Abstract:The satisfaction probability Pr[$\phi$] := Pr$_{\beta:vars(\phi) \to \{0,1\}}[\beta\models \phi]$ of a propositional formula $\phi$ is the likelihood that a random assignment $\beta$ makes the formula true. We study the complexity of the problem $k$SAT-Pr$_{>p}$ = {$\phi$ is a $k$CNF formula | Pr[$\phi$] > p} for fixed $k$ and $p$. While 3SAT-Pr$_{>0}$ = 3SAT is NP-complete and SAT-Pr$_{>1/2}$ is PP-complete, Akmal and Williams recently showed that 3SAT-Pr$_{>1/2}$ lies in P and 4SAT-Pr$_{>1/2}$ is NP-complete; but the methods used to prove these striking results stay silent about, say, 4SAT-Pr$_{>3/4}$, leaving the computational complexity of $k$SAT-Pr$_{>p}$ open for most $k$ and $p$. In the present paper we give a complete characterization in the form of a trichotomy: $k$SAT-Pr$_{>p}$ lies in AC$^0$, is NL-complete, or is NP-complete. The proof of the trichotomy hinges on a new order-theoretic insight: Every set of $k$CNF formulas contains a formula of maximum satisfaction probability. This deceptively simple statement allows us to (1) kernelize $k$SAT-Pr$_{\ge p}$ for the joint parameters $k$ and $p$, (2) show that the variables of the kernel form a backdoor set when the trichotomy states membership in AC$^0$ or NL, and (3) prove locality properties for $k$CNF formulas $\phi$, by which Pr[$\phi$] < $p$ implies that Pr[$\psi$] < $p$ holds already for a subset $\psi$ of $\phi$'s clauses whose size depends only on $k$ and $p$, and Pr[$\phi$] = $p$ implies $\phi \equiv \psi$ for some $k$CNF formula $\psi$ whose size once more depends only on $k$ and $p$.

Unsatisfiable CNF Formulas need many Conflicts

Unsatisfiable CNF Formulas contain Many Conflicts.

How Many Conflicts Does It Need To Be Unsatisfiable?

Unsatisfiable Linear CNF Formulas Are Large and Complex

Unsatisfiable Linear CNF Formulas Are Large, and Difficult to Construct Explicitely

Trivial, Tractable, Hard. A Not So Sudden Complexity Jump in Neighborhood Restricted CNF Formulas.

Unsatisfiable Linear K-Cnfs Exist, for Every K

Satisfiability of Almost Disjoint CNF Formulas

The Lovász Local Lemma and Satisfiability

Small unsatisfiable $k$-CNFs with bounded literal occurrence

Partial Satisfaction of K-Satisfiable Formulas.

On the Satisfaction Probabilities of $k$-CNF Formulas

Two tractable subclasses of minimal unsatisfiable formulas

Linear CNF formulas and satisfiability

On the random satisfiable process

Bounds for variables with few occurrences in conjunctive normal forms

On CNF formulas irredundant with respect to unit clause propagation

Unsatisfiable hitting clause-sets with three more clauses than variables.

Sufficient Condition for Polynomial Solvability of Random 3-CNF Formulas

Satisfiable Formulas Closed under Replacement.

A New Bound for 3-Satisfiable MaxSat and Its Algorithmic Application.