Precipitation in Al-Zr-Sc alloys: a comparison between kinetic Monte Carlo, cluster dynamics and classical nucleation theory

Emmanuel Clouet,Maylise Nastar,Alain Barbu,Christophe Sigli,Georges Martin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0507259

2005-07-18

Abstract:Zr and Sc precipitate in aluminum alloys to form the Al\_3Zr\_xSc\_{1-x} compound which, for low supersaturations of the solid solution, exhibits the L1\_2 structure. The aim of the present study is to model at an atomic scale the kinetics of precipitation and to build mesoscopic models so as to extend the range of supersaturations and annealing times that can be simulated up to values of practical interest. In this purpose, we use some ab initio calculations and experimental data to fit an Ising type model describing thermodynamics of the Al-Zr-Sc system. Kinetics of precipitation are studied with a kinetic Monte Carlo algorithm based on an atom-vacancy exchange mechanism. Cluster dynamics is then used to model at a mesoscopic scale all the different stages of homogeneous precipitation in the two binary Al-Zr and Al-Sc alloys. This technique correctly manages to reproduce both the kinetics of precipitation simulated with kinetic Monte Carlo as well as experimental observations. Focusing on the nucleation stage, it is shown that classical theory well applies as long as the short range order tendency of the system is considered. This allows us to propose an extension of classical nucleation theory for the ternary Al-Zr-Sc alloy.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and model the precipitation process in aluminum - zirconium - scandium (Al - Zr - Sc) alloys. Specifically, the research aims to describe the precipitation kinetics in detail through a multi - scale approach combining atomic - scale and meso - scale simulations, and to establish a meso - scale model to extend the range of supersaturation and annealing time that can be simulated to values that are meaningful in practical applications.

### Research Background and Problems

1. **Optimization of Material Properties**
- Adding transition elements such as manganese (Mn), chromium (Cr), zirconium (Zr) or scandium (Sc) to aluminum alloys can form small ordered precipitates, which can increase tensile strength and inhibit recrystallization.
- In order to optimize material properties, precise control of the precipitation process is required, especially by combining the addition of solute elements to change the precipitation distribution.

2. **Complexity of Precipitation Kinetics**
- For ternary Al - Zr - Sc alloys, there is less information on precipitation kinetics, but its possible kinetic paths are more abundant than those of binary alloys.
- Although atomic - scale simulations (such as kinetic Monte Carlo simulations) can predict kinetic paths in detail, due to computational time limitations, they can only simulate the early stages of precipitation and high - supersaturation conditions.

3. **Requirement for Meso - scale Models**
- It is necessary to develop meso - scale models to study alloys and heat - treatment processes that are compatible with technical requirements and to allow the comparison of simulated kinetics with experimental data.
- These meso - scale models include cluster dynamics (CD) and models based on classical nucleation theory (CNT), which describe the cluster size distribution of alloys.

### Solutions

1. **Multi - scale Approach**
- Use atomic - scale kinetic Monte Carlo (KMC) simulations to study precipitation kinetics.
- Combine with meso - scale cluster dynamics (CD) models to extend the range of supersaturation and annealing time that can be simulated.

2. **Model Validation**
- The results of KMC simulations are consistent with experimental observations, especially in terms of the structure and composition distribution of precipitates.
- The CD model can reproduce the kinetic changes simulated by KMC and is in good agreement with experimental data, especially under low - supersaturation conditions.

3. **Extension of Classical Nucleation Theory**
- Considering the short - range order tendency of the system, an extension of the classical nucleation theory is proposed to be applicable to ternary Al - Zr - Sc alloys.

Through these methods, researchers hope to be able to understand the precipitation process in Al - Zr - Sc alloys more comprehensively and provide valuable guidance for material design.