Energy-Momentum of a regular MMaS-class black hole

Owen Patashnick
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218271805007413
2005-06-24
Abstract: We compute the energy and momentum of a regular black hole of type defined by Mars, Martin-Prats, and Senovilla using the Einstein and Papapetrou definitions for energy-momentum density. Some other definitions of energy-momentum density are shown to give mutually contradictory and less reasonable results. Results support the Cooperstock hypothesis.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to find a reasonable local energy - momentum density definition in general relativity. Specifically, the author calculates the energy and momentum distributions of a class of regular black holes (i.e., black holes without singularities) defined by Mars, Martín - Prats, and Senovilla. By using the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein and Papapetrou, the author shows that these calculation results are consistent with physical intuition. Meanwhile, the paper also compares several other energy - momentum complex definitions (such as the definitions of Landau - Lifshitz and Møller), pointing out that the results they give are either contradictory to each other or unreasonable in some cases. These results support the Cooperstock hypothesis, that is, energy is localized in the regions where the energy - momentum tensor is non - zero. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Calculate the energy and momentum of specific types of regular black holes**: - Using the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein and Papapetrou, calculate the energy and momentum distributions of a class of regular black holes. - The results show that these calculation results are consistent with physical expectations. 2. **Compare different energy - momentum complex definitions**: - Compare the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein, Papapetrou, Landau - Lifshitz, and Møller. - It is found that the definitions of Landau - Lifshitz and Møller give unreasonable or contradictory results in some cases. 3. **Support the Cooperstock hypothesis**: - The Cooperstock hypothesis believes that energy is localized in the regions where the energy - momentum tensor is non - zero. - The results of this paper support this hypothesis and further verify the rationality of the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein and Papapetrou. ### Specific content of the paper - **Introduction part**: - Introduce the importance of the energy - momentum localization problem in general relativity. - Review the early methods of defining energy - momentum density and their existing problems. - **Black hole model**: - Describe the metric form of a class of regular black holes defined by Mars, Martín - Prats, and Senovilla. - Give the specific function forms and discuss the conditions satisfied by these functions. - **Energy - momentum calculation**: - Using the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein and Papapetrou, calculate in detail the energy and momentum distributions of black holes. - Compare the energy - momentum complex definitions of Landau - Lifshitz and Møller and point out their deficiencies. - **Conclusion**: - Summarize the research results and emphasize the rationality of the energy - momentum complex definitions of Einstein and Papapetrou. - Discuss the physical meaning of the Cooperstock hypothesis and its influence on gravitational wave detection. ### Formula display - **Einstein energy - momentum complex**: \[ \Theta^i_k=\frac{1}{16\pi}H^{kl}_{i,l} \] where, \[ H^{kl}_i = - H^{lk}_i = g_{in}\sqrt{-g}\left[-g(g^{kn}g^{lm}-g^{ln}g^{km})\right]_{,m} \] - **Landau - Lifshitz energy - momentum complex**: \[ L^i_k=\frac{1}{16\pi}\lambda^{iklm}_{,lm} \] where, \[ \lambda^{iklm}=-g(g^{ik}g^{lm}-g^{il}g^{km}) \] - **Møller energy - momentum complex**: \[ J^i_k=\frac{1}{8\pi}J^{kl}_{i,l} \] where, \[ J^{kl}_i=\sqrt{-g}(g^{ia}_{,b}-g^{ib}_{,a})g^{kb}g^{la} \] - **Papapetrou energy - momentum complex**