The Review and Analysis of Human Computer Interaction (HCI) Principles

V. Hinze-Hoare

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0707.3638

2007-07-25

Abstract:The History of HCI is briefly reviewed together with three HCI models and structure including CSCW, CSCL and CSCR. It is shown that a number of authorities consider HCI to be a fragmented discipline with no agreed set of unifying design principles. An analysis of usability criteria based upon citation frequency of authors is performed in order to discover the eight most recognised HCI principles.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of unified design principles and theoretical frameworks in the field of human - computer interaction (HCI). Specifically, the paper points out:

1. **Fragmentation in the HCI field**: Although HCI has developed for many years, there is still a serious phenomenon of disciplinary fragmentation at present. Different researchers and practitioners have differences in methodology, core concepts, research objects, etc., and lack a widely - accepted theoretical framework and design principles.

2. **Lack of unified design principles**: Although many different rules and principles have been proposed for evaluating and designing HCI systems, there is a lack of consistency among these rules and principles. Different researchers and designers may adopt different methods and standards, resulting in difficulty in forming a unified standard in practical applications.

3. **Evaluation of user experience**: With the development of HCI, user experience (Usability) has gradually become the core concern in this field. However, how to effectively evaluate and improve user experience is still a challenge. The paper attempts to determine the most recognized HCI principles by analyzing the views of frequently - cited authors, so as to provide guidance for evaluating and designing HCI systems.

In order to address these problems, the paper analyzes through the following steps:

- **Literature survey**: Based on the citation frequency of authors, select the most influential researchers and analyze the HCI principles in their work.
- **Principle normalization**: Normalize the HCI principles proposed by various researchers and weight each principle according to the citation frequency.
- **Determine the most significant principles**: Rank the weighted principles to determine the eight most recognized HCI principles.

These eight principles include:
1. **Recoverability**: The ability of users to recover from errors.
2. **Familiarity**: The extent to which users can use existing experience to understand and operate new systems.
3. **Consistency**: The degree to which the system exhibits similar behavior in similar situations.
4. **Substitutivity**: The ability of users to input the same value or perform the same action in multiple ways.
5. **Task Migratability**: The ability of task control to transfer between the system and users.
6. **Synthesisability**: The ability of users to construct predictive mental models.
7. **Predictability**: The ability of users to predict the results of future operations based on past experience.
8. **Perceptual Ergonomics**: Consider human perception characteristics to optimize interface design.

Through these steps, the paper aims to provide a more unified and consistent design principle framework for the HCI field, thereby reducing disciplinary fragmentation and improving the evaluation and design level of user experience.