Complex microwave conductivity of Pr$_{1.85}$Ce$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4-δ}$ thin films using a cavity perturbation method

Guillaume Cote,Mario Poirier,Patrick Fournier

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3054293

2007-11-27

Abstract:We report a study of the microwave conductivity of electron-doped Pr$_{1.85}$Ce$_{0.15}$CuO$_{4-\delta}$ superconducting thin films using a cavity perturbation technique. The relative frequency shifts obtained for the samples placed at a maximum electric field location in the cavity are treated using the high conductivity limit presented recently by Peligrad $\textit{et}$ $\textit{al.}$ Using two resonance modes, TE$_{102}$ (16.5 GHz) and TE$_{101}$ (13 GHz) of the same cavity, only one adjustable parameter $\Gamma$ is needed to link the frequency shifts of an empty cavity to the ones of a cavity loaded with a perfect conductor. Moreover, by studying different sample configurations, we can relate the substrate effects on the frequency shifts to a scaling factor. These procedures allow us to extract the temperature dependence of the complex penetration depth and the complex microwave conductivity of two films with different quality. Our data confirm that all the physical properties of the superconducting state are consistent with an order parameter with lines of nodes. Moreover, we demonstrate the high sensitivity of these properties on the quality of the films.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the research problem of pairing symmetry in electron - doped cuprate superconductors. Specifically, by using the microwave resonant cavity technique, the researchers measured the microwave conductivity of Pr\(_{1.85}\)Ce\(_{0.15}\)CuO\(_{4 - \delta}\) (PCCO) superconducting thin films to detect the physical properties of these materials in the superconducting state, especially whether they have consistent d - wave symmetry.

### Research Background and Problems

1. **Pairing Symmetry in High - Tc Cuprate Superconductors**
- The pairing symmetry in high - Tc superconductors is a very active research area. Microwave measurement methods are particularly useful in detecting the characteristics of these symmetries. When a microwave resonant cavity is loaded with a conductive sample, the real and imaginary parts of the complex conductivity \(\tilde{\sigma}=\sigma_1 - i\sigma_2\) can be inferred by measuring the changes in the resonance frequency and the quality factor Q.
- Based on the two - fluid model of superconductors, both the condensed pairs and quasiparticles contribute to \(\tilde{\sigma}\), which in turn determines the temperature dependence of the magnetic penetration depth \(\lambda(T)\) and the quasiparticle relaxation rate \(T^{- 1}_1(T)\).

2. **Differences between Electron - Doping and Hole - Doping**
- D - wave symmetry has been well - established in hole - doped cuprate superconductors, but it is still controversial in electron - doped cuprate superconductors.
- When using single - crystal samples, residual microwave absorption is usually observed in the superconducting state, which may hinder the accurate determination of \(\lambda(T)\). This residual absorption may be caused by the inhomogeneity of the oxygen reduction process within the crystal volume, and oxygen reduction is necessary to induce the superconducting state.

3. **Advantages of Thin Films**
- Compared with single crystals, high - quality electron - doped cuprate superconducting thin films can be grown on appropriate substrates by pulsed laser ablation. The small thickness and in - situ annealing of the thin films ensure uniform reduction within the sample volume.
- However, there are important differences in microwave measurements between thick samples (single crystals) and thin samples (thin films), which have not been fully overcome yet.

### Research Methods

1. **Microwave Resonant Cavity Technique**
- The researchers used a rectangular copper cavity, which can excite two resonance modes, TE\(_{102}\) (16.5 GHz) and TE\(_{101}\) (13 GHz).
- The resonance curves of each mode were obtained by a synthesized sweeper and a scalar network analyzer, and the resonance frequency \(f_0\) and the full - width at half - maximum \(\frac{1}{2Q}\) were obtained by Lorentz fitting.

2. **Data Processing**
- In order to derive the complex conductivity from the measured frequency shift, the researchers proposed a correction method, using the measurement results of the same sample at two different resonance frequencies and analyzing different substrate configurations.
- By introducing the concept of a virtual substitute sample, the asymmetric influence of the dielectric substrate on the field configuration was considered.

### Main Findings

1. **Complex Penetration Depth and Complex Conductivity**
- The researchers extracted the temperature - dependent complex penetration depth \(\tilde{\lambda}(T)\) and complex conductivity \(\tilde{\sigma}(T)\) of two PCCO thin films with different qualities.
- The data indicate that the superconducting - state physical properties of these thin films are consistent with the order parameter with nodal lines.

2. **Influence of Thin - Film Quality**
- The quality of the thin film has a significant impact on its physical properties. High - quality thin films (such as thin film A) exhibit characteristics closer to d - wave symmetry, while low - quality thin films (such as thin film B) exhibit more impurity scattering effects.

### Conclusion

This research through micro...