Calculating modules in contextual logic program refinement

Robert Colvin,Ian J. Hayes,Paul Strooper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cs/0608110

2006-08-29

Abstract:The refinement calculus for logic programs is a framework for deriving logic programs from specifications. It is based on a wide-spectrum language that can express both specifications and code, and a refinement relation that models the notion of correct implementation. In this paper we extend and generalise earlier work on contextual refinement. Contextual refinement simplifies the refinement process by abstractly capturing the context of a subcomponent of a program, which typically includes information about the values of the free variables. This paper also extends and generalises module refinement. A module is a collection of procedures that operate on a common data type; module refinement between a specification module A and an implementation module C allows calls to the procedures of A to be systematically replaced with calls to the corresponding procedures of C. Based on the conditions for module refinement, we present a method for calculating an implementation module from a specification module. Both contextual and module refinement within the refinement calculus have been generalised from earlier work and the results are presented in a unified framework.

Logic in Computer Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve several key problems in the modularization of logic programs and contextual refinement, specifically including:

1. **Contextual refinement of logic programs**: The author extends and generalizes the earlier work on contextual refinement. Contextual refinement simplifies the refinement process by abstractly capturing the contextual information (usually including the value information of free variables) of program sub - components. This makes it more convenient to handle various parts of the program during the refinement process without having to consider the entire program from scratch every time.

2. **Module refinement**: A module is a set of programs that operate on a common data type. Module refinement allows the process calls in the specification module \(A\) to be systematically replaced by the corresponding process calls in the implementation module \(C\). Based on the conditions of module refinement, the author proposes a method for calculating the implementation module from the specification module. This method ensures that the interfaces and behaviors between modules remain consistent during the refinement process.

3. **Unified framework**: The author integrates the results of contextual refinement and module refinement into a unified framework, enabling these two refinement methods to be studied and applied under the same theoretical system. This unified framework not only simplifies the theoretical presentation but also provides more systematic guidance for practical applications.

### Formula and symbol explanations

- **Contextual refinement**:
- Let \(S\) be a program fragment and \(V\) be its free variables. Then \(S\) constrains (instantiates) \(V\) to satisfy \(S\).
- Contextual refinement provides the contextual information of program fragments by introducing assumptions. For example, assuming \(X\neq0\), the program fragment \(S\) can be represented as \(\{X\neq0\}, S\).

- **Module refinement**:
- The refinement relationship between module \(A\) and module \(C\) is represented as \(A\sqsubseteq C\), which means that all process calls in \(A\) can be replaced by the corresponding process calls in \(C\).
- The coupling invariant is used to describe the relationship between the abstract type and the implementation type. For example, for the refinement of list reversal, the coupling invariant can be represented as \(R = DL1 - DL2\), where \(DL1\) and \(DL2\) are difference lists.

### Paper structure

- **Section 2**: Introduces the basic concepts of wide - spectrum language and its refinement.
- **Section 3**: Discusses in detail the contextual refinement of logic programs and illustrates it with an example of data refinement.
- **Section 4**: Explores module refinement, focusing on how to reason about processes that operate on a common data type.
- **Section 5**: Proposes a general scheme for deriving the implementation module from the specification module and specializes it for specific combinations of abstract operations and coupling invariants.
- **Section 6**: Extends the specification language to eliminate the non - determinism in some coupling invariants, thus allowing a more efficient implementation module.
- **Section 7**: Discusses related work and summarizes the main contributions of this paper.

In general, this paper aims to provide a more systematic and efficient method for deriving the implementation of logic programs through the combination of contextual refinement and module refinement, ensuring the correctness and efficiency of the programs.