Low-Temperature Thermal Conductivity of Superconductors With Gap Nodes

Tomas Lofwander,Mikael Fogelstrom

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.95.107006

2005-03-17

Abstract:We report a detailed analytic and numerical study of electronic thermal conductivity in d-wave superconductors. We compare theory of the cross over at low temperatures from T-dependence to T^3-dependence for increasing temperature with recent experiments on YBCO in zero magnetic field for temperatures from 0.04K to 0.4K by Hill et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 027001 (2004). Transport theory, including impurity scattering and inelastic scattering within strong coupling superconductivity, can consistently fit the temperature dependence of the data in the lower half of the temperature regime. We discuss the conditions under which we expect power-law dependences over wide temperature intervals.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the behavior of electron thermal conductivity in high - temperature superconductors at low temperatures, especially in the case of the existence of gap nodes in d - wave superconductors. Specifically, the authors focus on:

1. **Temperature Dependence**: To study the transition of electron thermal conductivity from the linear dependence on low temperature \(T\) (\(T\)-dependence) to the \(T^{3}\) dependence at higher temperatures.
2. **Fitting of Experimental Data**: To explain and fit the experimental data obtained by Hill et al. on the YBa\(_2\)Cu\(_3\)O\(_7\) material [12] through theoretical calculations. These experimental data show the behavior of electron thermal conductivity in the temperature range \(T\in[0.04K, 0.4K]\) under zero magnetic field.
3. **Influence of Scattering Mechanisms**: To explore the influence of elastic impurity scattering and inelastic scattering on thermal conductivity, and analyze the dominant role of different scattering mechanisms in different temperature intervals.

### Specific Problem Description

- **Transition of Temperature Dependence**: The paper attempts to explain why at extremely low temperatures, the thermal conductivity shows a linear dependence on temperature, while at higher temperatures it shows a \(T^{3}\) dependence. This transition is closely related to the existence of gap nodes and scattering mechanisms.

- **Theoretical Explanation of Experimental Data**: The paper aims to explain the experimentally observed thermal conductivity behavior, especially the variation law of electron thermal conductivity with temperature, through a theoretical model. The form of thermal conductivity observed in the experiment is:
\[
\frac{\kappa_{\text{el}}(T)}{T}=\left(\frac{\kappa_0}{T}\right)(1 + kT^{2})
\]
where \(\frac{\kappa_0}{T}=0.16\,\text{mW}/(\text{K}^{2}\cdot\text{cm})\) and the coefficient \(k = 19.2\,\text{K}^{-2}\).

- **Role of Scattering Mechanisms**: The paper discusses in detail the influence of different types of scattering mechanisms (such as elastic impurity scattering and inelastic scattering) on thermal conductivity. In particular, the authors explore which scattering mechanism is dominant in different temperature ranges, and explain why power - law behavior can be observed in some temperature intervals, while it is difficult to observe in other temperature intervals.

### Main Conclusions

- **Influence of Inelastic Scattering**: Inelastic scattering has a significant influence on the behavior of thermal conductivity when \(T\rightarrow0\), but has no influence on the coefficient of the \(T^{3}\) term.
- **Fitting of Experimental Data**: The paper successfully fits the large slope \(k = 19.2\,\text{K}^{-2}\) in the experimental data, indicating that the sample is relatively clean and the scattering phase shift is slightly below the unitary limit.
- **Limitations of Applicable Range**: The validity of Sommerfeld expansion is limited and only applicable to a relatively narrow low - temperature interval. Therefore, in the higher - temperature interval, there are deviations between theoretical and experimental results.

In summary, through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, this paper deeply explores the temperature dependence of electron thermal conductivity in d - wave superconductors and the underlying physical mechanisms.