The Einstein-Varicak Correspondence on Relativistic Rigid Rotation

Tilman Sauer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812834300_0432

2007-04-07

Abstract:The historical significance of the problem of relativistic rigid rotation is reviewed in light of recently published correspondence between Einstein and the mathematician Vladimir Varicak from the years 1909 to 1913.

History and Philosophy of Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Einstein the Stubborn: Correspondence between Einstein and Levi-Civita

Galina Weinstein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1202.4305

2012-02-20

Abstract:Before developing his 1915 General Theory of Relativity, Einstein held the "Entwurf" theory. Tullio Levi-Civita from Padua, one of the founders of tensor calculus, objected to a major problematic element in this theory, which reflected its global problem: its field equations were restricted to an adapted coordinate system. Einstein proved that his gravitational tensor was a covariant tensor for adapted coordinate systems. In an exchange of letters and postcards that began in March 1915 and ended in May 1915, Levi-Civita presented his objections to Einstein's above proof. Einstein tried to find ways to save his proof, and found it hard to give it up. Finally Levi-Civita convinced Einstein about a fault in his arguments. However, only in spring 1916, long after Einstein had abandoned the 1914 theory, did he finally understand the main problem with his 1914 gravitational tensor. In autumn 1915 the Göttingen brilliant mathematician David Hilbert found the central flaw in Einstein's 1914 derivation. On March 30, 1916, Einstein sent to Hilbert a letter admitting, "The error you found in my paper of 1914 has now become completely clear to me".

History and Philosophy of Physics
Post-Einsteinian Effects in the General Theory of Relativity from Higher-Order Riemannian Geometry

William Bies

2024-06-06

Abstract:In Part I of this series, the author has shown how to extend the framework of Riemannian geometry so as to include infinitesimals of higher than first order. The purpose of the present contribution is to initiate an investigation into the implications of higher-order differential geometry for the general theory of relativity. As we have seen, a novel concept of inertial motion is implied in the analogue of the geodesic equation when modified to include the effects of higher infinitesimals and it therefore should not come as a surprise that it has potentially observable kinematic consequences. The route we prefer to take goes through the Einstein-Hilbert action generalized to reflect the presence of higher infinitesimals and a cosmological constant. A variational principle yields an hierarchy of field equations, which reduce to the Einsteinian case at first order. In the weak-field limit, we recover the usual relativistic equation for a moving body to leading order. To exemplify the theoretical framework, we undertake a preliminary study of the Schwarzschild solution and Friedmann-Robertson-Walker cosmology in the presence of second-order terms. But the most exciting results concern the novel effects in orbital mechanics that arise when the higher-order corrections cannot be neglected. Indeed, the higher-order Riemannian geometry predicts a modification of Newtonian dynamics corresponding to the Pioneer anomaly for a spacecraft on a hyperbolic escape trajectory from the solar system and to the flyby anomaly for the differential between ingoing and outgoing asymptotic velocities of a spacecraft passing near a rotating planet -- both of which are found to agree well with sensitive empirical findings.

Differential Geometry
Historical and Philosophical Aspects of the Einstein World

Cormac O'Raifeartaigh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1906.08678

2019-06-20

Abstract:This article presents a brief review of some historical and philosophical aspects of Einstein's 1917 paper 'Cosmological Considerations in the General Theory of Relativity', a landmark work that denoted the starting point of modern theoretical cosmology. Our presentation includes a discussion of Einstein's early views of issues such as the relativity of inertia, the curvature of space and the cosmological constant. Particular attention is paid to lesser-known aspects of Einstein's paper such as his failure to test his model against observation, his failure to consider the stability of the model and a slight mathematical confusion concerning the introduction of the cosmological constant term. Taken in conjunction with his later cosmological works, we find that Einstein's approach to cosmology was characterized by a pragmatic search for the simplest model of the universe that was consistent with the principles of relativity and with contemporaneous astronomical observation.

History and Philosophy of Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Einstein on Involutions in Projective Geometry

Tilman Sauer,Tobias Schütz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2011.13901

2020-11-28

Abstract:We discuss Einstein's knowledge of projective geometry. We show that two pages of Einstein's Scratch Notebook from around 1912 with geometrical sketches can directly be associated with similar sketches in manuscript pages dating from his Princeton years. By this correspondence, we show that the sketches are all related to a common theme, the discussion of involution in a projective geometry setting with particular emphasis on the infinite point. We offer a conjecture as to the probable purpose of these geometric considerations.

