Abstract:Mendelian randomization (MR) implemented through instrumental variables analysis is an increasingly popular causal inference tool used in genetic epidemiology. But it can have limitations for evaluating simultaneous causal relationships in complex data sets that include, for example, multiple genetic predictors and multiple potential risk factors associated with the same genetic variant. Here we use real and simulated data to investigate Bayesian network analysis (BN) with the incorporation of directed arcs, representing genetic anchors, as an alternative approach. A Bayesian network describes the conditional dependencies/independencies of variables using a graphical model (a directed acyclic graph) with an accompanying joint probability. In real data, we found BN could be used to infer simultaneous causal relationships that confirmed the individual causal relationships suggested by bi-directional MR, while allowing for the existence of potential horizontal pleiotropy (that would violate MR assumptions). In simulated data, BN with two directional anchors (mimicking genetic instruments) had greater power for a fixed type 1 error than bi-directional MR, while BN with a single directional anchor performed better than or as well as bi-directional MR. Both BN and MR could be adversely affected by violations of their underlying assumptions (such as genetic confounding due to unmeasured horizontal pleiotropy). BN with no directional anchor generated inference that was no better than by chance, emphasizing the importance of directional anchors in BN (as in MR). Under highly pleiotropic simulated scenarios, BN outperformed both MR (and its recent extensions) and two recently-proposed alternative approaches: a multi-SNP mediation intersection-union test (SMUT) and a latent causal variable (LCV) test. We conclude that BN incorporating genetic anchors is a useful complementary method to conventional MR for exploring causal relationships in complex data sets such as those generated from modern "omics" technologies.

Bayesian network-based Mendelian randomization for variant prioritization and phenotypic causal inference

Bayesian network analysis incorporating genetic anchors complements conventional Mendelian randomization approaches for exploratory analysis of causal relationships in complex data

Inferring the Direction of a Causal Link and Estimating Its Effect via a Bayesian Mendelian Randomization Approach

Likelihood-based Mendelian randomization analysis with automated instrument selection and horizontal pleiotropic modeling

Selecting likely causal risk factors from high-throughput experiments using multivariable Mendelian randomization

Mendelian randomization: genetic anchors for causal inference in epidemiological studies

Mendelian randomization: causal inference leveraging genetic data

Causal inference for multiple risk factors and diseases from genomics data

Bayesian Weighted Mendelian Randomization for Causal Inference based on Summary Statistics

Mendelian randomization accounting for correlated and uncorrelated pleiotropic effects using genome-wide summary statistics

A Bayesian approach to Mendelian randomization using summary statistics in the univariable and multivariable settings with correlated pleiotropy

Mendelian Randomization Approach, Used for Causal Inferences

A Novel One‐Sample Mendelian Randomization Approach for Count‐Type Outcomes That Is Robust to Correlated and Uncorrelated Pleiotropic Effects

Mendelian randomization under the omnigenic architecture

Bayesian Mendelian randomization testing of interval causal null hypotheses: ternary decision rules and loss function calibration

Benchmarking Mendelian Randomization methods for causal inference using genome-wide association study summary statistics

A new robust and accurate two-sample Mendelian randomization method with a large number of genetic variants

Mendelian Randomization Analysis in Observational Epidemiology

Bayesian Mendelian Randomization Analysis for Latent Exposures Leveraging GWAS Summary Statistics for Traits Co-Regulated by the Exposures

A Random Effects Model-based Method of Moments Estimation of Causal Effect in Mendelian Randomization Studies

Bayesian Mendelian Randomization identifies disease causing proteins via pedigree data, partially observed exposures and correlated instruments