Frank Kasper Phases of Squishable Spheres and Optimal Cell Models 1
C.-H. Hsu,J.,Wang,S. Mei,X. Dong,Y. Li,H. Liu,W. Zhang,T. Aida,W. B. Zhang,K. Yue,S. Z. D. Cheng,C. Lieghton,F. S. Bates,N. Xie,W. Li,F. Qui,A.-C. Shi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36471/jccm_january_2016_01
2016-01-01
Abstract:1) Selective assemblies of giant tetrahedra via precisely controlled interactions, Optimal sphere packings as models of matter date back to Kepler [1], who conjectured that hexagonally-close packed structures (e.g. FCC, HCP lattices) are maximal-density arrangements of rigid spheres. That conjecture is now proven to be correct [2] and generally accepted to explain the stability of hexagonally-close packed order in many materials, from colloids to metals. By comparison, understanding the optimal packing of highly-deformable, squishable spheres, and its implications for self-organized soft matter, remains an active area of inquiry. Consider a schematic of squishable spherical domains, self-assembled from many amphiphillic block copolymer molecules, shown in Fig. 1A. In neat systems, where solvent is unavailable to fill gaps, idealized spheres must be deformed, squished, to fill the interstitial voids and distribute mass roughly evenly throughout the volume, as is generically favored by van der Waals forces. The resulting structure is composed of self-assembled domains occupying lower symmetry cells, related to the Voronoi cells of the lattice. Finding the optimal lattice therefore reduces to problem of determining the space-filing polyhedra that minimize the free energy cost to squish the ideally-spherical assembly into the appropriate set of lower symmetry, polyhedral cells. What is that cost? In 2000, Ziherl and Kamien proposed that a natural term in that cost is proportional to the area of those cells [3], and hence, with the additional assumption of constant cell volume, that optimal soft sphere lattices can related to optimal dry foams. As a standard measure, consider the reduced area A(X) = A(X)/A Sph , where A(X) is the area of the polyhedral cells of partition X and A Sph is the area of an equal-volume sphere (such that A(X) > 1). In 1994, Weaire and Phelan showed that the equal-volume partition provided by the A15 lattice has the lowest known area with A(A15) = 1.0935 [4]. Based on Weaire and Phelan's result–which disproved Kelvin's conjecture that BCC optimizes cell area (A(BCC) = 1.0973) and stands to this day–Ziherl and Kamien developed a heuristic model to rationalize the appearance of A15 lattice in amphiphilic dendron assemblies [5]. Recent studies of a broader class of assemblies shed new light on this optimal cell shape argument and the ability of soft systems, more generally, to form lattice symmetries beyond those typically encountered in single component systems, such as FCC or BCC. A15 belongs to a class of lattices known as …