Social Percolation and the Influence of Mass Media

Ana Proykova,Dietrich Stauffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371%2802%2900964-0

2002-03-19

Abstract:Mass media shift the percolative phase transition observed in the marketing model of Solomon and Weisbuch.

Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Social Percolation

Sorin Solomon,Gerard Weisbuch

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371%2899%2900543-9

1999-08-28

Abstract:We introduce the simplest model which relates the emergence of collective social/economic phenomena to the existence of a (possibly self-organized) percolation transition. We suggest a series of extensions to financial, economic, political systems.

Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems
Detecting and modelling real percolation and phase transitions of information on social media

Jiarong Xie,Fanhui Meng,Jiachen Sun,Xiao Ma,Gang Yan,Yanqing Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-021-01090-z

IF: 24.252

2021-04-01

Nature Human Behaviour

Abstract:It is widely believed that information spread on social media is a percolation process, with parallels to phase transitions in theoretical physics. However, evidence for this hypothesis is limited, as phase transitions have not been directly observed in any social media. Here, through an analysis of 100 million Weibo and 40 million Twitter users, we identify percolation-like spread and find that it happens more readily than current theoretical models would predict. The lower percolation threshold can be explained by the existence of positive feedback in the coevolution between network structure and user activity level, such that more-active users gain more followers. Moreover, this coevolution induces an extreme imbalance in users' influence. Our findings indicate that the ability of information to spread across social networks is higher than expected, with implications for many information-spread problems.

psychology, experimental,neurosciences,multidisciplinary sciences
Opinion dynamics in social networks under the influence of mass media

Haibo Hu,Wenhao Chen,Yixuan Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amc.2024.128976

IF: 4.397

2024-12-01

Applied Mathematics and Computation

Abstract:Mass media and social networks have become the primary channels for people to obtain and share information. The news and information to which people are exposed or that they actively acquire can potentially change their opinions on specific issues. Despite ubiquity, the integrated influence of mass media, social networks and individual characteristics on opinion dynamics is less explored. In this study, we propose a general theoretical framework based on improved voter model for opinion dynamics in social networks, which incorporates media outlets, network structure and individual heterogeneity, and allows us to systematically and analytically study the effect of diverse factors on opinion evolution and final steady state. We find that eventually only the opinions held by media outlets or stubborn agents can survive. The ultimate agents with specific opinions generally consist of four parts: stubborn ones, the agents induced by stubborn ones through network links, the agents directly caused by media outlets, and the agents indirectly induced by the effect of media outlets via network links. The model has abundant dynamic behaviors and can be potentially extended to more complicated but more realistic opinion evolution processes. Our theoretical findings are validated by numerical simulations.

mathematics, applied
A model for cross-cultural reciprocal interactions through mass media

J. C. González-Avella,M. G. Cosenza,M. San Miguel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0051035

2012-12-17

Abstract:We investigate the problem of cross-cultural interactions through mass media in a model where two populations of social agents, each with its own internal dynamics, get information about each other through reciprocal global interactions. As the agent dynamics, we employ Axelrod's model for social influence. The global interaction fields correspond to the statistical mode of the states of the agents and represent mass media messages on the cultural trend originating in each population. Several phases are found in the collective behavior of either population depending on parameter values: two homogeneous phases, one having the state of the global field acting on that population, and the other consisting of a state different from that reached by the applied global field; and a disordered phase. In addition, the system displays nontrivial effects: (i) the emergence of a largest minority group of appreciable size sharing a state different from that of the applied global field; (ii) the appearance of localized ordered states for some values of parameters when the entire system is observed, consisting of one population in a homogeneous state and the other in a disordered state. This last situation can be considered as a social analogue to a chimera state arising in globally coupled populations of oscillators.

