Abstract:Abstract Fragility, quantifying the rapidity of variation of relaxation times, is analysed for a series of model glass formers, which differ in the softness of their interparticle interactions. In an attempt to rationalize experimental observations in colloidal suspensions that softer interactions lead to stronger (less fragile) glass formers, we study the variation of relaxation dynamics with density, rather than temperature, as a control parameter. We employ density-temperature scaling, analyzed in recent studies, to address the question. We find that while employing inverse density in place of temperature leads to the conclusion that softer interactions lead to stronger behaviour, the use of scaled variables involving temperature and density lead to the opposite conclusion, similarly to earlier investigations where temperature variation of relaxation dynamics was analysed for the same systems. We rationalize our results by considering the Adam-Gibbs (AG) fragility, which incorporates the density dependence of the configurational entropy and an activation energy that may arise from other properties of a glass former. Within the framework of the Adam-Gibbs relation, by employing density temperature scaling for the analysis, we find that softer particles make more fragile glasses, as deduced from dynamical quantities, which is found to be consistent with the Adam-Gibbs fragility.Graphical abstract We analyse fragility, which quantifies the rapidity of variation of relaxation times, using density as the control variable, for model glass formers with varying softness of interactions. Using scaled variables, we find – and rationalise thermodynamically by computing configurational entropy – that fragility increases with softness, contrary to previous work.

Why liquids are fragile

A thermodynamic connection to the fragility of glass-forming liquids

Density dependence of relaxation dynamics in glass formers, and the dependence of their fragility on the softness of inter-particle interactions

Relation of the Fragility and Heat Capacity Jump in the Supercooled Liquid Region with the Shear Modulus Relaxation in Metallic Glasses.

Correlation of Fragility of Supercooled Liquids with Elastic Properties of Glasses

Why Is the Range of Timescale So Wide in Glass-Forming Liquid?

The Correlation Between Fragility, Density, and Atomic Interaction in Glass-Forming Liquids

Temperature Dependence of Structural Relaxation in Glass-Forming Liquids and Polymers

Universal behavior of the apparent fragility in ultraslow glass forming systems

Revealing the role of molecular rigidity on the fragility evolution of glass-forming liquids

Probabilistic interpretation of liquid fragility

Universal correlations between the fragility and interparticle repulsion of glass-forming liquids

Liquid Fragility Calculations from Thermal Analyses for Metallic Glasses

New Experimental Evidence for Thermodynamic Links to the Kinetic Fragility of Glass-Forming Polymers

Kinetic Fragility of Binary and Ternary Glass Forming Liquid Mixtures.

Highlighting the interdependence between volumetric contribution of fragility and cooperativity for polymeric segmental relaxation

The relationship between fragility, configurational entropy and the potential energy landscape of glass-forming liquids

Relationship between particle elasticity, glass fragility, and structural relaxation in dense microgel suspensions

Fragility in glassy liquids: A structural approach based on machine learning

Generalized Entropy Theory Investigation of the Relatively High Segmental Fragility of Many Glass-Forming Polymers

Thermodynamics, kinetics and fragility of bulk metallic glass forming liquids