Extragalactic Globular Clusters in the Near-Infrared: V. IC 4051 and NGC 3311

M. Hempel,D. Geisler,D.W. Hoard,W.E. Harris
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20041857
2005-05-06
Abstract:We present the results of combined optical and near-infrared photometry for the globular cluster systems of the giant ellipticals IC 4051 and NGC 3311. We use the reduced age-metallicity degeneracy in (V-I) vs.(V-H) color-color diagrams to derive the cumulative age distribution within the red sub-population of globular clusters and to search for age sub-populations. The age distribution is then compared to the one determined for simulated globular cluster systems in order to set constraints on the relative age and size of these globular cluster sub-populations. In both galaxies we find a significant fraction of globular clusters with ages between 2- 5 Gyr. We also investigate the metallicity distribution in both systems. Small number statistics prevent us from making any definite statements concerning NGC 3311, but we find that the derived metallicity distribution of the IC 4051 clusters strongly depends on the assumed age distribution. Based on our most likely result that finds a large number of young/intermediate age clusters (~2 Gyr) within the selected globular cluster sample, we find metallicity peaks at $\sim$ -0.2 for the old clusters and +0.8 for the young clusters. Only few very metal poor clusters are found. However, the metallicity distribution within the young/intermediate globular cluster population is significantly affected by our choice of the applied Single Stellar Population model. The mean metallicity of the second generation of globular clusters changes from the above mentioned and extremely high +0.8 dex to +0.2 dex. Note that the model dependency becomes less severe with an increasing age of the cluster population.
Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve include: 1. **Determining the age distribution of the globular cluster system in galaxies**: By combining optical and near - infrared photometry, the author attempts to overcome the age - metallicity degeneracy in order to derive the cumulative age distribution of the red - subpopulation globular clusters in two giant elliptical galaxies, IC 4051 and NGC 3311, and look for subgroups of different ages. 2. **Studying the metallicity distribution**: Besides the age distribution, the author also explores the metallicity distribution of the globular clusters in these two galaxies. For IC 4051, they find that the metallicity distribution strongly depends on the assumed age distribution. 3. **Comparing simulation and observation results**: The author compares the observed age distribution with the simulated globular cluster system to constrain the relative ages and sizes of these globular cluster subgroups. 4. **Exploring the influence of the environment on the globular cluster system**: By selecting two galaxies located in different environmental densities (IC 4051 is in a low - density environment, while NGC 3311 is in a high - density environment), the author hopes to start exploring the influence of environmental density on the globular cluster system. ### Specific problems - **Determination of age distribution**: The author uses the (V−I) vs. (V−H) color - color diagram to derive the age distribution of globular clusters. The formula is as follows: \[ (V - H)_{\text{aperture}} = 0.983 (V - H)_{\text{psf}}+ 0.015 \] This relationship is used to correct the differences between different photometric methods. - **Analysis of metallicity distribution**: Through near - infrared data, the author can measure the metallicity more accurately. For example, for IC 4051, they use the following conversion formula to convert the photometric data of the F160W filter into the standard H - band photometric data: \[ H = F160W - 0.115 \, (\pm 0.048) \, \text{mag} \] - **Influence of model dependence**: The author discusses the influence of different single - stellar - population models (SSP models) on the results. For example, the results using the Bruzual & Charlot (2003) and Maraston (2005) models show that for clusters older than 1 Gyr, the difference between the two models is small. Through these analyses, the author hopes to reveal the formation history of the globular cluster systems in these two galaxies and the evolution process of their host galaxies.