Physics and Society,Statistical Mechanics,Social and Information Networks,Chaotic Dynamics
Mass communication, social influence, and consumer behavior: two field experiments

Bernad Batinic,Markus Appel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jasp.12090

2013-06-16

Journal of Applied Social Psychology

Abstract:The present article connects advertising by means of mass communication with social influence processes. Predictions derived from a theoretical model on the impact of mass communication on consumers who were not directly exposed to the message (distant consumers) were tested with two field experiments (Experiment 1: n = 77 participants, n = 261 peers; Experiment 2: n = 97 participants, n = 289 peers). Both studies addressed consumer behavior in the media sector. The results suggest that mass communication changes the behavior of distant consumers, that recipients' opinion leadership enhances the indirect impact of mass communication, and that recipients' consumer behavior mediates the influence of mass communicated messages on distant consumers. The role of word‐of‐mouth is also examined.

psychology, social
Effects of Mass Media action on the Axelrod Model with Social Influence

Arezky H. Rodríguez,Y. Moreno

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.82.016111

2010-02-25

Abstract:The use of {\it dyadic interaction} between agents, in combination with {\it homophily} (the principle that ``likes attract'') in the Axelrod model for the study of cultural dissemination has two important problems: the prediction of monoculture in large societies and an extremely narrow window of noise levels in which diversity with local convergence is obtained. Recently, the inclusion of {\it social influence} has proven to overcome them (A. Flache and M. W. Macey, <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="0808.2710" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/0808.2710">arXiv:0808.2710</a>). Here we extend the Axelrod model with social influence interaction for the study of Mass Media effects through the inclusion of a super-agent which acts over the whole system and has nonnull overlap with each agent of the society. The dependence with different parameters as the initial social diversity, size effects, Mass Media strength and noise is outlined. Our results might be relevant in several socio-economic contexts and for the study of the emergence of collective behavior in complex social systems.

Physics and Society
A Media Sociology for the Networked Public Sphere: The Hierarchy of Influences Model

Stephen D. Reese,Pamela J. Shoemaker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15205436.2016.1174268

2016-05-02

Abstract:We have promoted a hierarchy of influences model for understanding the complex factors shaping media—particularly news—content: from the individual to social-system level. Meanwhile, technology-enabled changes in the media eco-system have shifted old boundaries and encouraged new, more spatially oriented concepts, such as fields and networks. In this essay we revisit our levels-of-analysis perspective, which in the historical context of communication research was a response to the media effects paradigm, and incorporate within the model examples from recent research. We argue that the hierarchical of influences can still take into account new realignments of media and other forces. Emerging spaces in the network public sphere may not fit as easily into the once familiar professional, organizational, and institutional containers, but the new media configurations supporting these spaces must still be understood with reference to a larger framework of power.

communication
Percolation-Based Model of New-Product Diffusion with Macroscopic Feedback Effects

Martin Hohnisch,Sabine Pittnauer,Dietrich Stauffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0308358

2003-08-18

Statistical Mechanics

Abstract:This paper proposes a percolation-based model of new-product diffusion in the spirit of Solomon et al. (2000) and Goldenberg et al. (2000). A consumer buys the new product if she has formed her individual valuation of the product (reservation price) and if this valuation is greater or equal than the price of the product announced by the firm in a given period. Our model differs from previous percolation-based models of new-product diffusion in two respects. First, we consider macroscopic feedback effects affecting the supply or the demand side of the market (or both). Second, a consumer who did not buy the product in the period in which her valuation was formed remains a potential buyer and buys in some later period if and when her individual valuation equals or exceeds the price of the product. Unlike most previous models of new-product diffusion, our framework accounts for the empirical finding of long tails characteristic for early stages of innovation diffusion.
Social Anti-Percolation and Negative Word of Mouth

