The Effect of Electric Fields In A Classic Introductory Physics Treatment of Eddy Current Forces

P. J. Salzman,John Robert Burke,Susan M. Lea

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1341249

2006-07-23

Abstract:A simple model of eddy currents in which current is computed solely from magnetic forces acting on electrons proves accessible to introductory students and gives a good qualitative account of eddy current forces. However, this model cannot be complete; it ignores the electric fields that drive current outside regions of significant magnetic field. In this paper we show how to extend the model to obtain a boundary value problem for current density. Solution of this problem in polar coordinates shows that the electric field significantly affects the quantitative results and presents an exercise suitable for upper division students. We apply elliptic cylindrical coordinates to generalize the result and offer an exercise useful for teaching graduate students how to use non-standard coordinate systems.

Physics Education,General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in classical electromagnetism, how to describe and calculate the acting force of eddy currents more accurately, especially when considering the influence of the electric field on the current density. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of existing models**:
- The existing simplified models calculate eddy currents only by the force of the magnetic field acting on electrons. Although they can give a qualitative explanation, they ignore the influence of the electric field on the current.
- Such models cannot explain the flow mechanism of the current outside the magnetic field area, especially the role of the Hall electric field, which leads to an overestimation of the eddy current force.

2. **Research objectives**:
- By introducing the influence of the electric field, extend the existing eddy current model so that it can describe the quantitative results of eddy currents more accurately.
- Solve the boundary value problem of the current density at the magnetic field boundary and provide a teaching case suitable for senior undergraduate and graduate students.

3. **Specific problems**:
- How to establish a more complete eddy current model when considering the electric field?
- How to determine the current density by solving the boundary value problem and evaluate the influence of the electric field on the eddy current force?

4. **Methodology**:
- Use polar coordinate systems and elliptic - cylindrical coordinate systems to deal with the cases of circular and elliptical magnetic field areas respectively.
- Solve the current density and electric field distribution through the eigenfunction expansion of the Laplace equation.
- Analyze the eddy current force correction factors under different geometric shapes (such as circular and elliptical).

5. **Main conclusions**:
- For an infinitely large planar conductor and a circular magnetic field area, the existence of the electric field makes the eddy current force decrease by half.
- For an elliptical magnetic field area, the correction factor depends on the eccentricity of the ellipse, and the formula is \(\frac{\sqrt{1 - \epsilon^{2}}}{1+\sqrt{1 - \epsilon^{2}}}\), where \(\epsilon\) is the eccentricity of the ellipse.
- When considering a conductor of finite size, the correction factor will also be affected by the ratio of the conductor size to the magnet size.

Through these improvements, the paper provides a more comprehensive and accurate method for calculating the eddy current force and shows the importance of the electric field in the eddy current phenomenon.