The Narrow Theta(1543)--A QCD Dilemma: Tube or Not Tube?

Aharon Casher,Shmuel Nussinov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2003.10.041
2003-09-18
Abstract:We argue that a width of less than MeV of the new Theta resonance is inconsistent with the observed ratio of resonance and background events in the various photon initiated experiments if the latter can be described by K, K*, etc., exchange. An evaluation of the Feynman diagrams which were believed to be relevant is presented and supports the general claim in the one case where a cross section has been given by the experimental group. More detailed arguments based on the flux tube model explaining the narrow widths and the apparent conflict with the production rates are presented. We predict narrow Tetra-quarks at mass ~ O(1-1.2 GeV) which the analysis of LEAR may have missed.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve two main problems regarding the newly discovered Θ(1540) resonance state (i.e., the pentaquark state): ### 1. Narrow - width problem The first problem is that the experimentally observed width of the Θ(1540) resonance state is very narrow, much less than 20 MeV. Specifically: \[ \Gamma(\Theta) < 0 \text{ MeV} \] This contradicts the width predicted by the kaon - exchange model. According to the kaon - exchange model, the Θ width inferred from photon - induced reactions should be between 5 - 15 MeV. This contradiction needs to be explained. ### 2. Yield problem The second problem is that in photon - induced experiments, the observed Θ yield seems to require a larger width. However, according to the kaon - exchange model, this yield is inconsistent with the narrow width of Θ. Specifically: \[ \Gamma(\Theta) \sim 5 - 15 \text{ MeV} \] This conflicts with the above narrow - width assumption. ### Discussion of solutions To solve these problems, the author proposes several possible explanations: #### 1. Color - flux - tube model The author introduced the color - flux - tube model to explain the narrow width of Θ. In this model, tetraquark and pentaquark states have complex "color networks", which include junctions and anti - junctions. These structures suppress the decay of Θ, resulting in a very small width. #### 2. Suppression of junction - anti - junction pair creation and annihilation The author also discussed the creation and annihilation processes of junction - anti - junction (J - ¯J) pairs. If these processes are suppressed, then the decay width of Θ will be very small, and its probability of being produced by nucleon collisions will also be very low, which explains the contradiction in the experiment. #### 3. Existence of tetraquark states The author speculates that there may be some narrow tetraquark states with masses of about 1 - 1.2 GeV. These states may have been missed in low - energy proton - antiproton annihilation experiments. If these tetraquark states can be found, it will further support their theory. ### Summary The main purpose of this paper is to explain why the width of the Θ(1540) resonance state is so narrow and how to reconcile this narrow width with the yield observed in experiments. By introducing the color - flux - tube model and discussing the creation and annihilation processes of junction - anti - junction pairs, the author proposes a possible solution.