A Historical Note about how the Property was Discovered that Hydrogenated Substances Increase the Radioactivity Induced by Neutrons

Alberto De Gregorio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0309046
2003-09-22
Abstract:At the "Domus Galilaeana" in Pisa, many original documents and records are kept, which belong to the scientific activity carried out by Enrico Fermi until 1938. I compared those documentary sources with the supported evidences, the personal recollections, concerning the discovery that hydrogenated substances increase the radioactivity induced by neutrons: such a comparison leads to the conclusion that the discovery occurred on October 20th 1934, i.e., two days before the date that all the accounts that have been supported so far report. That suggests that any historical study to come, and regarding the experiments carried out by Fermi and his group on neutrons, cannot neglect to analyse carefully the accounts regarding those experiments and to compare them with the archive records.
History and Philosophy of Physics,Nuclear Experiment,Nuclear Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the discovery time and historical background of the property that hydrogenated substances (such as paraffin and water) increase neutron - induced radioactivity. Specifically, the paper explores the following issues: 1. **Determining the discovery date**: By analyzing the original documents stored in Domus Galilæana, the paper aims to determine the specific date when Fermi and his team first discovered that hydrogenated substances can enhance neutron - induced radioactivity. The traditional view holds that this discovery occurred on October 22, 1934, but through detailed comparison of experimental records and personal recollections, the paper presents a different view. 2. **Clarifying experimental details**: The paper not only focuses on the specific discovery date but also attempts to clarify some details in the experimental process. For example, what materials Fermi and his team used in the experiment, how they conducted the experiment, and how they reached their conclusions. 3. **Verifying the accuracy of personal recollections**: The paper compares the recollections of Fermi's team members and their families, including different versions of accounts by Amaldi, Segrè, Pontecorvo, D’Agostino, etc., and verifies the accuracy of these recollections through archival records. ### Main conclusions of the paper Through detailed analysis of the Domus Galilæana archives, the paper reaches the following conclusions: - **The discovery date should be October 20, 1934**, rather than the commonly believed October 22. This conclusion is based on the explicit dates in notebook B.1 and other experimental records. - **Consistency of the experimental process**: From October 20 to 22, Fermi's team conducted multiple experiments, each using a similar method, that is, soaking the sample in water or shielding it with paraffin to observe the change in neutron - induced radioactivity. - **Importance of archival records**: The paper emphasizes the importance of archival records in historical research, pointing out that even the consistent statements of multiple witnesses need to be verified through original documents. ### Scientific background involved Fermi and his team conducted a large number of experiments on neutron - induced artificial radioactivity in 1934. They found that when using hydrogenated substances (such as paraffin and water), the efficiency of the interaction between neutrons and target substances was significantly increased. This discovery is of great significance for understanding the interaction mechanism between neutrons and matter and lays the foundation for subsequent nuclear reaction research. ### Summary Through meticulous analysis of historical archives, the paper corrects the traditional view on the discovery date of hydrogenated substances enhancing neutron - induced radioactivity and emphasizes the crucial role of archival records in the history of scientific research. This work not only helps to restore historical facts more accurately but also provides valuable references for future related research.