Diffusive grain-surface chemistry involving the atoms and diatomic molecules of two elements

J.G.L. Rae,N.J.B. Green,T.W. Hartquist,M.J. Pilling,T. Toniazzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20030415

2003-03-31

Abstract:A model of the grain surface chemistry involving the accretion of atoms of two different elements, X and Y, and their reactions to form species X_2, XY, and Y_2 was examined for a wide range of choices for the values of its three free parameters - the accretion rate of X and Y, the desorption rate of X and the grain surface sweeping time of Y, all considered relative to the grain surface sweeping rate of X. Relative production rates of the diatomics were calculated with five methods involving, respectively, a high-order truncation of the master equation, a low-order truncation of the master equation, the standard deterministic rate equation approach, a modified rate equation approach and a set of approximations which are in some cases appropriate for accretion dominated chemistry. The accuracies of the relative production rates calculated with the different methods were assessed for the wide range of model parameters. The more accurate of the low-truncation master equation calculations and the standard deterministic rate equation approach gives results which are in most cases within ten or twenty per cent of the results given by the high-truncation master equation calculations. For many cases, the more accurate of the low order truncation and the standard deterministic rate equation approaches is indicated by a consideration of the average number of atoms of the two species on the grain's surface.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to study and compare the accuracy and applicability of different methods in simulating chemical reactions on the surfaces of interstellar dust grains. Specifically, it examines the processes of adsorption, diffusion, and formation of binary molecules (such as \( X_2 \), \( XY \), and \( Y_2 \)) of atoms of two different elements (denoted as X and Y) on the surfaces of dust grains.

#### Main research contents:
1. **Model parameters**: Three main free parameters are considered in the paper:
- The accretion rates of X and Y.
- The desorption rate of X.
- The sweeping time of Y relative to X.

2. **Method comparison**: The author uses five different methods to calculate the relative production rates of these binary molecules and evaluate the accuracy of each method. These five methods include:
- High - order truncation of the master equation.
- Low - order truncation of the master equation.
- Standard deterministic rate equation approach.
- Modified rate equation approach.
- Approximations suitable for accretion - dominated chemistry.

3. **Result evaluation**: Evaluate the accuracy of the other four methods by comparing the results of the high - order truncation of the master equation. Pay special attention to the performance in different parameter ranges to determine which method is more reliable under specific conditions.

#### Research background:
- In some cases, the speed at which species adsorb from the gas phase to the surfaces of dust grains is faster than the speed at which they diffuse and react on the surfaces. This case is called the "reaction limit".
- In other cases, the speed at which species diffuse and react on the surfaces is faster than the adsorption speed. In this case, it is called the "adsorption limit". In this situation, the number of reactive species on each grain on average is small, and a stochastic model needs to be used for description.

#### Research purposes:
- Through simulations over a wide range of parameters, understand the performance of different methods in dealing with chemical reactions on the surfaces of interstellar dust grains, especially their applicability and accuracy under different conditions.
- Provide a reasonable combination of methods so that the abundances of \( X_2 \), \( XY \), and \( Y_2 \) can be predicted relatively accurately in practical applications.

In summary, the goal of this paper is to find the most accurate and practical method for simulating chemical reactions on the surfaces of interstellar dust grains under different physical conditions through detailed comparison of different mathematical models and methods.