Self Calibration in Cluster Studies of Dark Energy: Combining the Cluster Redshift Distribution, the Power Spectrum and Mass Measurements

Subhabrata Majumdar,Joseph J. Mohr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/422829

2003-05-20

Abstract:We examine the prospects for measuring the dark energy equation of state parameter w within the context of any uncertain redshift evolution of galaxy cluster structure (building on Majumdar and Mohr, 2003) and show that including the redshift averaged cluster power spectrum, P_cl(k), and direct mass measurements of 100 clusters helps tremendously in reducing cosmological parameter uncertainties. Specifically, we show that when combining the redshift distribution and the power spectrum information for a particular X-ray survey (DUET) and two SZE surveys (SPT & Planck), the constraints on the dark energy equation of state w can be improved by roughly a factor of 4. Because surveys designed to study the redshift distribution of clusters will have all the information necessary to construct P_cl(k), the benefit of adding P_cl(k) in reducing uncertainties comes at no additional observational cost. Combining detailed mass studies of 100 clusters with the redshift distribution improves the parameter uncertainties by a factor of 3-5. The data required for these detailed mass measurements-- assumed to have 1sigma uncertainties of 30-- are accumulating in the the XMM-Newton and Chandra archives. The best constraints are obtained when one combines both the power spectrum constraints and mass measurements with the cluster redshift distribution; when using the survey to extract the parameters and evolution of the mass--observable relations, we estimate the uncertainties on w of ~4% to 6%. These parameter constraints are obtained from self-calibrating cluster surveys alone. In combination with CMB or distance measurements that have different parameter degeneracies, cluster studies of dark energy will provide enhanced constraints and allow for cross--checks of systematics.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to improve the constraint on the dark energy equation - of - state parameter \( w \) by combining the redshift distribution, power spectrum, and mass measurement of galaxy clusters, thereby reducing the uncertainty of cosmological parameters. Specifically, the author explores how, in the context of the uncertain redshift evolution of galaxy cluster structures, adding the average redshift power spectrum \( \bar{P}_{\text{cl}} \) and direct mass measurements (for example, 100 galaxy clusters) can significantly improve the constraint accuracy of the dark energy equation - of - state parameter \( w \).

### Background and Problem Description of the Paper

1. **Galaxy Clusters and Dark Energy Research**
- The number density of galaxy clusters is very sensitive to the amplitude of the initial Gaussian fluctuations, which makes them an important tool for studying dark energy.
- By measuring the change in the number density or abundance of galaxy clusters with redshift, the equation - of - state parameter \( w = p/\rho \) of dark energy can be constrained.

2. **Existing Challenges**
- If the uncertainty of the evolution of galaxy cluster structures with redshift is not considered, the constraint on \( w \) will be greatly weakened.
- It is necessary to combine multiple observables (such as redshift distribution, power spectrum, and mass measurement) to overcome these uncertainties.

### Solutions

1. **Introducing the Average Power Spectrum \( \bar{P}_{\text{cl}} \)**
- The average power spectrum \( \bar{P}_{\text{cl}} \) is derived from the correlated positions of galaxy clusters in the survey, and it provides information about the underlying dark matter power spectrum and bias.
- This method does not require additional observational costs because the redshift information required for the redshift distribution is sufficient to construct \( \bar{P}_{\text{cl}} \).

2. **Combining Mass Measurements**
- Detailed mass measurements of 100 galaxy clusters can further reduce parameter uncertainties.
- These data have been accumulated in the XMM - Newton and Chandra archives.

3. **Self - Calibration Method**
- Combining redshift distribution, power spectrum, and mass measurement can make galaxy cluster surveys essentially self - calibrated, that is, contain enough information to solve the mass - observable relationship at each redshift and constrain cosmological parameters.

### Main Conclusions

- When combining redshift distribution and power spectrum information, the constraint on \( w \) can be improved by about 4 times.
- When combining detailed mass measurements, the parameter uncertainty can be improved by 3 - 5 times.
- The best constraint can be obtained by using power spectrum constraints and mass measurements simultaneously, with an estimated uncertainty of \( w \) being 4% - 6%.

Through this method, galaxy cluster surveys can not only provide independent cosmological constraints but also be combined with other measurements (such as CMB or distance measurements) to enhance the constraints and allow cross - checking of systematic errors.