Helicity and electron correlation effects on transport properties of double-walled carbon nanotubes

Shidong Wang,Milena Grifoni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.95.266802

2005-05-19

Abstract:We analytically demonstrate helicity determined selection rules for intershell tunneling in double-walled nanotubes with commensurate (c-DWNTs) and incommensurate (i-DWNTs) shells. For i-DWNTs the coupling is negligible between lowest energy subbands, but it becomes important as the higher subbands become populated. In turn the elastic mean free path of i-DWNTs is reduced for increasing energy, with additional suppression at subband onsets. At low energies, a Luttinger liquid theory for DWNTs with metallic shells is derived. Interaction effects are more pronounced in i-DWNTs.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the influence of the inter - shell coupling on the transport properties in double - walled carbon nanotubes (DWNTs), especially how to explain the electrical transport behaviors of different types of DWNTs (including commensurate double - walled carbon nanotubes c - DWNTs with a rational ratio of lattice constants and incommensurate double - walled carbon nanotubes i - DWNTs with an irrational ratio) under low - energy and high - energy conditions through analyzing helicity and electron - correlation effects.

### Main research contents

1. **Derivation of selection rules**:
- Through the tight - binding model and Born approximation, the authors derived helicity - dependent selection rules, which determine the effective coupling for inter - shell tunneling. For i - DWNTs, the coupling between the lowest sub - bands can be ignored, but it becomes important when higher sub - bands are involved.

2. **Elastic scattering mean free path**:
- For i - DWNTs, as the energy increases, the enhanced inter - shell tunneling leads to a decrease in the elastic scattering mean free path \( l_{\text{el}} \), and shows characteristic suppression at the beginning of each sub - band. This result is consistent with recent ab - initio calculations and experimental observations, indicating that DWNTs change from ballistic behavior to diffusive behavior as the energy increases.

3. **Application of Luttinger liquid theory**:
- At low energies, after considering electron - electron interactions, the DWNTs with metallic shells can be described by the multi - channel Luttinger liquid theory. For c - DWNTs, the inter - shell tunneling significantly reduces the tunneling density - of - states exponent, while i - DWNTs show different power - law behaviors.

4. **Power - law behavior of tunneling density of states**:
- The paper also explored the power - law behavior of the tunneling density of states (TDOS). For i - DWNTs, TDOS varies with energy according to a power law, specifically in the form of \( \rho_{b/a}(\varepsilon) \sim |\varepsilon|^{\alpha_{b/a}} \), where the exponent \( \alpha_{b/a} \) depends on the position (end or middle). For c - DWNTs, TDOS also shows a similar power - law behavior, but there is an energy gap caused by the inter - shell coupling.

### Formula summary

- **Selection rules**:
\[
\ell_a+(n_a l_1^a + m_a l_2^a)=\ell_b+(n_b l_1^b + m_b l_2^b)\tag{5a}
\]
\[
k_u^a + F(n_a, m_a)=k_u^b + F(n_b, m_b)\tag{5b}
\]
where \( F(n,m)=\frac{2\pi}{3a_0 L(n,m)}((n + 2m)l_1-(2n + m)l_2)\), and \( L(n,m)=\sqrt{n^2 + m^2+nm}\) is the perimeter length of the shell.

- **Elastic scattering mean free path**:
\[
l_{\text{el},b}(E)=v_F\tau_b(E)
\]
where \( \tau_b(E)\) is the lifetime of electrons in shell \( b\) at energy \( E\).

- **Power - law behavior of tunneling density of states**:
\[
\rho_{b/a}(\varepsilon)\sim |\varepsilon|^{\alpha_{b/a}}
\]
The specific exponent \( \alpha_{b/a}\) can be further subdivided according to the position (end or middle):
\[
\alpha_{\text{end},b/a}=\frac{1}{4}\sum_{\xi = \pm}A_{b/a}\left(\frac{1}{K_{c+\xi}}- 1\right)
\]
\[
\alpha_{\text{bulk},b/a}=\frac{1}{8}\sum_{