Theoretical understanding of pion production in nucleon-nucleon collisions - a status report

C. Hanhart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812791351_0040

2002-07-05

Abstract:A status report is given for the current theoretical understanding of pion production close to threshold. In the first part of the talk predictions of a meson exchange model are compared to recent polarized data for the reactions $pp \to pp\pi^0$ as well as $pp\to pn\pi^+$ revealing, that the former reaction is badly described whereas the predictions for the latter turn out to be consistent with the data. Recent progress in the application of chiral perturbation theory allows to understand this difference.

Nuclear Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the theoretical understanding of pion production in nucleon - nucleon collisions near the threshold. Specifically, the paper mainly focuses on the following points:

1. **Differences between theoretical models and experimental data**: Early experimental data showed that in the near - threshold case, the total cross - section of the pp→ppπ0 reaction is 5 to 10 times lower than the results predicted by existing theoretical models. This indicates that the existing theoretical models have significant deficiencies in describing this specific reaction.

2. **Differences in the performance of different reaction channels**: For different pion - production reaction channels (for example, pp→pnπ+ and pp→dπ+), the performance of theoretical models varies. Some channels (such as pp→pnπ+) can describe the experimental data relatively well, while other channels (such as pp→ppπ0) cannot accurately predict the experimental results.

3. **Understanding by introducing effective field theory (EFT)**: In order to better understand these differences, researchers introduced effective field theory, especially chiral perturbation theory. Through this method, researchers hope to explain why some reaction channels (such as pp→ppπ0) are difficult to be accurately described by existing models, while other channels (such as pp→pnπ+) can better fit the experimental data.

### Specific problem summary

- **Insufficiency of theoretical models for the pp→ppπ0 reaction**: Early models cannot accurately describe the experimental data of the pp→ppπ0 reaction, especially in the near - threshold case.
- **Differences in different reaction channels**: The theoretical predictions of reaction channels such as pp→pnπ+ and pp→dπ+ are more consistent with the experimental data, while there is a large deviation between the theoretical prediction and the experimental data for the pp→ppπ0 reaction channel.
- **Introduction of chiral perturbation theory**: Through chiral perturbation theory, researchers hope to explain the differences between different reaction channels and improve the theoretical understanding of the pp→ppπ0 reaction.

### Mathematical formulas

The mathematical formulas involved in the discussion mainly include the calculation of scattering cross - sections and the correction terms in chiral perturbation theory. For example, the tree - level diagram and loop - diagram contributions in chiral perturbation theory can be represented by the following formulas:

- Tree - level diagram contributions (Tree - level diagrams):
\[
T_{\text{tree}}=\sum_{i}T_{i}^{\text{tree}}
\]

- Loop - diagram contributions (Loop diagrams):
\[
T_{\text{loop}}=\sum_{j}T_{j}^{\text{loop}}
\]

where \(T_{i}^{\text{tree}}\) and \(T_{j}^{\text{loop}}\) represent the contributions of the \(i\)-th tree - level diagram and the \(j\)-th loop - diagram respectively.

Through these formulas, researchers can more accurately describe the pion - production mechanisms in different reaction channels and explain the differences between theory and experiment.