Abstract:Many networks in political and social research are bipartite, with edges connecting exclusively across two distinct types of nodes. A common example includes cosponsorship networks, in which legislators are connected indirectly through the bills they support. Yet most existing network models are designed for unipartite networks, where edges can arise between any pair of nodes. However, using a unipartite network model to analyze bipartite networks, as often done in practice, can result in aggregation bias and artificially high-clustering -- a particularly insidious problem when studying the role groups play in network formation. To address these methodological problems, we develop a statistical model of bipartite networks theorized to be generated through group interactions by extending the popular mixed-membership stochastic blockmodel. Our model allows researchers to identify the groups of nodes, within each node type in the bipartite structure, that share common patterns of edge formation. The model also incorporates both node and dyad-level covariates as the predictors of group membership and of observed dyadic relations. We develop an efficient computational algorithm for fitting the model, and apply it to cosponsorship data from the United States Senate. We show that legislators in a Senate that was perfectly split along party lines were able to remain productive and pass major legislation by forming non-partisan, power-brokering coalitions that found common ground through their collaboration on low-stakes bills. We also find evidence for norms of reciprocity, and uncover the substantial role played by policy expertise in the formation of cosponsorships between senators and legislation. We make an open-source software package available that makes it possible for other researchers to uncover similar insights from bipartite networks.

Community Structure in Congressional Cosponsorship Networks

Party Polarization in Congress: A Network Science Approach

Community structure in the United States House of Representatives

The Role of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender in the Congressional Cosponsorship Network

The rise of partisanship and super-cooperators in the U.S. House of Representatives

A Statistical Model of Bipartite Networks: Application to Cosponsorship in the United States Senate

Time-dependent community structure in legislation cosponsorship networks in the Congress of the Republic of Peru

The evolution of polarization in the legislative branch of government

A network analysis of committees in the United States House of Representatives

A Network-Based Measure of Cosponsorship Influence on Bill Passing in the United States House of Representatives

Opinion Polarization by Learning from Social Feedback

Analyzing and visualizing polarization and balance with signed networks: the U.S. Congress case study

Cross-National Measurement of Polarization in Political Discourse: Analyzing floor debate in the U.S. and the Japanese legislatures

Disentangling Active and Passive Cosponsorship in the U.S. Congress

Stochastic modeling of Congress

Attraction by pairwise coherence explains the emergence of ideological sorting

Explaining Policy Ties in Presidential Congresses: A Network Analysis of Bill Initiation Data

Emergence of Polarization in Coevolving Networks

Voting Behavior, Coalitions and Government Strength through a Complex Network Analysis

Follower-Followee Network, Communication Networks, and Vote Agreement of the U.S. Members of Congress

Online Communities and Social Network Structure