowering the transaction costs and contributing to market transformation. The role of certificate trading is more ambiguous. Trading can bring benefits where the target is set sufficiently high with respect to the energy saving potential in the sectors covered. Theoretically trading may be better suited for broader systems with comprehensive coverage, but even in smaller schemes trading may reduce the transaction costs of compliance for obliged actors without sufficient expertise on end-use energy efficiency. Yet, trading increases the administrative cost ratio of energy saving obligations.

Economics,Environmental Science