T. Erez,S. Moldovan,Soloman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-59140-984-7.ch053

2007-01-01

Abstract:Many new products fail, despite preliminary market surveys having determined considerable potential market share. This effect is too systematic to be attributed to bad luck. We suggest an explanation by presenting a new percolation theory model for product propagation, where agents interact over a social network. In our model, agents who do not adopt the product spread negative word of mouth to their neighbors, and so their neighborhood becomes less susceptible to the product. The result is a dramatic increase in the percolation threshold. When the effect of negative word of mouth is strong enough, it is shown to block any product from spreading to a significant fraction of the network. So, rather then being rejected by a large fraction of the agents, the product gets blocked by the rejection of a negligible fraction of the potential market. The rest of the potential buyers do not adopt the product because they are never exposed to it: the negative word of mouth spread by initial rejectors suffocates the diffusion by negatively affecting the immediate neighborhood of the propagation front.
Influence of media on collective debates

Walter Quattrociocchi,Guido Caldarelli,Antonio Scala

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1307.4292

2013-07-16

Physics and Society

Abstract:The information system (T.V., newspapers, blogs, social network platforms) and its inner dynamics play a fundamental role on the evolution of collective debates and thus on the public opinion. In this work we address such a process focusing on how the current inner strategies of the information system (competition, customer satisfaction) once combined with the gossip may affect the opinions dynamics. A reinforcement effect is particularly evident in the social network platforms where several and incompatible cultures coexist (e.g, pro or against the existence of chemical trails and reptilians, the new world order conspiracy and so forth). We introduce a computational model of opinion dynamics which accounts for the coexistence of media and gossip as separated but interdependent mechanisms influencing the opinions evolution. Individuals may change their opinions under the contemporary pressure of the information supplied by the media and the opinions of their social contacts. We stress the effect of the media communication patterns by considering both the simple case where each medium mimics the behavior of the most successful one (in order to maximize the audience) and the case where there is polarization and thus competition among media reported information (in order to preserve and satisfy their segmented audience). Finally, we first model the information cycle as in the case of traditional main stream media (i.e, when every medium knows about the format of all the others) and then, to account for the effect of the Internet, on more complex connectivity patterns (as in the case of the web based information). We show that multiple and polarized information sources lead to stable configurations where several and distant opinions coexist.
Analysis of flows in social media uncovers a new multi-step model of information spread

Matteo Serafino,G. Virginio Clemente,James Flamino,Boleslaw K. Szymanski,Omar Lizardo,Hernan A. Makse

2024-09-02

Abstract:Since the advent of the internet, communication paradigms have continuously evolved, resulting in a present-day landscape where the dynamics of information dissemination have undergone a complete transformation compared to the past. In this study, we challenge the conventional two-step flow model of communication, a long-standing paradigm in the field. Our approach introduces a more intricate multi-step and multi-actor model that effectively captures the complexities of modern information spread. We test our hypothesis by examining the spread of information on the Twitter platform. Our findings support the multi-step and multi-actor model hypothesis. In this framework, influencers (individuals with a significant presence in social media) emerges as new central figures and partially take on the role previously attributed to opinion leaders. However, this does not apply to opinion leaders who adapt and reaffirm their influential position on social media, here defined as opinion-leading influencers. Additionally, we note a substantial number of adopters directly accessing information sources, suggesting a potentialdecline if influence in both opinion leaders and influencers. Finally, we found distinctions in the diffusion patterns of left- and right-leaning groups, indicating variations in the underlying structure of information dissemination across different ideologies.

Physics and Society
The Changing Landscape of Media Communication: An Analysis of the Impact of New Media Marketing on News Consumption and Consumer Behavior

Lanjing Yin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/ijeh.v11i3.14436

2023-11-30

International Journal of Education and Humanities

Abstract:The rapid ascent of new media platforms has orchestrated significant shifts in the landscape of media communication, precipitating profound alterations in the dissemination of information and the shaping of consumer behaviors. This research endeavor seeks to delve meticulously into the intricate repercussions emanating from new media marketing strategies on the dynamic trends of news consumption and consumer behavior. Employing a comprehensive analysis that spans case studies, surveys, and pertinent literature, we aim to unveil the multifaceted and diverse influence wielded by new media in sculpting the intricacies of the contemporary media panorama.
Online Communities and Social Network Structure

Yanhao Wei,Wensi Zhang,Sha Yang,Xi Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3420525

