The Energy-Entropy Principle

Rodrigo de Abreu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0207022
2002-07-05
Abstract:In this paper, through a criticism of what we call the paradigmatic view of thermodynamics, we aim at showing a new perspective attained in this matter. The generalization of heat as internal energy (generalization of the kinetic energy concept of heat) permits the generalization of the Kelvin postulate: "It is impossible, without another effect, to convert internal energy into work" (no reference to heat or to heat reservoir).
General Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the inconsistencies and difficulties in thermodynamic concepts and expressions, especially the criticism of the traditional thermodynamic paradigmatic view. Specifically: 1. **Is thermodynamics an independent physical field?** The author questions whether thermodynamics can be completely defined relying on the concept of heat, and proposes internal energy as a broader basis. 2. **The concept of heat in the first law of thermodynamics**: The author believes that introducing heat ($dQ$) as a quantity independent of internal energy will lead to confusion, especially in expressions related to quasi - static and reversible processes. 3. **The re - formulation of the second law of thermodynamics**: The author attempts to generalize the Kelvin postulate, that is, "it is impossible to completely convert internal energy into work without other effects", by regarding heat as part of the internal energy. 4. **Terminological conflicts and errors**: The author points out that there are multiple different meanings when using the term "heat", which leads to conceptual confusion. For example, the difference between "heat exchange" (Heat II) and "change in internal energy" (Heat I). 5. **Microscopic explanation**: The author also explores how to understand the second law of thermodynamics from a microscopic perspective, especially when dealing with irreversible processes, emphasizing the correct expression of entropy change. ### Summary of main problems - **The unity of thermodynamic concepts**: The author hopes to eliminate the contradictions between thermodynamics and other physical fields (such as mechanics), especially by re - defining the relationship between heat and internal energy. - **The expressions of thermodynamic laws**: The author attempts to make the expressions of the first and second laws of thermodynamics more consistent and clear by eliminating heat as an independent concept. - **Avoiding terminological confusion**: The author suggests clearly distinguishing the concept of "heat" in different situations to avoid misunderstandings in theory and practical applications. Through these efforts, the author aims to provide a new perspective to make the basic concepts of thermodynamics more rigorous and easier to understand.