Superconductivity and Cobalt Oxidation State in Metastable Na(x)CoO(2-delta)*yH2O (x ~ 1/3; y ~ 4x)

P. W. Barnes,M. Avdeev,J. D. Jorgensen,D. G. Hinks,H. Claus,S. Short
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.72.134515
2005-06-22
Abstract:We report the synthesis and superconducting properties of a metastable form of the known superconductor NaxCoO2*yH2O (x ~ 1/3, y ~ 4x). Instead of using the conventional bromine-acetonitrile mixture for sodium deintercalation, we use an aqueous bromine solution. Using this method, we oxidize the sample to a point that the sodium cobaltate becomes unstable, leading to formation of other products if not controlled. This compound has the same structure as the reported superconductor, yet it exhibits a systematic variation of the superconducting transition temperature (Tc) as a function of time. Immediately after synthesis, this compound is not a superconductor, even though it contains appropriate amounts of sodium and water. The samples become superconducting with low Tc values after ~ 90 h. Tc continually increases until it reaches a maximum value (4.5 K) after about 260 h. Then Tc drops drastically, becoming non-superconducting approximately 100 h later. Corresponding time-dependent neutron powder diffraction data shows that the changes in superconductivity exhibited by the metastable cobaltate correspond to slow formation of oxygen vacancies in the CoO2 layers. In effect, the formation of these defects continually reduces the cobalt oxidation state causing the sample to evolve through its superconducting life cycle. Thus, the dome-shaped superconducting phase diagram is mapped as a function of cobalt oxidation state using a single sample. The width of this dome based on the formal oxidation state of cobalt is very narrow - approximately 0.1 valence units wide. Interestingly, the maximum Tc in NaxCoO2*yH2O occurs when the cobalt oxidation state is near 3.5. Thus, we speculate that the maximum Tc occurs near the charge ordered insulating state that correlates with the average cobalt oxidation state of 3.5.
Materials Science,Superconductivity
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the superconducting properties of sodium cobaltate hydrate \( \text{Na}_x\text{CoO}_2 \cdot y\text{H}_2\text{O} \) (where \( x \approx 1/3 \) and \( y \approx 4x \)) in the metastable state and its relationship with the cobalt oxidation state. Specifically, the researchers prepared this metastable sodium cobaltate hydrate by a new synthesis method - using a water - soluble bromine solution instead of the traditional bromine - acetonitrile mixture to de - intercalate sodium ions, and observed the change of its superconducting transition temperature \( T_c \) over time. The following are the main problems and goals of the paper: 1. **Time - dependence of superconducting properties**: - The researchers found that in the initial stage after synthesis, the material did not show superconductivity. - After about 90 hours, the sample began to show superconductivity with a low \( T_c \), and \( T_c \) gradually increased with time until it reached a maximum of 4.5 K at about 260 hours. - After that, \( T_c \) decreased rapidly and completely lost superconductivity after about 100 hours. 2. **Change of cobalt oxidation state**: - Through neutron powder diffraction data, the researchers found that the change of superconducting properties is closely related to the cobalt oxidation state. - The slow formation of oxygen vacancies in the CoO₂ layer leads to a gradual decrease in the cobalt oxidation state, thus affecting the superconducting properties. - The maximum \( T_c \) appears when the cobalt oxidation state is about + 3.5, which is related to the charge - ordered insulating state. 3. **Drawing of superconducting phase diagram**: - The researchers drew a superconducting phase diagram through a single sample, showing the relationship between \( T_c \) and the change of cobalt oxidation state. - The superconducting phase diagram presents a very narrow dome - shaped region with a width of about 0.1 valence unit. 4. **Explanation of superconducting mechanism**: - The researchers explored possible superconducting mechanisms and proposed two explanations: - A multi - doping mechanism similar to that of layered copper - oxide superconductors. - Or there is some instability (such as charge ordering) near the optimal cobalt oxidation state, which leads to the sudden disappearance of superconductivity. In conclusion, this paper aims to reveal the superconducting properties of sodium cobaltate hydrate in the metastable state and its complex relationship with the cobalt oxidation state, and provides a new perspective for understanding the superconducting mechanism of such materials.