2019-01-01

Abstract:This paper aims to understand the effects of online communities on the network structure and their marketing implications. To account for the fact that communities are not formed exogenously, we model and estimate how they co-evolve with the friendship network. We control for unobserved heterogeneity and homophily by modeling individuals’ latent positions and similarities. Using data from a worldwide Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) Game, we find that individuals’ friendship formation decision and community membership decision reinforce each other. Moreover, model simulation reveals that, under some circumstances, online communities may promote not only within-community ties but also cross-community ties. Here, one important moderating factor is the community stickiness, which is captured by the positive effects of an individual’s number of friends in a community on her probability of staying in that community (instead of switching to a different community). As shown by our simulated diffusion exercises, only a moderately sticky community system promotes cross-community ties and consequently improves information reach. This insight helps social platforms manage online communities more effectively to improve the marketing value of social networks.
Mass media competition and alternative ordering in social dynamics

O. Alvarez-Llamoza,M. G. Cosenza,J. C. Gonzalez-Avella,M. A. Suarez,K. Tucci,P. Valverde

2024-05-08

Abstract:We investigate the collective behavior of a system of social agents subject to the competition between two mass media influences considered as external fields. We study under what conditions either of two mass media with different intensities can impose its message to the majority. In addition to a collective state dominated by the stronger mass media and a disordered phase, we characterize two nontrivial effects as the parameters of the system are varied: (i) the appearance of a majority sharing the state of the weaker mass media, and (ii) the emergence of an alternative ordering in a state different from those of either media. We explore the dependence of both phenomena on the topology of the network of interactions. We show that the presence of long-range interactions rather than random connections is essential for the occurrence of both effects. The model can be extended to include multiple mass media and we illustrate it by considering three mass media fields acting on the system. Nontrivial collective behaviors persist for some ranges of parameters: the weakest mass media can convince the majority, and the system can spontaneously order against all applied fields.

Physics and Society,Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems
Indirect Influence in Social Networks As an Induced Percolation Phenomenon

Jiarong Xie,Xiangrong Wang,Ling Feng,Jin-Hua Zhao,Wenyuan Liu,Yamir Moreno,Yanqing Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2100151119

2022-01-01

Abstract:Percolation theory has been widely used to study phase transitions in network systems. It has also successfully explained various macroscopic spreading phenomena across different fields. Yet, the theoretical frameworks have been focusing on direct interactions among nodes, while recent empirical observations have shown that indirect interactions are common in many network systems like social and ecological networks, among others. By investigating the detailed mechanism of both direct and indirect influence on scientific collaboration networks, here we show that indirect influence can play the dominant role in behavioral influence. To address the lack of theoretical understanding of such indirect influence on the macroscopic behavior of the system, we propose a percolation mechanism of indirect interactions called induced percolation. Surprisingly, our model exhibits a unique anisotropy property. Specifically, directed networks show first-order abrupt transitions as opposed to the second-order continuous transition in the same network structure but with undirected links. A mix of directed and undirected links leads to rich hybrid phase transitions. Furthermore, a unique feature of the nonmonotonic pattern is observed in network connectivities near the critical point. We also present an analytical framework to characterize the proposed induced percolation, paving the way to further understanding network dynamics with indirect interactions.
The Production and Consumption of Social Media

Apostolos Filippas,John Horton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2104.00834

2021-04-02

General Economics

Abstract:We model social media as collections of users producing and consuming content. Users value consuming content, but doing so uses up their scarce attention, and hence they prefer content produced by more able users. Users also value receiving attention, creating the incentive to attract an audience by producing valuable content, but also through attention bartering -- users agree to become each others' audience. Attention bartering can profoundly affect the patterns of production and consumption on social media, explains key features of social media behavior and platform decision-making, and yields sharp predictions that are consistent with data we collect from EconTwitter.
The Evolving Landscape of Public Relations: Media Influence and The Power of Social Media Platforms

