The pair $(\aleph_n,\aleph_0)$ may fail $\aleph_0$--compactness

Saharon Shelah
2004-04-13
Abstract: Let P be a distinguished unary predicate and
Logic
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore specific model - theoretical problems, especially the compactness of two - cardinal models under certain conditions. Specifically, the author Saharon Shelah attempts to prove the existence of a model in which, for the specific cardinal pair \((\aleph_n, \aleph_0)\), \(\aleph_0\)-compactness may not hold. #### Specific problem description 1. **Research background**: - Since the early days of model theory, people have been interested in two - cardinal models. These models are generalizations of the Löwenheim - Skolem theorem. - Previous research has shown that under certain conditions, specific cardinal pairs have compactness. For example, Mostowski [Mo57] studied problems related to generalized quantifiers. 2. **Main problems**: - The core problem of the article is to explore whether there exists a model \(M\) such that for some natural number \(n\) and the cardinal pair \((\aleph_n, \aleph_0)\), the model is not \(\aleph_0\)-compact. - More specifically, Shelah attempts to prove that: for \(n = 4\), there exists a countable first - order theory \(T\) such that \(T\) has no model in \(K\), but every finite subset of \(T\) has a model in \(K\). Here \(K\) is the set of all models with cardinality \(\aleph_n\) and the cardinality of their \(P\) subsets is \(\aleph_0\). 3. **Key results**: - The main theorem shows that under certain assumptions (such as \(2^{\aleph_0}\geq\aleph_n\)), the cardinal pair \((\aleph_n, \aleph_0)\) may not be \(\aleph_0\)-compact, especially for \(n\geq4\). - This result is achieved by constructing a specific forcing method, which adds a special class of coloring functions that satisfy certain 2 - identities while destroying other identities. ### Summary The main goal of this paper is to prove that for the specific cardinal pair \((\aleph_n, \aleph_0)\), especially in the case of \(n = 4\), there exists a model such that this cardinal pair is not \(\aleph_0\)-compact. This conclusion is proved by the ingenious application of the forcing method and reveals some deep - seated problems in model theory and set theory.