Abstract: It is known that four-dimensional cosmologies exhibiting transient phases of acceleration can be obtained by compactifications of low-energy effective string or M-theory on time-varying manifolds. In the four-dimensional theory, the acceleration can be attributed to a quintessential scalar field with a positive effective potential. Recently, Townsend has conjectured that the potentials obtained by such compactifications cannot give rise to late-time accelerating universes which possess future event horizons. Such a `no-go' result would be desirable, since current string or M-theory seems unable to provide an adequate description of space-times with future event horizons. In this letter, we provide a proof of this conjecture for a class of warped compactifications with a single scalar modulus parametrising the volume of the compactification manifold.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify and prove Townsend's conjecture, that is, in the cosmological models obtained from the low - energy effective string theory or M - theory compactifications, it is impossible to produce a late - time acceleratingly expanding universe with a future event horizon. Specifically, the author attempts to prove that for a certain class of warped compactifications, in the case of a single scalar modulus parameterizing the volume of the compact manifold, a universe that leads to late - time accelerating expansion and has a future event horizon cannot be obtained.
### Specific Problem Description
1. **Background and Motivation**:
- Current observations indicate that the universe is undergoing accelerating expansion, but the nature and origin of the "dark energy" driving this accelerating expansion are still unclear.
- A popular candidate is a scalar field with positive potential energy, also known as quintessence.
- Although it is possible to construct potential energies of arbitrary forms to achieve temporary or eternal accelerating expansion, deriving suitable potential energies from more fundamental theories such as string theory or M - theory remains a challenge.
2. **Existing Theoretical Limitations**:
- There is a "no - go theorem" which states that if the strong energy condition (SEC) is satisfied in a high - dimensional theory, then SEC must also be satisfied in the four - dimensional theory after compactification. This excludes the possibility of accelerating expansion because accelerating expansion requires violating SEC.
- Townsend and Wohlfarth discovered a way to bypass this no - go theorem. By considering time - dependent hyperbolic compactification manifolds, a brief accelerating phase can be obtained.
3. **Townsend's Conjecture**:
- Townsend further proposed that in the cosmological models obtained from the low - energy effective string theory or M - theory compactifications, it is impossible to produce a late - time acceleratingly expanding universe with a future event horizon.
- This situation is particularly important because current string theory or M - theory seems unable to provide a sufficient description of spacetimes with a future event horizon.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
- The author provides a proof of the above - mentioned conjecture, which is applicable to a certain class of warped compactifications, which contains a scalar modulus parameterizing the volume of the compact manifold.
- By analyzing the equations in the four - dimensional universe, the author proves that if the potential energy \( V(\phi) \) satisfies the condition \( V' \leq -\sqrt{\frac{n + 2}{n}} V \), then there will be no late - time acceleratingly expanding universe with a future event horizon.
### Key Formulas
- Potential energy condition: \[ V' \leq -\sqrt{\frac{n + 2}{n}} V \]
- Equation of the four - dimensional universe: \[ \ddot{S}=\frac{1}{6}(-\dot{\phi}^2 + V) \]
- Equation of the scalar field: \[ \ddot{\phi}=-3\frac{\dot{\phi}\dot{S}}{S}-V' \]
Through these analyses, the author proves that in the cosmological models obtained from the low - energy effective string theory or M - theory compactifications, it is indeed impossible to produce a late - time acceleratingly expanding universe with a future event horizon, thus supporting Townsend's conjecture.