Xiangdi Sheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/qbhhq068

2024-04-01

Abstract:This article offers a thorough examination of the relationship between media and public relations by reviewing previous literature. It introduces theories and models in the field of media including a two-way symmetrical model of communication, uses and gratifications theory and corporate social responsibility, highlights the significance of social media which has been rapidly evolving and argues for the strategic incorporation of both conventional and digital platforms. Simultaneously, this paper offers a critique of the excessive integration and commercialization of media and public relations. It contends that news pertaining to public relations may exhibit a limited scope and may mislead audiences. Furthermore, the study proposes recommendations for future research and growth in this field. Through a comprehensive comprehension and strategic utilization of media impact, professionals in the field of public relations are able to adeptly traverse the ever-changing terrain, successfully engage a wide range of audiences, and effectively address a multitude of practical challenges.
Mass media destabilizes the cultural homogeneous regime in Axelrod's model

Lucas R. Peres,José F. Fontanari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/43/5/055003

2009-10-06

Abstract:An important feature of Axelrod's model for culture dissemination or social influence is the emergence of many multicultural absorbing states, despite the fact that the local rules that specify the agents interactions are explicitly designed to decrease the cultural differences between agents. Here we re-examine the problem of introducing an external, global interaction -- the mass media -- in the rules of Axelrod's model: in addition to their nearest-neighbors, each agent has a certain probability $p$ to interact with a virtual neighbor whose cultural features are fixed from the outset. Most surprisingly, this apparently homogenizing effect actually increases the cultural diversity of the population. We show that, contrary to previous claims in the literature, even a vanishingly small value of $p$ is sufficient to destabilize the homogeneous regime for very large lattice sizes.

Physics and Society,Computational Physics
Introduction to statistical physics of media processes: Mediaphysics

Dmitri V. Kuznetsov,Igor Mandel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0506217

2005-06-29

Physics and Society

Abstract:Processes of mass communications in complicated social or sociobiological systems such as marketing, economics, politics, animal populations, etc. as a subject for the special scientific discipline - "mediaphysics" - are considered in its relation with sociophysics. A new statistical physics approach to analyze these phenomena is proposed. A keystone of the approach is an analysis of population distribution between two or many alternatives: brands, political affiliations, or opinions. Relative distances between a state of a "person's mind" and the alternatives are measures of propensity to buy (to affiliate, or to have a certain opinion). The distribution of population by those relative distances is time dependent and affected by external (economic, social, marketing, natural) and internal (mean-field influential propagation of opinions, synergy effects, etc.) factors, considered as fields. Specifically, the interaction and opinion-influence field can be generalized to incorporate important elements of Ising-spin based sociophysical models and kinetic-equation ones. The distributions were described by a Schrodinger-type equation in terms of Green's functions. The developed approach has been applied to a real mass-media efficiency problem for a large company and generally demonstrated very good results despite low initial correlations of factors and the target variable.

Social Percolation and the Influence of Mass Media

Social Percolation

Detecting and modelling real percolation and phase transitions of information on social media

Opinion dynamics in social networks under the influence of mass media

A model for cross-cultural reciprocal interactions through mass media

Mass communication, social influence, and consumer behavior: two field experiments

Effects of Mass Media action on the Axelrod Model with Social Influence

A Media Sociology for the Networked Public Sphere: The Hierarchy of Influences Model

Percolation-Based Model of New-Product Diffusion with Macroscopic Feedback Effects

Social Anti-Percolation and Negative Word of Mouth

Influence of media on collective debates

Analysis of flows in social media uncovers a new multi-step model of information spread

The Changing Landscape of Media Communication: An Analysis of the Impact of New Media Marketing on News Consumption and Consumer Behavior

Online Communities and Social Network Structure

Mass media competition and alternative ordering in social dynamics

Indirect Influence in Social Networks As an Induced Percolation Phenomenon

The Production and Consumption of Social Media

The Evolving Landscape of Public Relations: Media Influence and The Power of Social Media Platforms

Mass media destabilizes the cultural homogeneous regime in Axelrod's model

Introduction to statistical physics of media processes: Mediaphysics