Abstract:I propose an adaptationist theory of cosmological natural selection with intelligence (CNSI) that corrects an apparent error in Smolin’s theory of cosmological natural selection (Smolin’s CNS). Smolin’s CNS is a mostly reasonable extension of speculative yet conventional cosmological ideas, such as that we live in a multiverse and that black holes generate new universes by leading to big bang-like events. It extends these ideas by noting that if some universe types were particularly capable of producing new universes that were similar to themselves (i.e. at reproducing), then they would become particularly well represented in the multiverse; in other words, universes may evolve via Darwinian selection. Smolin’s CNS seems to err, however, in identifying black holes as the aspect of the universal ‘phenotype’ that is most likely to constitute an adaptation for universe reproduction. The error stems from overlooking what could be considered the ‘first law of Darwinian adaptation’: aspects of a phenotype that exhibit more improbable complexity are more likely to be adaptations. Because intelligent life exhibits higher improbable complexity (and therefore lower entropy) than black holes, it is more likely than black holes to be an adaptation for universe reproduction. From this perspective, biological evolution would represent a developmental subroutine of cosmological evolution, and the ultimate function of intelligent life would be to develop the knowledge and technology that would ultimately enable the universe to reproduce. This simple adaptationist correction to Smolin’s CNS produces a CNSI theory which more thoroughly explains the existence of complexity in our universe, because it directly accounts for not just non-biological order but biological order as well. Scientifically, the adaptationist framework of CNSI could be useful for facilitating conceptual integration between biology and physics. Philosophically, this framework is notable especially for implying that life serves a fundamental ‘purpose’ and that ‘moral progress’ can be objectively, if only broadly, defined.

Cosmological Natural Selection Revisited. Some Remarks on the Conceptual Conundrum and Possible Alleys

Implications of the Reduction Principle for Cosmological Natural Selection

Cosmology of self-replicating universes in black holes formed by dark matter-seeded stellar collapse

Cosmological Natural Selection and the Function of Life

On the black hole species (by means of natural selection)

Computational and Biological Analogies for Understanding Fine-Tuned Parameters in Physics

Cosmological inhomogeneities, primordial black holes, and a hypothesis on the death of the universe

A note on the black hole information paradox in de Sitter spacetimes

Anthropic Selection for a Low-Entropy Past

Regular Black Holes: Towards a New Paradigm of Gravitational Collapse

Embedding Black Holes and Other Inhomogeneities in the Universe in Various Theories of Gravity: A Short Review

Is nature natural?

Reconsidering the logical structure of the theory of natural selection

Black Holes at Future Colliders and Beyond: a Topical Review

Black holes reconsidered

The black hole challenge in Randall-Sundrum II model

Einstein, tea leaves, meandering rivers, and the origin of supermassive black holes in ekpyrotic universe

Reevaluating the Cosmological Origin of Dark Matter

Ontological Categorizations and Selection Biases in Cosmology: the case of Extra Galactic Objects

Black holes embedded in FLRW cosmologies