History and Philosophy of Physics
Relativistic Elastostatics I: Bodies in Rigid Rotation

R.Beig,B.G.Schmidt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/22/11/021

2005-05-19

Abstract:We consider elastic bodies in rigid rotation, both nonrelativistically and in special relativity. Assuming a body to be in its natural state in the absence of rotation, we prove the existence of solutions to the elastic field equations for small angular velocity.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
A mechanistic interpretation of relativistic rigid body rotation

Stefan Catheline

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-35897-9

2023-06-03

Abstract:The starting point of this manuscript is classical rigid body rotation. As it is well known, it contradicts basis of relativity since infinite speed is reached at infinite distance from the rotation center O. In order to fix this problem, a phenomenological circle-based construction using Euclidian trigonometry is first described: the relativistic rigid body rotation. The physical Eulerian acceleration implied by this geometrical construction then sketches future links with Maxwell's equation and Lense-Thirring effect. More importantly, relativistic rigid body rotation is shown to be compatible with Lorentz transformation and brings new geometrical interpretations of time and space intervals.
Riccati Equation for Static Spaces and its Applications

Zhixin Wang

2024-09-15

Abstract:In this paper, we derive a Riccati-type equation applicable to (sub-)static Einstein spaces and examine its various applications. Specifically, within the framework of conformally compactifiable manifolds, we prove a splitting theorem for the Riemannian universal covering. Furthermore, we demonstrate two distinct methods by which the Riccati equation can establish the connectivity of the conformal boundary under the static Einstein equation. Additionally, for compact static triples possessing positive scalar curvature, we establish the compactness of the universal covering.

Differential Geometry
Rigidity for Einstein manifolds under bounded covering geometry

Cuifang Si,Shicheng Xu

2024-09-24

Abstract:In this note we prove three rigidity results for Einstein manifolds with bounded covering geometry. (1) An almost flat manifold $(M,g)$ must be flat if it is Einstein, i.e. $\operatorname{Ric}_g=\lambda g$ for some real number $\lambda$. (2) A compact Einstein manifolds with a non-vanishing and almost maximal volume entropy is hyperbolic. (3) A compact Einstein manifold admitting a uniform local rewinding almost maximal volume is isometric to a space form.

Differential Geometry
Correspondence between Einstein-Yang-Mills-Lorentz systems and dynamical torsion models

Jose A. R. Cembranos,Jorge Gigante Valcarcel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.96.024025

2018-03-06

Abstract:In the framework of Einstein-Yang-Mills theories, we study the gauge Lorentz group and establish a particular correspondence between this case and a certain class of theories with torsion within Riemann-Cartan space-times. This relation is specially useful in order to simplify the problem of finding exact solutions to the Einstein-Yang-Mills equations. The applicability of the method is divided into two approaches: one associated with the Lorentz group SO(1,n-1) of the space-time rotations and another one with its subgroup SO(n-2). Solutions for both cases are presented by the explicit use of this correspondence and, interestingly, for the last one by imposing on our ansatz the same kind of rotation and reflection symmetry properties as for a nonvanishing space-time torsion. Although these solutions were found in previous literature by a different approach, our method provides an alternative way to obtain them and it may be used in future research to find other exact solutions within this theory.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Extrinsic Curvature and the Einstein Constraints

Harald P. Pfeiffer,James W. York

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.67.044022

2002-11-07

Abstract:The Einstein initial-value equations in the extrinsic curvature (Hamiltonian) representation and conformal thin sandwich (Lagrangian) representation are brought into complete conformity by the use of a decomposition of symmetric tensors which involves a weight function. In stationary spacetimes, there is a natural choice of the weight function such that the transverse traceless part of the extrinsic curvature (or canonical momentum) vanishes.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Non-relativistic regime and topology: topological term in the Einstein equation

Quentin Vigneron

2024-01-08

Abstract:We study the non-relativistic (NR) limit of relativistic spacetimes in relation with the topology of the Universe. We first show that the NR limit of the Einstein equation is only possible in Euclidean topologies, i.e. for which the covering space is $\mathbb{E}^3$. We interpret this result as an inconsistency of general relativity in non-Euclidean topologies and propose a modification of that theory which allows for the limit to be performed in any topology. For this, a second reference non-dynamical connection is introduced in addition to the physical spacetime connection. The choice of reference connection is related to the covering space of the spacetime topology. Instead of featuring only the physical spacetime Ricci tensor, the modified Einstein equation features the difference between the physical and the reference Ricci tensors. This theory should be considered instead of general relativity if one wants to study a model universe with a non-Euclidean topology and admitting a non-relativistic limit.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics
The relativity revolution from the perspective of historical epistemology

Jürgen Renn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/430654

Isis

Abstract:This essay analyzes Einstein's relativity revolution as part of a long-term development of knowledge in which the knowledge system of classical physics was reorganized in a process of reflection, described here as a "Copernican process." This process led in 1905 to the introduction of fundamentally new concepts of space, time, matter, and radiation. On the basis of an extensive historical reconstruction, the heuristics of Einstein's creation of the general theory of relativity, completing the relativity revolution, is interpreted as a further transformation of the knowledge of classical physics, starting from conceiving gravitation as a borderline problem between field theory and mechanics. The essay thus provides an answer to the puzzle of how Einstein was able to create a theory capable of accounting for a wide range of phenomena that were discovered only much later.
The Relativistic Rotation Transformation and the Observer Manifold

Satyanad Kichenassamy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/axioms12020205

2024-04-03

Abstract:We show that relativistic rotation transformations represent transfer maps between the laboratory system and a local observer on an observer manifold, rather than an event manifold, in the spirit of C-equivalence. Rotation is, therefore, not a parameterised motion on a background space or spacetime, but is determined by a particular sequence of tetrads related by specific special Lorentz transformations or boosts. Because such Lorentz boosts do not form a group, these tetrads represent distinct observers that cannot put together their local descriptions into a manifold in the usual sense. The choice of observer manifold depends on the dynamical situation under consideration, and is not solely determined by the kinematics. Three examples are given: Franklin's rotation transformation for uniform plane rotation, the Thomas precession of a vector attached to an electron, and the motion of a charged particle in an electromagnetic field. In each case, at each point of its trajectory, there is a distinguished tetrad and a special Lorentz transformation that maps Minkowski space to the spacetime of the local observer on the curve.

General Mathematics
Signature of Einstein-Cartan theory

Bruno Arderucio Costa,Yuri Bonder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2023.138431

2023-12-13

Abstract:We study the physical effects of torsion as predicted by the Einstein-Cartan theory in the test particle approximation and the non-relativist limit. We first present the corresponding non-relativistic Hamiltonian for a 2-spinor. Then, we solve an idealized reflection and transmission problem for a non-relativistic spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ beam travelling across a spin-polarized target. We identify deviations in the spin polarizations of the reflected and transmitted as observables capable of distinguishing Einstein-Cartan from standard general relativity. If measured, this effect would constitute compelling evidence for the presence of spacetime torsion.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Einstein's Special Relativity: The Hyperbolic Geometric Viewpoint

Abraham A. Ungar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1302.6961

2013-02-28

Abstract:The analytic hyperbolic geometric viewpoint of Einstein's special theory of relativity is presented.

Mathematical Physics
Einstein Gravity from Einstein Action: Counterterms and Covariance

Martin Krššák

2024-06-13

Abstract:The field equations of general relativity can be derived from the Einstein action, which is quadratic in connection coefficients, rather than the standard action involving the Gibbons-Hawking-York term and counterterm. We show that it is possible to construct a new counterterm directly for the Einstein action, which removes divergences and naturally introduces a flat reference spacetime. The total action is then covariant under simultaneous transformation of both the spacetime and reference tetrads, and argue that this is analogous to the Gibbons-Hawking action. We then explore different perspectives arising naturally from different uses of the reference tetrad, and explore implications of viewing gravity as fundamentally described in terms of non-covariant connection coefficients.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
On the Mathematics of Coframe Formalism and Einstein-Cartan Theory -- A Brief Review

Manuel Tecchiolli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/universe5100206

2023-09-29

Abstract:This article is a review of what could be considered the basic mathematics of Einstein-Cartan theory. We discuss the formalism of principal bundles, principal connections, curvature forms, gauge fields, torsion form, and Bianchi identities, and eventually, we will end up with Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble field equations and conservation laws in their implicit formulation.

Mathematical Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
On the Hole Argument and the Physical Interpretation of General Relativity

Jaume de de Haro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/universe10020091

IF: 2.8128

2024-02-14

Universe

Abstract:Einstein presented the Hole Argument against General Covariance, understood as invariance with respect to a change in coordinates, as a consequence of his initial failure to obtain covariant equations that, in the weak static limit, contain Newton’s law. Fortunately, about two years later, Einstein returned to General Covariance, and found these famous equations of gravity. However, the rejection of his Hole Argument carries a totally different vision of space-time. Its substantivalism notion, which is an essential ingredient in Newtonian theory and also in his special theory of relativity, has to be replaced, following Descartes and Leibniz’s relationalism, by a set of “point-coincidences”.

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields
On the Absoluteness of Rotation

P. Hraskó,D. Szepessy

2023-06-13

Abstract:We argue that in the general relativistic calculation of planetary orbits, the choice of a reference frame which is an obligatory condition in the Newtonian approach is replaced by an appropriate boundary condition on the solution of Einstein equation. Implications of this observation on the nature of rotation and the physical interpretation of the metric tensor are discussed.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

The Einstein-Varicak Correspondence on Relativistic Rigid Rotation

Einstein the Stubborn: Correspondence between Einstein and Levi-Civita

Post-Einsteinian Effects in the General Theory of Relativity from Higher-Order Riemannian Geometry

Historical and Philosophical Aspects of the Einstein World

Einstein on Involutions in Projective Geometry

Relativistic Elastostatics I: Bodies in Rigid Rotation

A mechanistic interpretation of relativistic rigid body rotation

Riccati Equation for Static Spaces and its Applications

Rigidity for Einstein manifolds under bounded covering geometry

Correspondence between Einstein-Yang-Mills-Lorentz systems and dynamical torsion models

Extrinsic Curvature and the Einstein Constraints

Non-relativistic regime and topology: topological term in the Einstein equation

The relativity revolution from the perspective of historical epistemology

The Relativistic Rotation Transformation and the Observer Manifold

Signature of Einstein-Cartan theory

Einstein's Special Relativity: The Hyperbolic Geometric Viewpoint

Einstein Gravity from Einstein Action: Counterterms and Covariance

On the Mathematics of Coframe Formalism and Einstein-Cartan Theory -- A Brief Review

On the Hole Argument and the Physical Interpretation of General Relativity

On the Absoluteness of Rotation